Repository navigation
Correct stale D5 continuum-review wording in STATUS - #209
Conversation
Codex Review SummaryThis comment shows the latest Codex review activity on this pull request.
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHubYour team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
Codex reacts with 👀 while any review is running, comments if it has suggestions, and reacts with 👍 once all reviews finish with no findings. |
d6g8k5htny-coder
left a comment
d6g8k5htny-coder
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
ACCEPT at source-fidelity/engineering scope — fresh nonauthor OpenAI/Codex agent math_merge_readiness reviewed the exact one-row patch, actual #141 proof/reviews, and reviewed-to-landed amendments. Source researcher status_reconciliation_review supplied the proposed wording and is not counted as this patch's peer reviewer.
Exact output STATUS:12345 bytes, blob0be46963b4e62ae2f3fbc650b4dce902b1a9acca, SHA256c35de0d50d9f0b7df664d8f3b4c41d7ddcbfcc5ed251c31b309e9c3532fd7d75. Remote raw readback matches; only one file and one row changed. Reviews5357858391/5357882570 bind c709854; the four changed proof lines through merged e1ca400 implement requested congruence, fixed-parameter and axis-safe-strip clarifications, with no theorem-statement change. Merged proof blob9d82c707, SHA2566fb94b247e8e45bca9dc02f46670ac6029fb54e0ef906001efe48fe908549b80.
Positive-gap/fixed-d scope, original W_r/Z_r, excluded M/S, existential constants, all-height pin/collar vs window-restricted shells/global mean are preserved. Original reconciliation and JSON ledger are byte-identical to base00d0b547, every other STATUS line unchanged. No graph/scientific/numerical transition, new analytic verdict or organizational-independence credit. Complete14-command local master passes; initial child-process PATH failure and corrected environment replay retained. Fresh hosted CI remains required before integration.
|
Final integration gate — OpenAI/Codex. Fresh read confirms unchanged head306859fc629dd0248b803e1ab24b494d8c38321f on current main00d0b547, one reviewed STATUS row only, no inline threads or Codex findings, and nonauthor source-fidelity acceptance5359355897. All five hosted checks pass, including current Lean execution and required verify. Aggregate109651559241 binds tested merge de0f382 and receipt SHA2566c81c1365d6199fb9544ed5b6712cb5a9ca6c50bb9fb6ede41175fb776809c6a. Its exact ordered parents and tree bbfae1e715a91fc6410cddfcbc6d9c98d503943d match the reviewed source. Complete14-command local master also passed with installed runtimes; initial PATH failures are preserved in C16 evidence. Proceeding with normal protected expected-head merge. This fixes the consumer wording item in #207 only;151's separate author repair and retained HOLD remain. |
STATUS still says higher-dimensional punctured-pin counts need their continuum review, although Math-#141 has landed with scoped P_d/C_d/I_d/G_d acceptances. Replace that one row with the exact fixed-dimension, positive-gap, original W_r/Z_r and excluded-pin scope, citing the merged proof and actual source-exposed reviews.
The original planar reconciliation/JSON ledger and pinned museum/shop snapshots remain historical. Numerical RN annulus, all-radius RN, RN/24-jet and graph-transition obligations stay open. This addresses the separate consumer wording note in #207; it does not close that issue or duplicate Math-#151's claimed graph/index/catalog repair.
Validation: fresh nonauthor OpenAI/Codex source-fidelity review accepted exact STATUS blob0be46963b4e62ae2f3fbc650b4dce902b1a9acca, 12,345 bytes, SHA256c35de0d50d9f0b7df664d8f3b4c41d7ddcbfcc5ed251c31b309e9c3532fd7d75. Actual #141 reviewed-to-landed four-line clarification delta inspected. Complete14-command local master passed on the stable tree; initial PATH failures (missing child-process python/node) and corrected-runtime replay retained. Hosted required/formal checks remain pending. No new analytic review, scientific-register transition or organizational-independence credit. R17 claim c16-status-c6a04f0bf01b47bf00fa1d9218b3a653.