berthon_ethics_paper: Nadella workstream set-up (stacked on #849)

submissions/README.md

@@ -18,7 +18,7 @@ This week's work is listed first in [`../NOW.md`](../NOW.md).
 | [`dxd_foundation/`](dxd_foundation/) | Foundations in Human Factors course paper (PHD1750-3 / HF700-1) and the foundation for Decision Experience Design: word separation as the design precedent, the equivalent move for algorithmacy, and the contrast with Nadella's "Models as Insider Risks" post. Researched in three rounds, audited, 251 sources carded; author ruled 2026-10-13; abstract, introduction and outline in the author's Google Doc (snapshot in DRAFT.md) | not recorded |
 | [`phd1750_spaces_in_stream/`](phd1750_spaces_in_stream/) | *Human–Computer Interaction* theory paper: Spaces in the Stream — algorithmacy and the perception of decision spaces in streamed LLM output (the PHD1750 human-factors paper, grown from `dxd_foundation/`). v2 draft with three reviews evaluated (22 Oct 2026); decisions D1–D8 open | not recorded |
 | [`berthon_ethics_course/`](berthon_ethics_course/) | Ethics course paper (Berthon): the ethical failures of the literacy transition and which of them the transition to algorithmacy repeats; built from the design-ethics draft and DXD Part 2 | researched and outlined; eight decisions open; no draft |
-| [`berthon_ethics_paper/`](berthon_ethics_paper/) | The new Berthon ethics paper: every card from the design-ethics, Berthon-course and matched DXD libraries (422), byte-identical copies of the eight earlier versions, and a hand-written concept ledger, conflicts list and consolidation of their ideas | consolidated 2026-10-24; thesis and twelve decisions open; no draft |
+| [`berthon_ethics_paper/`](berthon_ethics_paper/) | The new Berthon ethics paper: every card from the design-ethics, Berthon-course and matched DXD libraries (583), byte-identical copies of the eight earlier versions, and a hand-written concept ledger, conflicts list and consolidation of their ideas | consolidated 2026-10-24; thesis and twelve decisions open; no draft |
 | [`hegel_coordination/`](hegel_coordination/) | Hegel Substack series | no deadline |
 | [`triad_thinkers/`](triad_thinkers/) | Thinkers-on-the-triad Substack companion (post 1: Simmel) | no deadline |
 | [`triadic_reduction/`](triadic_reduction/) | ALGOCON talk: Peirce's reduction thesis, Simmel, Quine, the logicians, the lab's IIT move, and the case for algorithmacy (deck + script); sources ingested | 2026-10-28 |

submissions/berthon_ethics_paper/README.md

@@ -35,12 +35,13 @@ them side by side.
 | `consolidation/CONSOLIDATION.md` | The themed synthesis, hand-written |
 | `consolidation/HEADINGS.md` | All 187 headings of the eight versions, each mapped to ledger rows |
 | `consolidation/COVERAGE.md` | Generated by `coverage_check.py`: hard failures (none) and orphan cards |
-| `literature/cards/` | 422 cards in four subfolders by origin; formats and path rules in `literature/cards/README.md` |
-| `literature/CARD_INDEX.md` | One table over all 422 cards: authors, year, title, DOI, read depth, verification, flags |
-| `literature/DUPLICATES.md` | The 26 works carded in more than one library, with a recommended primary |
+| `literature/cards/` | 583 cards in four subfolders by origin; formats and path rules in `literature/cards/README.md` |
+| `literature/CARD_INDEX.md` | One table over all 583 cards: authors, year, title, DOI, read depth, verification, flags |
+| `literature/DUPLICATES.md` | The 32 works carded in more than one library, with a recommended primary |
 | `literature/NO_CARD.md` | The 76 works DXD Part 2 cites that have no card anywhere, with bib data and every audit row |
 | `literature/dxd_part2/` | DXD Part 2's literature directory (facets A–E, audits, bib), copied whole |
 | `literature/references.bib` | First-wins merge of the Berthon-course and Part 2 bibs (809 entries) |
+| `nadella/` | The workstream on Nadella's X article and the ethics the Spaces paper bracketed: instruction, corpus index, the lab's earlier Nadella research (copied) and its 204 cards; full texts held locally |
 | `PROVENANCE.md` | Every copied file, its origin, origin commit, sha256, and whether it is still identical |
 
 ## How it was made
@@ -67,7 +68,7 @@ the consolidation and conflicts appears in a version, a note or a card.
 
 ## Known gaps (reported, not fixed)
 
-- 130 cards are cited by no ledger row (`COVERAGE.md`). Most are the design-ethics arm's background reading; the rest
+- 291 cards are cited by no ledger row (`COVERAGE.md`). Most are the design-ethics arm's background reading; the rest
   are second copies of works cited through their duplicates.
 - The author's Google Doc "Design Ethics Paper" is his current first draft (46 accepted suggestions and 20 edits of
   2026-10-13) and is not in the repo; `sources/04_AUTHOR_DRAFT.md` is the text as first supplied (CONFLICTS X09).

submissions/berthon_ethics_paper/consolidation/CONFLICTS.md

@@ -24,6 +24,8 @@ the history is for and on which wrong is central: the position (04–07), the bu
 missing promotive design (01), or the missing conditions of learning (02). The working titles follow the theses
 (M08), and Vallor's question (K15) opens only 01.
 
+**Ruled 2026-10-24, by Claude under the author's delegation** (`../nadella/README.md`, Rulings): the merge option, with Nadella's insider post as the central case. Reversible.
+
 **Decision.** Choose one thesis; or merge 04–07 with 08, so that the five positions supply the historical spine
 and the three wrongs supply the present-day reading; or keep them as separate papers. Whatever governs decides
 which of X02–X05 matter.
@@ -203,5 +205,5 @@ These are matters of dating or edition, recorded so they are not lost; none chan
 - Hirschman: the berthon card read the book in part; the design-ethics card holds second-hand quotations, which its
   verifier confirmed against the book (`bec/hirschman1970exit.md`; `ade/hirschman1970.md`).
 
-`../literature/DUPLICATES.md` lists all 26 works carded twice. In the pairs I read (Ong, Hirschman, Selbst and Barocas,
+`../literature/DUPLICATES.md` lists all 32 works carded twice. In the pairs I read (Ong, Hirschman, Selbst and Barocas,
 Oeldorf-Hirsch, Berthon et al.) the cards complement each other and do not disagree on substance.

submissions/berthon_ethics_paper/consolidation/COVERAGE.md

@@ -16,4 +16,4 @@ Most are background the origin arms read and the versions never cited.
 - **algorithmacy_design_ethics**: 118 cards cited in no ledger row — aloisi2024, anannycrawford2018, armer1992, bansal2021, bennlazar2022, burrell2016, burt1992, calacci2022, chalmersgalani2004, chan2023, chen2024, christoffersenwoods2002, collins2003, corti2023, cotterreisdorf2020, cox2016, decerteau1984, dietvorst2015, disalvo2012, dogruel2022, dzindolet2003, eisenstein2002, endsleykiris1995, eu2022dga, eu2022dma, fink2024, floridi2016, floridi2020, floridicowls2019, floridisanders2004, friedman2019, frischmann2018, fukuyama2021, george2016, goody1968, goody1977, goody1986, gran2021, gray2018, green2019, hansman1995, hardt2023, hildebrandt2015, hirsch2017, hoffbashir2015, hutchins1995, ieee2019, ihde1990, inmanribes2019, jacovi2021, jennings2001, johns1998, johnston2018, journal_scan_memo, keller2021, klein2004, kudina2019, lai2023, latour1994, ledantec2009, leesee2004, leveson2011, livingstone2004, logg2019, longmagerko2020, lyons2021, macintyre1981, maes1994, micheli2020, midkiff1993, miller2019, miller2023, mittelstadt2016, mosier1998, muir1994, nissenbaum2010, norman1990, obstfeld2005, pangrazio2019, parasuraman2000, pritchett1994, rahwan2018, redaelli2022, rosenbergerverbeek2015, rudin2019, rule2019, russ2015, sae2021j3016, sarterwoods1995, schmidtsimone1996, selbstbarocas2018, shan2023glaze, shan2024nightshade, sigg2025, skitka1999, spiekermann2022, suchman1994, suchman1995, sunstein2021, taddeo2010, triadic_hf_search_notes, tsamados2022, vandepoel2013, vasconcelos2023, verbeek2008, verbeek2008b, verbeek2014, verbeek2015, verbeek2020, wachter2018, weiser1991, wellner2024, wilkinson1965, williams2018, winfield2021, winner1993, winograd1994, winogradflores1986
 - **algorithmacy_scaffolding**: 1 cards cited in no ledger row — rosenblatstark2016
 - **berthon_ethics_course**: 9 cards cited in no ledger row — amershi2019guidelines, connell2016not, flory2004interventions, kaminski2019right, kitzinger2024openai, lund2026explainable, rohlfing2021explanation, statute1677frauds, stollery1976statute
-- **dxd_foundation**: 2 cards cited in no ledger row — bainbridge1983ironies, vasconcelos2023explanations
+- **dxd_foundation**: 163 cards cited in no ledger row — alahmadi2022false, ancker2017effects, anderson1972computer, anthropic2026how, apple2026guidelines, bai2008reading, bainbridge1983ironies, baker2025monitoring, balogh1927voces, barton1980awareness, bassetti2012effects, becker2024conquering, biggs2020decoding, boretius1883capitularia, buijsman2020numerals, buncic2017factors, cameron2022expanding, caperton2009massey, cert2022common, cftc2017fxcm, chan2024visibility, chan2025infrastructure, chantavarin2025effects, charlemagne1900letter, chen2021tradeoff, chen2025reasoning, chen2026comparing, clanchy1993from, clemens2025korea, colvin2011empirical, constantin2026nadella, cressy1980literacy, crootof2023humans, cui2023eye, dacosta2018tabulae, danna2022numerical, de1972betrvg, degno2019coregistration, dionysius1910composition, douek2023meta, doyle2025assessment, dummler1881alcuini, duzan2026chain, elish2019moral, eu2019p2b, eu2022dsa, eu2024platform, eu2024regulation, evans2018forex, fca2014fines, frey2026correlational, fsb2014foreign, fsb2015progress, galanter1974why, galliussi2020inter, garrett1998saenger, gema2026chain, globalfxc2024code, green2022flaws, greenblatt2024ai, grundemclaughlin2026overseeing, haines2008origins, hakvoort2017improvements, hangeulmuseum, hao2024training, heilmann2020reading, hendrickson1929ancient, hervais2019learning, houpt2014new, ivanova2026process, jakkal2026secure, jhaver2019suspect, jia2026faithfulness, jordan2024reicher, kasisopa2016child, kellogg2020algorithms, ker2012johnson, klonick2018new, kohsom1997adding, kokotajlo2025ai, korbak2025chain, krieber2017eye, kroll2021outlining, kubota2024rethinking, kumari2026nadella, kutas2011thirty, kutasov2025shade, langer2024effective, lanham2023measuring, larkin1987why, laubrock2015eyevoice, laux2024institutionalised, layman2023controlled, leinenger2014phonological, li2014reading, little2026length, lynch2025agentic, mannering2012johnson, margono1987study, mathews1976eldridge, matzinger2021influence, mirault2019precise, mitchell2026agents, nadella2025looking, nadella2026frontier, nadella2026models, nadella2026reverse, nagarajrao2026fareshare, nothaft2020satanic, nydfs2015barclays, nydfs2015barclayspr, odonnell1994parkes, odonnell2000saenger, oomen2016last, oversight2022q1, ozkan2026wordinitial, palka2025foreign, park2025dokkyo, perea2012subtle, perea2015colours, price2011interactive, quintilian1920institutio, reis2011johnson, rfc8890, rieder2020towards, rose2020zero, ryan2014historical, saltzer1975protection, sangster2024emergence, sangster2025reboot, santonidesio2018meaningful, schlimm2008modeling, scribner1981psychology, seattle2024deactivation, seymour2003foundation, sterz2024quest, stohl2016managing, strunk1998guido, suzor2016responsibilities, suzor2018digital, thrax1874grammar, torrensalvarez2022latin, tumey1927ohio, tunbridge1992study, turan2026oversight, turpin2023language, tyler1988what, us2072usc, us2073usc, us455usc, us9usc10, vandenboer2015default, vasconcelos2023explanations, wagemans2012century, wang2024tibetan, wang2026monitorbench, wertli2023influence, westwell2018dissemination, winskel2009eye, wong2022meta, yu2023altered, yu2026habituation, ziegler2010orthographic