Skip to content

Add portable compact-cutoff proof candidate and hosted checks - #415

Closed
d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 1 commit into
codex/compact-cutoff-baseline-20261009-root01a11cbffrom
codex/compact-cutoff-proof-20261010-root01a11cbf
Closed

d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 1 commit into
codex/compact-cutoff-baseline-20261009-root01a11cbffrom
codex/compact-cutoff-proof-20261010-root01a11cbf

Conversation

@d6g8k5htny-coder

@d6g8k5htny-coder d6g8k5htny-coder commented Oct 10, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Current disposition — 14 October 2026

The original F2 hosted attempt FAILED during proof compilation. This PR remains OPEN / DRAFT / UNMERGED. Exact head bb3c92e3226827c9aa1d8746226efaf758e06e2c, stacked base 06bac48e476c825323a74efb7e80cdb5ad9e9bb6.

Fresh native run38077569264, attempt1 and job114287641297 bind the original 10 October execution to this head/base. Source/setup and predecessor-build steps succeeded; first-leaf PROOF compilation FAILED. Control compilation, standalone kernel recheck and declaration-wide axiom audit were SKIPPED. Final integrity and log-retention steps succeeded, which does not qualify the failed proof. This is native execution-state readback, not a rerun, fresh source review or raw-log/private-archive audit.

The original first-attempt window ending 10 October 2026 at 19:20 UTC is historical, not a current execution authorization. An existing separately published proof-repair successor is #424, head f7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1, based on this exact F2 head. Its current disposition separately records successful proof compilation followed by failed controls and links onward to #425. Consult the existing stack and its actual owners rather than repeat an already-published repair. No successor's source, review or execution result is transferred backward to #415.

This description changes no source, conditional endpoint, historical claim, reviewer attribution, admission rule, integration ownership or scientific status. Scientific effect NONE; no theorem acceptance or current-main integration is established. The full original description follows unchanged.

Metadata maintenance: actual OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, this Research Task Watch chat, RTW-415-DISPOSITION-20261014, coordinator pickup6177293910. Source/report exposed; organizational-independence credit0.

Original publication description — preserved as creation-time history

The prior portable compact-cutoff baseline reached the two intended theorem goals in hosted Lean but left both unproved. This PR adds a separate proof candidate for the same 21-field CompactGeometry endpoint and same actual-source witnesses, together with 34 proposed controls and a declaration-wide axiom audit. The original baseline package remains unchanged; all 26 predecessor sources and nine dependency records are retained exactly.

Validation is currently static only. Distinct reviewers checked endpoint parity, proof source, controls, audit guards, complete source hashes and the real parsed workflow. Controls have a partial specification verdict: an explicit anisotropic chart with a non-inner beta value and literal V1 rate at the same point remains unprepared. The existing anisotropic midpoint theorem multiplies values from different points and tests algebraic scaling only. No compilation, kernel, axiom or scientific acceptance is claimed.

A fresh first-attempt PR run against the baseline branch is eligible before 19:20 UTC on 10 October 2026. It records exact source hashes, versions, dependency HEADs and merge parents, then separately builds PushedHeight, proof and controls, checks both new modules with leanchecker, and audits all their declarations. Raw phase exits and failure evidence are retained. Source head bb3c92e, tree 6f7fc3ec9094a81a0b9509762cd46888f1c28a16; predeclared source amendment Math-193/6101007186, actual R17 row 1475, claim a72007c4-60a1-425f-9a74-a1340e963e89. Full landmark goal remains active.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

COMPLETE / OWN RELEASE — RTW-415-DISPOSITION-20261014, coordinator pickup main307/6177293910.

The opening now distinguishes original F2 run38077569264/attempt1 proof-compilation FAILURE from creation-time static-only wording, records controls/kernel/axiom SKIPPED from original job114287641297, marks the 10 October19:20UTC execution window historical, and points to existing successor#424 without transferring its evidence. The entire original three-paragraph description is preserved unchanged.

Fresh native run/head/base and all original attempt1 job steps were read in this invocation; the current PR was reread immediately before the body-only edit. Independent full readback afterward confirms the intended description/history, unchanged headbb3c92e3226827c9aa1d8746226efaf758e06e2c/base06bac48e476c825323a74efb7e80cdb5ad9e9bb6/preview57f14a021d0c2c5c587e5391bf5a015e7dc7bb85; OPEN/DRAFT/unmerged,1commit,38files,+11541/-0.

This finite metadata scope is now released. No project/Lean execution, CI rerun, source/ref/Ready/merge, raw-log/private-archive audit, historical claim release, review verdict, scientific predicate or protection change. No continuing custody or process remains. Actual OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, this RTW chat, source/report exposed, organizational-independence credit0; scientific effect NONE. Existing stack owners retain all substantive decisions.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

SUPERSEDED STACK CLOSEOUT

The original F2 proof attempt failed during compilation and its published repair path moved to #424, then onward through the compact-cutoff successor stack. This predecessor no longer owns active repair or integration work, so I am closing it unmerged.

Its branch, failed run, source package, and artifact history remain intact. No successor evidence is transferred backward and no scientific conclusion is changed.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant