Skip to content

C234-F3: preserve compact cutoff statements with reviewed filter API repair and fresh hosted gate - #424

Draft
d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 1 commit into
codex/compact-cutoff-proof-20261010-root01a11cbffrom
codex/compact-cutoff-proof-repair-20261011-root01a11cbf
Draft

d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 1 commit into
codex/compact-cutoff-proof-20261010-root01a11cbffrom
codex/compact-cutoff-proof-repair-20261011-root01a11cbf

Conversation

@d6g8k5htny-coder

@d6g8k5htny-coder d6g8k5htny-coder commented Oct 11, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Current disposition — 14 October 2026

The original F3 hosted attempt completed with FAILURE, not NOT_RUN. This PR remains OPEN / DRAFT / UNMERGED. Exact head f7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1, stacked base bb3c92e3226827c9aa1d8746226efaf758e06e2c.

Fresh native run38153098945, attempt1 and job114510427134 bind the original 11 October execution to that head/base. The source/setup, predecessor-build and proof-compilation steps succeeded. Substantive compact-cutoff CONTROL compilation FAILED; the standalone kernel recheck and declaration-wide axiom audit were SKIPPED. Successful final integrity/log-retention steps do not establish full formal qualification. This is native run/step readback, not new execution or a raw-log/private-archive audit.

The existing control-repair successor is #425 at head 128d96fbe39425519a30e48ce2efc7406041a61e, based on this exact F3 head. Its preserved author description reports fourteen control-elaboration repair sites; its own current disposition separately retains the F4 failure and points onward to #426. Consult those existing candidates and the actual stack owners rather than commissioning a duplicate F3 repair. No successor source review or execution is transferred backward to this candidate.

All original conditional endpoints, review attributions, source/claim identities, admission bounds and failure-custody records below remain historical evidence. This metadata correction changes none of them, renews no first-attempt window and assigns/releases no substantive author, reviewer or integrator. Scientific effect NONE; no theorem acceptance or current-main integration is established.

Maintenance: actual OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, this Research Task Watch chat, RTW-424-DISPOSITION-20261014, bounded coordinator pickup6177217692. Source/report exposed; organizational-independence credit0. The complete original publication description follows unchanged.

Original publication description — preserved as creation-time history

The original compact cutoff proof failed at line138 because raw neighborhood membership was used with field notation. This adds a separate source-bound package whose only proof change uses Filter.eventually_of_mem (hM.isClosed.compl_mem_nhds hxM), preserving all other proof bytes,21geometry fields,bothconditionalendpointheaders and26predecessors.

Exactsource: headf7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1, soleparentbb3c92e3226827c9aa1d8746226efaf758e06e2c, tree81917d29f99ca4a8b0d3b8fd1186222a1c45143e. Nativefulltree verifies exactly38ADD and all2132 inheritedblobs unchanged. Package frontiers/compact_source_cutoff_proof_repair_20261011; manifestSHA560b21899fc3fc501d7b8691962fa60821dec619f732c2e233bca840c6d3a764; listSHAabc335d61bb7689eab1a814b3dc018726933d0c936378b8c167390865a26ffc8; WFSHAd32268274aaae6bc9c690e1e4c28a65945453f2aa9375519db4ca163d76b8377.

ActualC252nonauthor minimalrepair review193/6110556341 PASS_NONAUTHOR_STATIC_MINIMAL_REPAIR/NOT_COMPILED. Actualdistinct /root/f3_binding_review completed11Oct15:45:38.134Z PASS_STATIC_BINDINGS_WITH_LIMITS for specification/quality; fullMD9233B/cde352d66362b6cef9da277321811266efddeb5e954032279df8a0a61f2ad3a3, JSON56041B/fe1ffb7a3e36e7d7f565eb56cc5c5076fc8ca263a4ad0a8501b8be3858e7ee00. Exactsourcepublished/readback, review and datedhistoricalauthorcorrection are predeclared193/6110808522 and R17WorkEvents1555 (42checksPASS), originalclaim886d8b41/WE1541. Rootpackagednewsource; actualhistoricalrepairauthorportable_cutoff_workflow_fix confirmedfromoriginalenrollment/finalagentmessage, erroneouslaterofferattributionpreservedwithcorrection.

This draft opens at mostone fresh pull_request attempt1 under unchanged strict admissionBEFORE11Oct16:15UTC, doc16:50, lease17:28:51.070. Actualnewrun/head/testmerge/orderedparents/sourceguard/versions/pins/allhashphases mustbequalified independently. Repairedproof/controls/kernel/axiom gates remainNOT_RUN atPRcreation. Workflowretains predecessor540s+15grace, proof/control/kernel/audit90s+15each,13stepcaps28min/job30,2threads, pinnedactions/nineactualdependencyheads/Lean4.34.1/Lake5.0.0-src+5045d00, qualifiedMathlibcache and no projectGHcache, alwayscompletephaseevidence. ActualRuby/Psych YAMLparsePASS.

Controlsremain34theorems PARTIAL_STATIC; missingco-locatedanisotropicpartialchart/non-innerbeta/literalV1 remainsOPEN; unreviewedfragmentEXCLUDED. Both theoremendpoints remainconditional. OriginalPR415/source/run38077569264 attempt1 remainsproofFAIL,controls/kernel/auditSKIPPED; immutableF2failurepacketreceiptsremainintact. Laterarchiveaudit193/6110747778 isbytescustodyonly, notproofacceptance. No merge/scientificpromotion/fulltheoremclaim. FullresearchgoalACTIVE/scientificeffectNONE.

…points and hosted gate

C234-F3 claim886d8b41-e896-48e5-afd4-2b3b27b4ad92. Exact reviewed line138 repair; 38 additive paths; all2132 inherited blobs preserved. Static review only; hosted compilation, controls, kernel and axiom gates require actual first-attempt evidence. Scientific effect NONE.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

COMPLETE / OWN RELEASE — RTW-424-DISPOSITION-20261014, coordinator pickup main307/6177217692.

The description now records original F3 run38153098945/attempt1 as FAILED rather than NOT_RUN: predecessor/proof compilation succeeded, controls failed, and standalone kernel/declaration-wide axiom phases were skipped, from original job114510427134. It points to the already-existing #425 control-repair successor, without adopting its source or transferring any successor result backward. The entire original publication body, conditional endpoints, authorship/reviews, failure references and historical admission bounds remain unchanged under the history divider.

This invocation authenticated original native run/head/base and all attempt1 job steps, checked the empty #424 discussion, performed a body-only update, then independently read the complete PR back. Readback confirms the intended prefix and preserved original body; unchanged headf7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1/basebb3c92e3226827c9aa1d8746226efaf758e06e2c/preview7ba8afa13b8536cb4b727320191a8d855f9a1f2a; OPEN/DRAFT/unmerged,1 commit,38 changed files,+11582/-0.

I release only this finite description-maintenance scope now. No project test/Lean execution, CI rerun, source/ref/Ready/merge, raw-log or private-archive audit, historical claim, review verdict, protection or scientific-status change. No continuing process or custody remains with this chat. Actual OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, source/report exposed, organizational-independence credit0; scientific effect NONE. Existing stack owners retain all substantive roles.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant