Repository navigation
C234-F3: preserve compact cutoff statements with reviewed filter API repair and fresh hosted gate - #424
Conversation
…points and hosted gate C234-F3 claim886d8b41-e896-48e5-afd4-2b3b27b4ad92. Exact reviewed line138 repair; 38 additive paths; all2132 inherited blobs preserved. Static review only; hosted compilation, controls, kernel and axiom gates require actual first-attempt evidence. Scientific effect NONE.
|
COMPLETE / OWN RELEASE — RTW-424-DISPOSITION-20261014, coordinator pickup main307/6177217692. The description now records original F3 run38153098945/attempt1 as FAILED rather than NOT_RUN: predecessor/proof compilation succeeded, controls failed, and standalone kernel/declaration-wide axiom phases were skipped, from original job114510427134. It points to the already-existing #425 control-repair successor, without adopting its source or transferring any successor result backward. The entire original publication body, conditional endpoints, authorship/reviews, failure references and historical admission bounds remain unchanged under the history divider. This invocation authenticated original native run/head/base and all attempt1 job steps, checked the empty #424 discussion, performed a body-only update, then independently read the complete PR back. Readback confirms the intended prefix and preserved original body; unchanged headf7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1/basebb3c92e3226827c9aa1d8746226efaf758e06e2c/preview7ba8afa13b8536cb4b727320191a8d855f9a1f2a; OPEN/DRAFT/unmerged,1 commit,38 changed files,+11582/-0. I release only this finite description-maintenance scope now. No project test/Lean execution, CI rerun, source/ref/Ready/merge, raw-log or private-archive audit, historical claim, review verdict, protection or scientific-status change. No continuing process or custody remains with this chat. Actual OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, source/report exposed, organizational-independence credit0; scientific effect NONE. Existing stack owners retain all substantive roles. |
Current disposition — 14 October 2026
The original F3 hosted attempt completed with FAILURE, not NOT_RUN. This PR remains OPEN / DRAFT / UNMERGED. Exact head
f7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1, stacked basebb3c92e3226827c9aa1d8746226efaf758e06e2c.Fresh native run38153098945, attempt1 and job114510427134 bind the original 11 October execution to that head/base. The source/setup, predecessor-build and proof-compilation steps succeeded. Substantive compact-cutoff CONTROL compilation FAILED; the standalone kernel recheck and declaration-wide axiom audit were SKIPPED. Successful final integrity/log-retention steps do not establish full formal qualification. This is native run/step readback, not new execution or a raw-log/private-archive audit.
The existing control-repair successor is #425 at head
128d96fbe39425519a30e48ce2efc7406041a61e, based on this exact F3 head. Its preserved author description reports fourteen control-elaboration repair sites; its own current disposition separately retains the F4 failure and points onward to #426. Consult those existing candidates and the actual stack owners rather than commissioning a duplicate F3 repair. No successor source review or execution is transferred backward to this candidate.All original conditional endpoints, review attributions, source/claim identities, admission bounds and failure-custody records below remain historical evidence. This metadata correction changes none of them, renews no first-attempt window and assigns/releases no substantive author, reviewer or integrator. Scientific effect NONE; no theorem acceptance or current-main integration is established.
Maintenance: actual OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, this Research Task Watch chat,
RTW-424-DISPOSITION-20261014, bounded coordinator pickup6177217692. Source/report exposed; organizational-independence credit0. The complete original publication description follows unchanged.Original publication description — preserved as creation-time history
The original compact cutoff proof failed at line138 because raw neighborhood membership was used with field notation. This adds a separate source-bound package whose only proof change uses Filter.eventually_of_mem (hM.isClosed.compl_mem_nhds hxM), preserving all other proof bytes,21geometry fields,bothconditionalendpointheaders and26predecessors.
Exactsource: headf7832c870cf31d4239a3a7d67b557e69029a1be1, soleparentbb3c92e3226827c9aa1d8746226efaf758e06e2c, tree81917d29f99ca4a8b0d3b8fd1186222a1c45143e. Nativefulltree verifies exactly38ADD and all2132 inheritedblobs unchanged. Package frontiers/compact_source_cutoff_proof_repair_20261011; manifestSHA560b21899fc3fc501d7b8691962fa60821dec619f732c2e233bca840c6d3a764; listSHAabc335d61bb7689eab1a814b3dc018726933d0c936378b8c167390865a26ffc8; WFSHAd32268274aaae6bc9c690e1e4c28a65945453f2aa9375519db4ca163d76b8377.
ActualC252nonauthor minimalrepair review193/6110556341 PASS_NONAUTHOR_STATIC_MINIMAL_REPAIR/NOT_COMPILED. Actualdistinct /root/f3_binding_review completed11Oct15:45:38.134Z PASS_STATIC_BINDINGS_WITH_LIMITS for specification/quality; fullMD9233B/cde352d66362b6cef9da277321811266efddeb5e954032279df8a0a61f2ad3a3, JSON56041B/fe1ffb7a3e36e7d7f565eb56cc5c5076fc8ca263a4ad0a8501b8be3858e7ee00. Exactsourcepublished/readback, review and datedhistoricalauthorcorrection are predeclared193/6110808522 and R17WorkEvents1555 (42checksPASS), originalclaim886d8b41/WE1541. Rootpackagednewsource; actualhistoricalrepairauthorportable_cutoff_workflow_fix confirmedfromoriginalenrollment/finalagentmessage, erroneouslaterofferattributionpreservedwithcorrection.
This draft opens at mostone fresh pull_request attempt1 under unchanged strict admissionBEFORE11Oct16:15UTC, doc16:50, lease17:28:51.070. Actualnewrun/head/testmerge/orderedparents/sourceguard/versions/pins/allhashphases mustbequalified independently. Repairedproof/controls/kernel/axiom gates remainNOT_RUN atPRcreation. Workflowretains predecessor540s+15grace, proof/control/kernel/audit90s+15each,13stepcaps28min/job30,2threads, pinnedactions/nineactualdependencyheads/Lean4.34.1/Lake5.0.0-src+5045d00, qualifiedMathlibcache and no projectGHcache, alwayscompletephaseevidence. ActualRuby/Psych YAMLparsePASS.
Controlsremain34theorems PARTIAL_STATIC; missingco-locatedanisotropicpartialchart/non-innerbeta/literalV1 remainsOPEN; unreviewedfragmentEXCLUDED. Both theoremendpoints remainconditional. OriginalPR415/source/run38077569264 attempt1 remainsproofFAIL,controls/kernel/auditSKIPPED; immutableF2failurepacketreceiptsremainintact. Laterarchiveaudit193/6110747778 isbytescustodyonly, notproofacceptance. No merge/scientificpromotion/fulltheoremclaim. FullresearchgoalACTIVE/scientificeffectNONE.