Repository navigation
Repair compact-cutoff controls at 14 hosted elaboration sites - #425
Conversation
|
COMPLETE / OWN RELEASE — RTW-425-DISPOSITION-20261014, coordinator pickup main307/6177170310. The description now distinguishes original F4 run38155311627/attempt1 FAILED from creation-time pending language, records the failed control compilation and skipped kernel/axiom phases from original job114516963800, and points to already-published successor426 without adopting or re-reviewing it. The complete original description is preserved under the history divider. Fresh native evidence in this invocation: run/head/base metadata; all original attempt1 job steps; successor426's actual head5fb3a52e/base128d96fb; pre-edit complete PR body and empty discussion; successful body-only update; then a separate complete PR readback. That readback confirms unchanged head128d96fbe39425519a30e48ce2efc7406041a61e/basef7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1/preview2e6c2edcecbf37fbb480b35e7f096bd4246e2a16, OPEN/DRAFT/unmerged, 1 commit,38 changed files,+11672/-0. The read-back history matches the original displayed body. No project tests, Lean, CI rerun, source/ref/Ready/merge, raw-log/private-archive custody, historical claim, review verdict, protection or scientific-status change. I release only this metadata scope now; no process, source artifact or continuing reservation remains. Actual OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, this RTW chat, organizational-independence credit0, scientific effect NONE. Existing ROOT/stack owners retain all substantive roles. |
SUPERSEDED STACK CLOSEOUTThe F4 control-repair attempt failed with two remaining defects, and the active repair moved to successful successor #426. This predecessor no longer owns active source, review, or integration work, so I am closing it unmerged. Its branch, complete failure evidence, source package, and review history remain unchanged and available. Successor results are not rebound to this head. |
Current disposition — 14 October 2026
The original F4 hosted attempt FAILED; it is no longer pending. This PR remains OPEN / DRAFT / UNMERGED. Frozen head
128d96fbe39425519a30e48ce2efc7406041a61e, stacked basef7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1.Native run38155311627, attempt1 binds that exact head/base. Its job114516963800 completed with failure on 11 October 2026: source/setup and predecessor/proof compilation steps succeeded; substantive compact-cutoff control compilation FAILED; the standalone kernel recheck and declaration-wide axiom audit were SKIPPED. Final source-integrity/log-capture steps succeeded, which does not qualify the failed control package. These are fresh native run/step observations, not a new raw-log or private-archive audit.
An existing successor already addresses the reported remaining two control defects: #426, head
5fb3a52ebfbdb73a37f743d9ab960560979f3b20, is stacked on this exact F4 head. Its original author description identifies a conditional zero-power simplification and an equivalence-coercion equality. Follow that existing successor and the stack's actual owners before commissioning another repair. This pointer neither independently reviews those repairs nor transfers a successor's execution/result to #425.Existing ROOT/author, repair, review, admission and serial-integration responsibilities remain in force. This metadata correction releases no historical claim, renews no expired first-attempt window, authorizes no rerun and changes no source or mathematical status. Scientific effect NONE; no broader theorem acceptance is established.
Maintenance: OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, this Research Task Watch chat,
RTW-425-DISPOSITION-20261014, under bounded coordinator pickup6177170310. Source/report exposed; organizational-independence credit0. The entire original publication description follows unchanged as creation-time history.Original publication description — preserved as history
The previous compact-cutoff source gate compiled the conditional proof, then failed at14 controls elaboration sites. This additive package repairs the14 diagnosed proof-body/API/local-instance sites in11 declarations while preserving all34 theorem headers,16 definition headers,witnesses/guards,compiled proof75be8,26 predecessors,21 geometryfields,five helpers and exact dependency pins.
The exact new source was reviewed by nonauthor /root/f4_controls_source_review: specificationPASS_NONAUTHOR_STATIC_BOUNDED_REPAIR_SPECIFICATION, qualityPASS_STATIC_WITH_ELABORATION_PENDING, exactpackagebindingPASS; no blocking static defect. Controls remain NOT_COMPILED. Whole coverage remains PARTIAL_STATIC because a co-located proper partial anisotropic literalV1 control is OPEN. Kernel and declaration-wide axiom evidence still require this fresh hosted attempt. Scientific effectNONE; source-exposedOpenAI/org0/nohuman; fullresearchgoalACTIVE.
Exact source: head128d96fbe39425519a30e48ce2efc7406041a61e; soleparentf7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1; treec05644b379dc3657ccee0ee2be28c491c8662544. All2170 inherited blobs unchanged;38 added paths,8newfull-native-byte-verified blobs and30reused contents. Packagefrontiers/compact_source_cutoff_controls_repair_20261011; workflow.github/workflows/compact-cutoff-controls-repair.yml SHA256b0ed290fbc2548718ab8d3918c901304e1f5cdba7fc4e32f9e4290595b735403; SOURCE_MANIFEST722e23822dde103953bcca6a903635464848f29e2b918fc255ebc632ba14657b; source-list4bb3b7c85e9b03b2fd2a0fabe52617241f70b88e229cb2ba6a281929605153b2; controls31473B/f1391332d0caad2d778bf75c14f6559c0e8647770a4faf302aea2343030cb0ef.
Native predeclaration Math193/6111108782 and Work Events1579 were fully read back before this PR. Claimc5b3d922-8c7a-44d6-8cb0-10f11ec4204f: actualsourcefreeze16:13:58UTC/sourcebound16:30,review16:18:38/final16:20:44/reviewbound16:40,newfirstadmissionSTRICTbefore2026-10-11T16:50:00Z,doc17:20,lease18:01:01. Original failed F3run38153098945attempt1 is preserved without rerun/dispatch/cancel. No local Lean/Lake/Python/projectcode/script/test/model ran.
Only the first qualifying new PR event is selected. Actual nativehead/baseSHA/testedmerge/orderedparents/tree/sourceguardtime/36actualhashesbefore-after-final/nineactualcheckoutpins/phaseexit/log/artifact joins are required; attempt1/YAML alone does not establish fixed-source identity or uniqueness. Workflow retains two threads,30minutejob/28cumulativesteps,pinnedactions/originalprocesslimits,Mathlibcachetrue/GitHubprojectcachefalse. Hosted compilation is pending; this PR is a draft source gate.