Skip to content

chore(html-kit): close T21 + T25 + D01, add 18_ debate trigger spec - #21

Merged
nyashkn merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
chore/board-t21-t25-d01
Jun 9, 2026
Merged

nyashkn merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
chore/board-t21-t25-d01

Conversation

@nyashkn

@nyashkn nyashkn commented Jun 9, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

  • T21 (telemetry stack decision) — blocked → done. Laminar chosen; modules shipped via B1/B2.
  • T25 (multi-agent debate orchestration) — trigger spec landed at `.html-kit/18_t25-debate-trigger-spec.md`. Card stays in `next` pending implementation claim.
  • T24 (agent-as-judge + Harbor) — unblocked: D01 shipped via B1, semantic gradient now meaningful.
  • D01 (score.py semantic hardening) — discovered → done. Pointer flipped to `eval/README.md`.

T25 trigger spec — 5 OR-composed primitives

ID Condition Tuning hook
TR1 Score < 0.7 `T25_SCORE_FLOOR`
TR2 ≥2 critic claims with HIGH/CRIT severity `T25_CRITIC_THRESHOLD`
TR3 3-run rolling Δ<0.05 AND latest <0.85 `T25_STAGNATION_*`
TR4 Cite-graph contradiction (T29 refutes edge on cited claim) none
TR5 `--debate` flag or `T25_FORCE_DEBATE=1` env override

Asymmetric cost bias: false-positive ~5x cheaper than false-negative (single-pass ships a bad claim into RL signal).

Test plan

  • Render `.html-kit/00_index.html` — verify card 18 appears.
  • Open `.html-kit/16_session-backlog-board.html` — verify T21 and D01 in Done column, T24 in Next-up column, T25 still in Next-up with new link.
  • Read `.html-kit/18_t25-debate-trigger-spec.md` end-to-end for technical consistency.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Board moves (16_session-backlog-board.html):
- T21 (telemetry stack decision) — blocked → done. Laminar chosen (self-host
  gRPC on lan.ds.ke, cloud fallback). omp session parser + back-emit helpers
  shipped via insight-kit B1/B2.
- T25 (multi-agent debate orch) — trigger spec landed; card points at
  18_t25-debate-trigger-spec.md. Stays in `next` for implementation claim.
- T24 (agent-as-judge + Harbor) — blocked → next. D01 (score gate semantic
  hardening) shipped via B1, unblocking the Harbor RL signal coupling.
- D01 (score.py semantic hardening) — discovered → done. Pointer flipped to
  eval/README.md §score.

New: 18_t25-debate-trigger-spec.md
- 5 OR-composed primitives: score floor <0.7, critic-severity cluster
  (≥2 HIGH/CRIT), 3-run stagnation (Δ<0.05 & score<0.85), cite-graph
  contradiction via T29 supports/refutes edges, manual --debate override.
- Asymmetric cost bias: false-positive (debate on easy run, ~5x) cheaper
  than false-negative (single-pass ships a bad claim into RL signal).
- Env tuning hooks: T25_SCORE_FLOOR, T25_CRITIC_THRESHOLD,
  T25_STAGNATION_{WINDOW,DELTA,CEILING}, T25_FORCE_DEBATE.
- Forward-pointer to insight_kit.platform.orchestration.debate (not yet
  implemented).

Index (00_index.html): card 18 added under cards 16-17.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@nyashkn
nyashkn merged commit ed28b78 into main Jun 9, 2026
1 check passed
@nyashkn
nyashkn deleted the chore/board-t21-t25-d01 branch June 9, 2026 01:34
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant