Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -861,6 +861,33 @@ full encoding and its delta encoding separately so transport reuse cannot hide
a semantic regression. Controller/executor separation is a later independent
comparison and cannot explain away a C1 regression.

### Default adoption and retirement qualification

The [context-delivery guide](../../guides/context-delivery.md#qualify-default-adoption-and-retirement)
turns this comparison into an operator plan. Documentation may ship first;
future broader default adoption needs both a declared DeepSeek model and a declared
strong model to support the claimed effectiveness and complete-cost scope.
The reference's existing Codex-scoped default remains current behavior, not proof
that these model comparisons have passed.
Record exact model/provider/version/effort and fixed task, source, host, tools,
feedback, evaluator, budget and stops. Include actual final input/output,
cached/uncached tokens, requests, detail/recovery reads, wall/IO/setup costs and
human attention, alongside task-native outcomes, constraint misses, wrong
actions and once-only recovery. Unknown cost is not zero; preserve repeated-run
variation, failures and negative cases. Historical-best optimization keeps that
native ranking, with final-retention facts separate. A Codex-scoped adapter
cannot qualify a DeepSeek host.

Keep this sequence in C1/C2/C9: explanation → both-model comparison → supported
profile's reversible adoption/release → scoped default → named old-path
retirement. Mixed or regressed results retain opt-in or explicit limitations.
Retirement requires actual caller replacement, historical decoding/readback,
supported-version and rollback coverage; full snapshots, digest checks,
authority/identity/stops and recovery remain. Do not preserve two permanent
semantic owners or delete a still-supported reader based on new-path existence.
This is a qualification plan, not new experiment authority, a claim of shipped
benefit, or a gate on other independent authorized work.

The [packaged source comparison](ledger/controller-executor-unified-contract-v0/2026-10-29-packaged-source-comparison.md)
pins mainline quota and the C1 candidate through real File/SQLite CLI delivery,
file deltas, capture refusal/recovery and once-only settlement. Source fidelity
Expand Down
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -645,6 +645,23 @@ C1 的主要对照是**同一单会话产品路径中的原 quota packet 与融
传输复用掩盖语义退步。Controller/executor 分离是之后独立的对照,不能用来解释或
抵消 C1 回归。

### 默认采用与退役资格

[上下文交付指南](../../guides/context-delivery.zh-CN.md#默认化与退役的验收) 把此比较落实为
操作方案。文档可先交付;未来扩大默认采用范围需要明确版本的 DeepSeek 与强模型分别支持
所声明的效果和完整成本范围。reference 已有的 Codex 范围默认仍是当前行为,不证明
这些模型对照已通过。记录精确 model/provider/version/effort,固定 task、source、host、
tools、反馈、evaluator、预算与停止条件。除原生任务成果、约束遗漏、错误动作和
一次性恢复外,计入实际最终 input/output、cached/uncached tokens、请求、详情/恢复
补读、墙钟/IO/搭建成本与人工注意力。未知成本不记零,保留重复波动、失败与负例。
历史最佳优化保持原生排名,终态保留事实另列。仅 Codex adapter 不资格化 DeepSeek 宿主。

顺序留在 C1/C2/C9:解释 → 双模型比较 → 受支持 profile 的可回退采用/发布 → 范围化
默认 → 点名旧路径退役。结果混合或退步时保留 opt-in 或明确限制。退役须核实际 caller
替换、历史解码/readback、支持版本与回退覆盖;完整快照、摘要校验、权限/身份/停止
和恢复继续保留。不长期保留两个同义决策 owner,也不因新路径存在就删除仍受支持的
reader。这是资格方案,不授予新实验权限,不宣称已交付收益,也不阻塞其他独立获授权工作。

[打包来源对照](ledger/controller-executor-unified-contract-v0/2026-10-29-packaged-source-comparison.zh-CN.md)
固定 mainline quota 与 C1 候选版本,经真实 File/SQLite CLI 验证交付、文件差分、
capture 拒绝/恢复及一次结算。本负载来源保真改善,冷态和观察器累计输出字节增加。
Expand Down
13 changes: 13 additions & 0 deletions docs/architecture/rfcs/loopx-overall-roadmap-v0.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -218,6 +218,19 @@ larger cold/output bytes and an open standalone numeric hash boundary. Preserve
that counterevidence and the original outcome/full-cost gate; a working saved-file
delta or once-only receipt does not establish long-horizon benefit.

The [context-delivery guide](../../guides/context-delivery.md) explains current
behavior and a minimum two-model comparison. Deliver documentation first;
within C1/C2/C9, qualify a declared DeepSeek model and a declared strong model
against the original quota path under matched conditions and complete costs.
Then qualify reversible adoption and release of a supported profile before a
broader default recommendation. The reference's existing Codex-scoped default
remains current behavior, not proof of model benefit. Mixed or regressed model results retain scoped opt-in
or explicit limitations. Retire only named replaced producers/consumers after
actual migration, historical-reader compatibility and rollback evidence; keep
full snapshots, integrity, authority, identity, stops and recovery. A guide,
Codex-only adapter or shorter output does not pass the model/default gate.
This sequence neither blocks independent authorized work nor starts experiments.

Use that RFC’s C1–C9 task/deletion map within the existing work streams: first
qualify unified single-session inputs, then role binding and shared lifecycle,
replan/result authoring, executor exchange, benchmark reuse, packaged App
Expand Down
9 changes: 9 additions & 0 deletions docs/architecture/rfcs/loopx-overall-roadmap-v0.zh-CN.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -167,6 +167,15 @@ C1 的[消费链切换表](controller-executor-unified-contract-v0.zh-CN.md#c1-
以及尚开放的独立数值 hash 边界。保留这些反证和原成果/完整成本门;文件差分或一次
结算回执可用,不证明长程收益。

[上下文交付指南](../../guides/context-delivery.zh-CN.md) 解释当前行为和最小双模型对照。
文档先交付;在 C1/C2/C9 内,用明确版本的 DeepSeek 与强模型,分别对照原 quota 路径,
固定可比条件并计入完整成本。随后验收受支持 profile 的可回退采用与发布,再决定默认
范围扩展建议;reference 已有的 Codex 范围默认仍是当前行为,不证明模型收益。
结果混合或某模型退步时,保留范围化 opt-in 或明确限制。退役须点名已替换的
producer/consumer,以实际迁移、历史 reader 兼容和回退证据为依据;保留完整快照、
完整性、权限、身份、停止与恢复。指南、仅 Codex adapter 或更短输出不通过模型/默认
门。此顺序不阻塞独立获授权工作,也不启动实验。

把该 RFC 的 C1–C9 任务/删除表放在既有工作流内:先验收统一单会话输入,再做角色绑定
与共享生命周期、replan/结果编写、executor 交流、benchmark 复用、打包 App readback
及退役。App heartbeat 流程和实际 benchmark 消费者分别验收;managed Codex 可以作为
Expand Down
2 changes: 2 additions & 0 deletions docs/guides/README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -6,6 +6,8 @@ Guides are task-oriented paths for people starting or operating LoopX.
- [Installing LoopX](installing-loopx.md)
- [Newcomer command path](newcomer-command-path.md)
- [Codex App 自动续跑体验指南](codex-app-autonomous-goal-experience.md)
- [Understand, use and evaluate context delivery](context-delivery.md)
- [理解、使用和验收上下文交付](context-delivery.zh-CN.md)
- [Minimal custom runtime example](minimal-custom-runtime-example.md)
- [Minimal custom runtime example (中文)](minimal-custom-runtime-example.zh-CN.md)
- [Custom Agent runner integration](custom-agent-runner-integration.md)
Expand Down
Loading
Loading