Repository navigation
console(record header): a url action placed at record_header on sys_user no longer renders in the 18.3 Console header menu, drawer or full page (18.2 rendered it) #29951
Description
triage#1 · os-zhuang · session_01AavokzJ5DndAwitDXvKy4U
Ruled: 6624172200 · letter A · 2026-11-04T06:22Z · amended by 6624212682 (no 18.3.x patch; the release note is written with the release that carries A) · 2026-11-04T06:24Z
Ruling-ref: 6624172200, 6624212682
Filing gate ①: a reproduced regression in 18.3.0, split out of #29946 by triage. The #29946 report names it as a second, separate defect ("a url action at record_header on sys_user … no longer renders in the 18.3 console's header menu, in the drawer or on the full page. 18.2 rendered it."). Its evidence is in the objectstack-ai/duly 18.3 browser check (duly-18.3-browser-check/REPORT.md, R1), from duly#185. ⛔ Not a claim.
Reader: domain:ui, the record-page header action menu (ui/packages/app-shell).
What happens
- Metadata: a
type: 'url'action whoselocationsincluderecord_header, onsys_user(the duly app's member page), is served in the metadata on 18.3.0. - 18.3.0 Console: it is absent from the record header's menu, in the drawer and on the full page.
- 18.2.0 Console: it rendered.
Wanted
- Measure first. Reproduce on
mainwith a packagedurlaction atrecord_headeronsys_user, and on a non-system object as the CONTROL. Name the commit that dropped it. - The header menu then renders a served
record_headerurlaction again, wherever 18.2 rendered it. - Pin: the action appears in the header menu on the drawer and on the full page. The pin is red on the dropped commit's parent behaviour.
Graded p1: a shipped regression, for a patch release.
Links: #29946 (the server half from the same report), duly#185.
Activity
objectstack-fleet commentedon Nov 3, 2026
domain:ui#1 · os-support-ai · session_01WGufzjDyeFwq6AuFu3vwTd
Claim: PM loop round 2 · 2026-11-03T17:12Z
Session:
session_01WGufzh8VRbTbBnqwnrXsSL(card thread; dispatching seatsession_01WGufzjDyeFwq6AuFu3vwTd)Account:
os-support-aiBranch:
claude/project-thread-4y2o5l(platform-assigned to the card thread; it can push only this branch)Worktree:
objectstack-issue-29951Domain:
domain:uiSeat:
domain:ui#1File surface:
ui/packages/app-shell/src/views/record-header action paths (DeclaredActionsBar.tsx,RecordDetailView.tsx,recordApprovalActions.ts) and/orui/packages/components/src/renderers/action/action-bar.tsx, their tests, one root.changeset/file (stop on breach; explain in the report)Container & model:
M,mode:thread,model: TIER_DEFAULT(dispatch-gates --tier: no path-derived mandate),effort: xhighClause-②: no
Metadata-protocol: none
Responsibility: suspected ui regression between 18.2.0 and 18.3.0 (
domain:ui), unless measured to be the server half (#29946) | no platform path covers it | every Console user opening asys_userrecord whose app declares arecord_headerurlaction (duly#185)Thread-read: none
Premise: unmeasured at claim; the order makes the dev reproduce on
origin/main6a4737abfirst and stop on no-repro or a server-side cause (#29946)Serial constraints cleared: none (#29897 is in
views/metadata-admin/ResourceEditPage.tsx; #29947 and #29949 touchdata-objectstackandpreview/DraftChangesPanel.tsx)Order:
/mnt/project-files/ui-orders/29951.md· maintainer scope 「车队可以继续派发了，只派发 p1 p2 ，总并发不超过 20」 (2026-11-03T15:40Z)objectstack-fleet commentedon Nov 3, 2026
domain:ui#1 · os-support-ai · session_01WGufzjDyeFwq6AuFu3vwTd
待维护者裁决 · #29951 · 2026-11-03T17:45Z
一句话： 18.3 里
sys_user记录页不再显示其他包加到记录头的动作，不是前端过滤造成的，而是 #27219 把平台的sys_user_detail改成了kind: 'full'页面并写死了 11 个动作 id；按现行契约「作者列出的列表就是全集」，别的包后加的动作一律不画。修它就要动这条契约，所以停下来请你裁。Governing text:
packages/spec/src/ui/component.zod.ts:683、:704（PageHeaderProps.actions：「An authored list is the whole set … omitting the key draws none of the object's actions」），出自 #11592 的裁决（「全部同意」选项 B）。实测（dev 读数全文：
/mnt/project-files/ui-orders/29951-findings.md；dev 报告评论随后贴本卡）：6a4737ab实机启动：sys_user上一个record_header的url动作确实由服务端下发（GET /api/v1/meta/object/sys_user里有），但整页和抽屉的头部与 ⋯ 菜单都没有；同样的动作放在showcase_account上（对照）两处都显示。6dbff8e20a（feat(spec,ui)!: retire the record page's slots.tabs; a page that needs its own strip is kind: 'full' #27219，2026-10-28）。之前sys_user_detail是slotted，头部由合成器实时读对象的全部记录头动作；之后是full+ 固定 id 列表。sys_organization_detail、sys_approval_request_detail同样被冻结。slots.tabs已退役），这一点任何方案都不能回退。选项
page:header上加一个显式开关：「画出绑定对象所有放在record_header/record_more的动作，实时读取」；三个平台页改用它。作者写的 id 列表仍然是全集，#11592 的含义不变。Metadata-protocol: added，minor）+ ui 读取 + platform-objects 三页 + approvals，各自的钉子sys_user_detail改回slotted。slots.tabs已退役，不可行PageSchema.apps，#29631）。四维分析
sys_user上加了 url 动作，18.2 显示、18.3 消失，真实部署在用。A、B 恢复它；D 让每个这样的应用多写一个页面才行。sys_user上加了动作、os validate通过，界面却静默不画，正是「声明而未兑现」。os-decision-facets
① 项目长远合理性：A 缩小特例——「作者列表 = 全集」不变，只多一个显式开关；B 让列表含义随动作来源包而变，扩大隐含规则；D 把平台页的限制推给每个应用。
② 实际业务拉动：今天就有人撞上——duly 应用（duly#185）在
sys_user加的 url 动作 18.2 显示、18.3 消失，属发版回归。③ 防 AI 犯错：A 是可校验的显式声明（id 列表或开关二选一）；D 让 AI 加的动作通过
os validate却静默不画，最易犯错；B 的来源规则 AI 难以推断。④ 创业阶段不扩散：A 新增一个永久键，但有实测拉动；D 不增键但保留静默丢弃；B 改面最大。
Prior rulings read: page:header,record_header,whole set → 0 hits; none; thread: #11592; repo: objectstack-ai/objectstack
席位推荐：A。 若 18.3.x 补丁不能带 minor：18.3.x 先发 D 的发布说明一行（明说已知限制和临时做法），A 进下一个 minor。A 涉及新 spec 键，裁定后按契约先行由 spec 车道起 spec 半边，本卡的 dev 线程（分支
claude/project-thread-4y2o5l）等裁决，可接 ui 与平台页半边。需要你做的： 在 A / B / D 中选一个（以及 18.3.x 是否先发 D 的说明）。
objectstack-fleet commentedon Nov 3, 2026
domain:ui#1 · os-support-ai · session_01WGufzh8VRbTbBnqwnrXsSL
os-dev-report
Stamp: 2026-11-03T17:48Z
{ "issue": 29951, "status": "needs_decision", "branch": "claude/project-thread-4y2o5l", "pr": null, "session": "session_01WGufzh8VRbTbBnqwnrXsSL", "premise_still_valid": true, "summary": "Reproduced on main 6a4737ab. A url action placed at record_header on sys_user by another package is served in GET /meta/object/sys_user but is drawn neither in the header row nor in its overflow menu, in the drawer or on the full page; the same action on showcase_account (CONTROL) is drawn in both. Cause is not a ui filter: 6dbff8e20a (#27219, Fixes #27053) rebuilt the platform page sys_user_detail from kind slotted (synthesized header, which reads the object's placed actions live) to kind full with a page:header naming the 11 platform action ids, and under the ruled page:header.actions contract (#11592, an authored list is the whole set) any action another package adds to sys_user is dropped. Same freeze on sys_organization_detail (4 ids) and sys_approval_request_detail (no ids). What #27219 was for, and must keep: the page owns its curated tab strip after slots.tabs retired. PM mechanism assumption falsified: no sys_ or url-type branch exists in the ui; the renderer follows the spec contract. Every fix touches that contract (a static page cannot name actions other packages add later), so this stops at a decision (os-dev, when to stop): options A to D are in the open question; the seat's analysis is comment 6611296943.", "tests": "No code change, so no pin and no ablation. Live: full pnpm build under os-verify-lock (VERDICT command-exit 0, 119/119 tasks), showcase backend pnpm dev --fresh on its own port, Console from ui src via vite with DEV_PROXY_TARGET. A writable package com.qa.hdr stores hdr_user_profile (url, record_header, objectName sys_user) and hdr_account_profile (url, record_header, objectName showcase_account). Served: /meta/object/sys_user lists hdr_user_profile; /meta/page/sys_user_detail is kind full and its header ids are ban_user, unban_user, unlock_user, set_user_password, impersonate_user, set_user_manager, update_my_profile, change_my_password, change_my_email, resend_verification_email, delete_my_account. Playwright readings: sys_user full page row = Update Profile, Ban User, Set Password, Edit, More actions; its menu = Refresh, Impersonate User, Set Manager, Change Password, Change Email, Add to favorites, Share, Delete My Account (QA User Profile absent). sys_user drawer: same row; menu = Impersonate User, Set Manager, Change Password, Change Email, Add to favorites, Share, Open as full page, Delete My Account (absent). showcase_account full page and drawer: row = QA Account Profile, Edit, More actions (present). Unit probe (throwaway, deleted): RecordDetailView with a sys_user def holding ban_user plus a url action at record_header draws Ban User, Edit only under a kind full default page naming ban_user, and Ban User, Open Profile, Edit with no page (the synthesized header the 18.2 slotted page drew); CONTROL non-system object with no page draws Open Profile. Page history: at 6dbff8e20a parent (and at 18.2.0 27f38ada) sys_user_detail is kind slotted with no page:header; at 6dbff8e20a it is kind full with the id list.", "gates": "NOT MEASURED: no diff, so no derived gate set and no changeset.", "dogfood_battery": "n/a: no PR.", "mcp_calls": "6, all reads: issue_read get 29951, issue_read get_comments 29951, issue_read get 29946, list_commits (RecordDetailView path), get_commit 27f38ada, list_commits (sys-user.page path). No MCP writes.", "api_writes": "1: this comment via post-stamped.mjs (POST issues/29951/comments).", "open_questions": [ { "question": "How does a kind full platform record page draw header actions that other packages place on its object?", "options": [ "A: additive page:header opt-in that draws every action of the bound object placed at record_header or record_more, in declaration order, read live; sys_user_detail, sys_organization_detail and sys_approval_request_detail use it instead of their frozen lists; an authored id list keeps meaning the whole set. Cost: one spec key, Metadata-protocol added, minor bump of the fixed group (not a patch); spec-key ripples, the ui reader in PageHeaderActions, three pages and their pins. Size M across spec, ui, platform-objects, plugin-approvals.", "B: amend the contract text, no key: an authored list is the whole set of the page package's own actions, and actions another package places on the object follow it. Needs served provenance: a stored action carries _packageId (measured), a code package's folded action carries objectName only (measured on showcase_task; a cross-package code action not measured), so a server stamp too. Changes every authored page; semantic change to a ruled contract. Size M to L across server, spec, ui.", "C (rejected): make sys_user_detail slotted again; the tabs slot is retired, so the curated strip #27219 kept would be lost.", "D: no code; declare the 18.3 behaviour and teach that a package adding a header action to a platform object ships an app-scoped record page (PageSchema.apps, #29631) naming it. Docs, skills and a release-notes line; the regression against 18.2 stays." ], "recommendation": "A, because it restores the 18.2 behaviour on the platform pages, keeps the strip #27219 was for and the #11592 meaning of an authored list, and is an explicit opt-in. If a patch release cannot carry a minor, D's release-notes line in 18.3.x and A in the next minor." } ], "security_findings": "none", "out_of_scope_findings": [ "carrier: this card's ruling covers the same freeze on sys_organization_detail and sys_approval_request_detail · noted, not filed" ] }Generated by Claude Code
os-support-ai commentedon Nov 4, 2026
decision thread · os-support-ai · session_01WGufzepGFmf3XtoZaZuheq
Ruling: decision thread "Discuss pending spec rulings" · letter A, plus a 18.3.x release-notes line · maintainer 「以上同意」 2026-11-04T06:22:07Z
The maintainer was presented the seat's "待维护者裁决" above (6611296943) in the project thread with A recommended, and the attached question whether 18.3.x first ships D's release-notes line with A in the next minor (recommended yes). They answered 「以上同意」 = the recommendation on every item presented, so this card's letter is A, with the release-notes line.
What the ruling binds (letter A):
@objectstack/specadds one explicit opt-in onpage:header: draw every action of the bound object placed atrecord_header/record_more, read live, in place of an authored id list. The authoredactionslist keeps itsPageHeaderProps.actionsdeclaresz.array(z.string())but objectui's canonicalpage:headerrenderer consumes ActionDef objects — satisfying the schema deletes every header button #11592 meaning (an authored list is the whole set); the new key is the other, explicit way to say "all placed actions". Spelling and exclusivity withactionsare the spec seat's call, named in the PR for the maintainer.sys_user_detail,sys_organization_detail,sys_approval_request_detail) switch to the opt-in, so an action another package places onsys_useris drawn again in the header menu, the drawer and the full page; feat(spec,ui)!: retire the record page's slots.tabs; a page that needs its own strip is kind: 'full' #27219's tab bar is kept.Metadata-protocol: added·@objectstack/specminor. Spec half first (domain:spec), then the ui reader and the platform-objects / approvals pages (domain:ui, the card thread onclaude/project-thread-4y2o5l), with the card's pin (the action appears in the header menu on the drawer and on the full page; red on the frozen page without the opt-in).PageSchema.apps, fix(console): open the record page scoped to the current app (PageSchema.apps) #29631). A lands in the next minor.slotted, undoes feat(spec,ui)!: retire the record page's slots.tabs; a page that needs its own strip is kind: 'full' #27219), D alone (regression kept).Workload of the letter: M as the seat sized it: one spec key + ui read + three platform pages + approvals, each with its pin; plus one release-notes line in 18.3.x.
Execution: the ui seat that filed the question dispatches the release-notes line now and the ui half after the spec half, with
Ruling-ref:naming this comment; the spec half is filed todomain:specciting this comment. Theneeds-user-decision→ working-state stroke is the ui seat's. TheRuled:body line is written by this act.Generated by Claude Code
os-support-ai commentedon Nov 4, 2026
decision thread · os-support-ai · session_01WGufzepGFmf3XtoZaZuheq
Ruling amendment: letter A stands; the 18.3.x release-notes line is withdrawn · maintainer 「18.3.x 不发」「等后续发版的时候再写说明」 2026-11-04T06:24Z
This amends ruling 6624172200 on one point only. The maintainer's words, verbatim: 「18.3.x 不发」 and 「等后续发版的时候再写说明」. So:
page:header, the three platform pages switched to it, spec half first then the ui half,Metadata-protocol: added, spec minor.The body's
Ruled:line is updated by this act to name both comments.Generated by Claude Code
objectstack-fleet commentedon Nov 4, 2026
domain:ui#1 · os-support-ai · session_01WGufzjDyeFwq6AuFu3vwTd
Blocked-by: #30018
Ruled 6624172200 (letter A) with the maintainer's amendment (「18.3.x 不发」「等后续发版的时候再写说明」, 2026-11-04T06:24Z): nothing ships in 18.3.x for this card, and the release note goes with the release that carries A. State:
needs-user-decision→pm:blockedin this stroke. The spec half is filed as #30018 (domain:spec, p1,Ruling-ref: 6624172200). The ui half (the reader plus the three platform pagessys_user_detail,sys_organization_detailandsys_approval_request_detail, with the card's pin) stays with this seat and the card thread onclaude/project-thread-4y2o5l, under Claim 6610580796. It is re-dispatched when #30018's PR merges. Assignee kept.