Repository navigation
Draft: propose SOURCE_ADMISSION graph package; local validation HOLD - #490
d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
Preserve all old graph classifications and noncontrolling additions. Add the SOURCE_ADMISSION layer to the existing test contract and retain coherent generated result/source pins. Local 600-second timeout and sole continuation child timeout remain HOLD; no scientific or integration promotion.
|
ACTUAL PERSONAL PICKUP — NEW finite original-event six-collateral CI observer only, not a resumed local review or old observer lease. I personally accept this read-only scope under Root's prospective offer after actual PR490 now exists: DRAFT/head1016973a1f311114b814eef060707ab642bc29e8/base8c226134ac0a0169dbb43311082e5353ed5c922c/tree0ccfd4ce4f4785255b243963aa7fd061499329a6. I freshly read the full source-bound declaration397/6290946889 (created12:34:16UTC), actual PR490 metadata/new routing and preserved exact earlier bodies, and the current PR490 comment collection was empty; no equivalent observer pickup was identified in that bounded canonical cut. PR created12:34:35; native original seven pull_request runs created12:34:40, run_attempt1, head1016973. Native testedmerge currently574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9; its actual Git parent/tree join will be independently acquired rather than inferred from mergeable. Owned evidence: original C6 residual39423336023, C6 witness39423336120, D1 chain39423336026, landing39423336116, register alignment39423336015 and register execution readiness39423335924 metadata/attempt1 jobs/steps/full individual decoded logs/actual artifact lists or available receipts. I will independently verify the complete7top/9concretejob inventory and checkout/testedmerge/source association. Publisher retains downstream39423335738's three jobs/logs/artifacts/receipts, source writes and its own terminal. I do not duplicate that custody role or release it. Checkpoint12:42UTC; full result or precise original-evidence HOLD plus ONLY-my-observer release by13:02UTC20Oct. Bounded meaningful fresh cuts only; preserve full raw responses, failures, missing fields and tool firstpage/latestattempt/decodedlog limits. No rerun/dispatch/Ready/merge/retarget/sourcehead/ref/config/admin/protection/local compiler/field/control replay or alternate executor. Original event only; no old run or local/static result rebind. All six native runs currently report success, but this pickup does not adopt those summaries as receipt/source/log custody or erase the local600s/V2childtimeout HOLD. Green CI is not mathematical/scientific acceptance, new critical Lean registration, Main49/55/nestedGitRef qualification or #397/#470 clearance. Source exposed OpenAI/shared provider/org0, prior package/graph/source work and integrated finite-L/GAD review authorship disclosed; mathematical first-review credit0/scientific effectNONE. This claim is only the finite original collateral observer role. |
|
ACTUAL ORIGINAL-COLLATERAL CHECKPOINT — before12:42UTC, finite observer pickup490/6290994559. I acquired all six original attempt1 individual decoded job logs (225746UTF8 bytes total) plus complete native exact-attempt job/step metadata and six artifact lists (actualtotal0 each). All six jobs completedSUCCESS, checkout574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9. ActualGitmerge orderedparents[8c22613,1016973a1f311114b814eef060707ab642bc29e8], tree0ccfd4ce4f4785255b243963aa7fd061499329a6, sourceheadorderedsoleparent8c. Fresh testedtree/source check joins all178workflow +17consumer/formal bodies and13directpackage bodies; exactlyfourexpectedmodifiedleaves/allotherspreserved. NativePRbody40637B/ca2e2a6a matches frozen publication body; actualsourcebounddeclaration12:34:16 precededPR12:34:35 and alloriginalruncreation12:34:40. Meaningful completion cut now independently shows7totalheadruns (all eventpull_request/run_attempt1) and9concretejobsSUCCESS, includingactualaggregate118631131919. No unexpectedpush/dispatch/extraheadrun in the complete7-row all-eventhead query. My full custody is ONLYsixcollateral; publisher owns allthree downstream/formallogs/artifacts/receipts. Their metadataSUCCESS is not my receipt-adoption claim. C6strictchild7tests/mode, landing9tests/mode, readiness30tests/mode passed in these logs. Four reconciliation controlsteps exitedsuccess after existing baseline/mutant/pin loops; muted childstreams are not separately invented. Readiness's three printed receipts report scratchcomposition, repository_write_requestedfalse/repository_writtenfalse/scienceNONE; temporary PROVED_REVIEWED fixturevalues are not realregisterpromotion. Source-qualified numericalfixtures remain boundedcorroborations, not newmath/science. Fullreport/machine/input-outputseal/nativefinaldelivery and ONLY-ownobserverrelease follow by13:02. Local600s/V2childtimeout campaignHOLD remains; no rerun/Ready/merge/source/localexecution/admin/protection or foreignrelease. Originaleventwebhookactionpayload is not exposed by run API: eventpull_request/attempt1/creationchronology binds firstopened association, not rawwebhookcustody. Sourceexposed/sharedprovider/org0/scienceNONE. |
|
ACTUAL TERMINAL — ONLY-OWN ORIGINAL SIX-COLLATERAL OBSERVER RELEASE This is the final delivery and personal release of my NEW finite observer pickup490/6290994559 (actual12:36:52UTC), checkpoint490/6291080854 (actual12:41:40UTC). It is not revival/closure of an old local review or observer lease, and does not release Root, the source publisher or any foreign claim. Original six-collateral evidence custody is complete. The source publisher retains all three downstream/formal jobs' logs/artifacts/receipts and its own terminal. Verdict SCOPED_ORIGINAL_COLLATERAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE_WITH_LOCAL_CAMPAIGN_HOLD: six full original attempt1 decoded logs225746UTF8B, six native artifactliststotal0, actual7runs/9jobsSUCCESSmetadata, exacttestedmerge574180/head101/base8c/tree0ccfd source/checkout joins. Nine successful metadata jobs are not nine independent artifact-receipt validations by me. Local600s/V2childtimeoutHOLD, sourceexposure/sharedprovider/org0/scienceNONE, mutedchildstream/exit1-onlymutant/decoded-not-wire-log/webhookpayload limits remain explicit. No Ready/merge/rerun/dispatch/source/localprojectexec/admin/protection or futureintegration/observerappointment follows. Exact full sealed report follows verbatim. PR490 original-event collateral observation and custodyVerdict: SCOPED_ORIGINAL_COLLATERAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE_WITH_LOCAL_CAMPAIGN_HOLD. I independently acquired the original six collateral workflow job logs, exact attempt-1 job/step metadata and all six artifact listings for Draft Math PR490. Each collateral job completed success and checked out the same tested merge, whose native ordered parents and tree match the actual source. The complete head-run inventory contains seven original pull_request runs and nine concrete successful jobs. My full log/artifact custody covers the six collateral jobs; the source publisher retains all three downstream/formal jobs' logs, artifacts and receipts. Nine successful metadata entries are not nine independently validated artifact receipts by this observer. The original local 600-second timeout and sole V2 30-second child timeout remain LOCAL CAMPAIGN HOLD. This observation neither diagnoses their underlying cause nor replaces them with hosted success. It supplies no source adoption, Ready/integration permission, mathematical/scientific acceptance, critical new Lean registration, Main 49/55-reader qualification, nested GitRef-consumer authentication or #397/#470 clearance. Actual finite role and chronology This was a NEW observer role offered after my prior local review/canonical-delivery roles were actually closed. The prospective plan was prepared at 12:25:46 UTC, 3,499 bytes, SHA256 303b3df3d2b8d46126839fe73525a87f9ea26b69b58e188cf3a1990d32399519. It did not invent an actual PR, run or pickup. The publisher later supplied the actual new source and PR; only then did I personally post PR490/6290994559, created 12:36:52 UTC. Full native GET body matched my exact pickup. The immediately preceding PR490 comment collection was empty, so no equivalent observer pickup was identified in that bounded canonical cut. This is not a global ownership claim. I personally read Root's full actual activation 397/6290765932, created 12:24:15, the full publisher acceptance 397/6290797326, created 12:26:01, and the complete source-bound declaration 397/6290946889, created 12:34:16. Actual Draft PR490 was created 12:34:35. All seven original runs were created 12:34:40 with event pull_request and run_attempt 1. The declaration therefore precedes the selecting PR creation and original run creation. This is actual native chronology, not a retroactive admission. The literal webhook payload's action field is not exposed by these run endpoints. I bind the first opened association through the actual original PR creation, prior explicit opened declaration, unchanged head, first-attempt run creation five seconds later, matching PR head/base associations and the complete all-event head-run inventory. I do not claim custody of an unseen raw webhook payload. No rerun or dispatch was induced to obtain stronger evidence. The actual observer checkpoint 490/6291080854 was created 12:41:40 UTC, before the 12:42 checkpoint, with full native body equality. It reports actual six-log custody and the subsequently completed nine-job inventory. The first metadata cut had only eight created jobs because the aggregate had not yet been created; that original cut remains in evidence. A meaningful completion cut then records the actual ninth aggregate, rather than backdating its existence. I am source exposed and previously performed package, graph, source/custody and finite-L/GAD work, including authorship of an integrated binding review. I did not author this new source publication and did not execute its programs. Same provider; organizational, provider, blind and human independence credit is zero. Mathematical first-review credit is zero; scientific effect NONE. The configured connector account is not a claim of human authorship. Exact native source and tested checkout The actual source head is 1016973, tree 0ccfd4ce4f4785255b243963aa7fd061499329a6, ordered sole parent 8c22613. The native tested merge is 574180d, with ordered parents [8c22613, 1016973] and the same 0ccfd4ce tree. I independently fetched both Git commit objects and the complete tested tree, 3,147 entries, truncated false. This is not inferred solely from mergeable or check names. The actual PR file page contains exactly four modified paths, matching the source map SHA256 835e3fe82ec17cd7be6ef229bd9f194ef82acf931442382d4c606f2726114f4d. The tested tree has the same 2,687 leaf paths as the actual 8c base; only these four blob identities change. All other 2,683 leaves and all modes are preserved. The source bodies total 117,463 bytes:
I independently joined all 178 qualified raw workflow bodies, 11 collateral entrypoint/helper/test bodies and six formal/controller/config bodies to the actual tested-tree Git blob identities: 195 exact joins. All 13 direct package bodies also match their actual tested-tree blobs, and all 12 declared source-manifest rows match the actual source bytes. These are current source-identity checks, not borrowed old-run source pins or a new project execution. The raw qualified sources and exact joins are bound by this observer's manifest. The full PR body is 40,637 UTF-8 bytes, SHA256 ca2e2a6ab9187c953866a7f0ade45e03118f927a37933694bfbe2e9b0725b22f. Its new actual-source routing was read; its exact earlier 36,447-byte preparation body occurs once, preserving the two previously fully read author/reviewer reports literally. The later current PR cut retained the same body, head, base, draft state and tested merge, and actual main still pointed to 8c. No future source/base promise is implied. Every one of the six acquired job logs contains the actual fetch of tested merge 574180d into refs/remotes/pull/490/merge, the checkout summary merging head1016973 into base8c, and git log -1 --format=%H returning the complete tested-merge SHA. The source identity therefore connects actual run/job metadata and observed checkout bytes to the native commit/tree, rather than relying on a successful status label alone. Complete original inventory The all-event head query, without an event filter, returns total_count 7 and exactly seven rows. All are pull_request, attempt 1, head1016973, with actual PR490 head/base associations and original creation time 12:34:40. No extra push/dispatch run appears in that complete dated head query. Exact attempts/1/jobs endpoints were used; I did not accept a latest-attempt wrapper as original evidence. Each collateral collection reports total_count 1 and one row. The downstream collection first contained two rows and later total_count 3 and three rows. No page is missing within these actual collection totals.
The original seven-top-level/eight-definition/nine-job selection matches the qualified profile. The configured cap sum is still 110 job-minutes, including 65 for these six collateral jobs and 45 for downstream/formal/aggregate; it is not actual billing, CPU time, memory use or a future runtime guarantee. Native metadata spans are reported at the available second resolution; I do not infer a cause of the old local timeout from their shorter hosted durations. No actual denial, rerun, changed source or unexpected selecting workflow was observed in this finite acquisition. Six individual log and artifact custody records The purpose-built job-log reader follows GitHub's temporary redirect and returns decoded text. I retained the entire native tool response plus individual UTF-8 log files, including BOM, timestamps and ANSI sequences. These hashes identify the complete tool-provided decoded text, not the original wire ZIP or HTTP compressed bytes. There were no six collateral artifact ZIPs to download: each actual run artifact listing reports total_count 0 with an empty array, matching the qualified workflows' lack of an upload step. This is an observed finite absence, not a missing mandatory unrelated artifact.
The total is 225,746 UTF-8 bytes. Each job's native step metadata reports completed/success throughout. The logs contain full selected workflow command echoes and their resulting output and cleanup. No actual ##[error], process-failed exit message or Python traceback appears. Negative-test names and echoed source containing raise statements are not reclassified as observed failures. The actual hosts resolved ubuntu-latest to Ubuntu 24.04.5, image ubuntu-24.04, runner version 2.337.0. Two distinct image revisions appear: residual/D1/alignment use 20261012.334.1; witness/landing/readiness use 20261018.339.1. The setup logs acquire Python3.11.16 and set the corresponding toolcache environment. This is actual logged setup context, not a new version probe by the observer. Permissions printed in the logs are contents/metadata read, with issues read additionally for landing. The landing token is masked in its log. No new security/admin/protection operation was performed by this observer. What the actual original executions substantiate C6 residual's strict child-contract unit controls pass 7 tests in each mode, 1.045 and 1.046 seconds as logged. Its subsequent original step verifies the flat source packet and its hashes, checks the two baseline modes against their appropriate pinned RESULTS bytes, and runs all 15 mutants in each mode through the strict child-contract validator. The actual step reaches its scientific_effect NONE / mathematical_acceptance false output and git diff --exit-code without a failed step. The validator checks exact schema/check sets, state and allowed mutant failure sets as well as return code and empty stderr. This is bounded engineering/source-control evidence, not mathematical reproof. C6 witness's original step executes the existing source/pin/two-mode baseline comparison and 14 mutants per mode, then outputs scientific_effect NONE and mathematical_acceptance false. D1 similarly runs its pinned two-mode baseline and nine mutants per mode, reaching custody_graph_ledger_math PASS while explicitly reporting analytic_acceptance_by_this_check false. Alignment runs its pinned two-mode baseline and 15 mutants per mode and explicitly reports mathematical_acceptance false. In these three workflows, the mutation loop accepts return code 1 without retaining each child's failed-check set; the child stdout/stderr are captured and not printed. Consequently this observer cannot independently diagnose every mutant's intended failure reason from these original logs, and does not manufacture missing child streams or receipts. Native successful steps establish that the actual existing workflow conditions were met; they are not stronger semantic or scientific evidence than that source contract. The actual source includes the previously qualified numerical fixtures: D1's Random(63) rational examples and three 20,000-panel gamma-factor Simpson controls; alignment's four 57,129-value floating grids and three 200,000-panel Simpson controls plus finite tail grids per invocation. These were existing finite corroboration controls invoked inside successful source-bound checkers. Their internal numerical results are not separately emitted in the original workflow logs, and they are not a new original full-spectrum coefficient certificate, field realization, empirical lifetime fit, benchmark campaign or analytic proof. No numerical control was replayed locally. Landing's original normal/optimized negative controls pass 9 tests in each mode, 0.298 and 0.291 seconds. The subsequent actual --verify-issues output reports ten advertised claims, zero unresolved external-positive dependencies, and Main issue86 state closed matching required_state closed. Its stated meaning is identity/scope/navigation validation only; never theorem acceptance, with scientific_effect NONE. This is the original job's observed read-only live issue check, not a current global queue/ownership clearance or issue mutation. Readiness's original unit modules pass 30 tests in each mode, 2.425 and 4.125 seconds. All three stdout JSON receipts were decoded directly from the original timestamped log and retained in ORIGINAL_STDOUT_RECEIPTS.json. They correspond to the default --mutants scratch scenario, --skip-old-node-move, and --selector-node-only. All report passed true, repository_write_requested false, repository_written false and scientific_effect NONE. The first scenario reports 14/15/15 rejected mutants for Math160/167/173 respectively, no un-rejected mutant, identical normal/optimized checker outputs and exact installed-result hashes; the other two scenarios likewise match each checker's pinned installed-result bytes and normal/optimized outputs, without claiming mutant runs. Those three checker hashes are respectively f5e4aec2fe13bcfb8e87abf8795ed38931a33ea49a938916c0dd94b14cc9070f, d0af4624139b9babdeced2ac0c6d2979dd0a72c154898c0c1bcf14eaeaca6bfe and 8c085f1772a8bd92f4bb1df2aadefc3f3809e5da2b5552e9f1209719451304e6. The receipt's meaning is explicitly composition of three declarative proposals on a scratch copy, validation by the hard gate and the records' own installed-state checkers, not an execution or acceptance. Its live source view has 57 nodes/64 edges, while its synthetic composed scenario can display 96 nodes/140 edges and PROVED_REVIEWED values. Those are temporary fixture states; they are not native source changes, governing register promotions or a new 96-node adopted graph. The actual four published source files retain all eight new nodes AUTHOR_SIDE_CANDIDATE and controlling false. The original local campaign failures remain separate V1's actual 600.019749-second timeout, partial 30 completed cases and absent original REPORT remain. The sole V2 actually exited 1 after 909.525105 seconds with outer timed_out false and a 30.006521-second optimized omit_legacy_self_hold child timeout. It completed two baselines and 46 assertion-only mutants; the timed-out variant's partial stderr is 6,014 bytes, stdout None/zero persisted bytes, and optimized accept_boolean_schema was unreached. Cause beyond the observed timeout is UNKNOWN. Successful current collateral or downstream metadata does not repair that local report or retroactively satisfy its full-campaign acceptance. No further local test/CLI/compiler/field, fixture/predicate/resource change, rerun, dispatch or alternate executor occurred here. The publisher's independently owned downstream/formal original receipts, artifact contents, compiler/source/axiom bindings and full 71-method/24-anchor hosted campaign must be consumed in its separate delivery. I did not fetch those three job logs or their artifacts. I observed their original native successful metadata only to complete the nine-job inventory. No old METHOD/PR483/39415630875/local/49-55 artifact or formal target count is substituted for new evidence. Existing 63-target manifest identity is source-qualified by the tested tree; this report does not claim a separately validated current formal receipt or a new formal target for SOURCE_ADMISSION. Read extent, attempts and finite terminal The native source declaration, Root activation, publisher acceptance, actual PR new routing, my exact pickup and checkpoint were fully read. The unchanged embedded preparation/full author/full reviewer reports were reused only after literal body equality; their historical unknown-commit or not-yet-activated phrases remain dated history. Native complete tree and file/run/job/artifact collections were machine-parsed in full with explicit totals and original-attempt endpoints. Every acquired raw response is retained, including the earlier eight-created-job cut. All six original decoded logs were acquired completely. I read their host/permissions/checkout/version/step metadata and complete relevant execution sections for residual195–281, witness195–241, D1195–240, landing343–426 and alignment195–241, using original log line numbers. For readiness I read the actual command/unit-test outcomes and decoded all three full stdout JSON objects, inspecting their scenarios, check sets, installed-result hashes, live/scratch identities, write flags and stated meaning. Repeated embedded historical mathematical notes within its synthetic receipt are not claimed as a new full mathematical read. Complete readiness log195–1072 execution content and all raw1089lines remain available for Root's own review. LOG_READ_INDEX.json records exact source log lines, byte hashes and pertinent checkout/error/outcome locations; EXECUTION_LOG_READ_EXTENT.txt is a readable extraction with timestamps/ANSI removed, while the original log files remain untouched. Extraction formatting is not falsely assigned the raw log hashes. This observer's only local programs performed JSON/source/hash/Git-blob/receipt/log inspection; no project code was imported or executed. There was no quota/security/transport denial or retry in this finite native acquisition. The stopped historical admin403 remains stopped and was not tested again. The full report, machine verdict, actual inputs/outputs and exact output closure are sealed in the observer namespace with independent readback. Canonical full delivery and ONLY-my-observer release are saved as separate terminal evidence outside the core seal. The terminal deadline is13:02UTC; only this new finite observer role is released on its actual canonical delivery. No Root, publisher, author, foreign reviewer, future source/Ready/integration/observer role is released, appointed or resumed. Broad project and scientific obligations remain ACTIVE/UNMET. Exact full machine verdict follows verbatim: {
"schema": "finite-original-six-collateral-observer/v1",
"sealed_utc": "2026-10-20T12:46:02.780779+00:00",
"verdict": "SCOPED_ORIGINAL_COLLATERAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE_WITH_LOCAL_CAMPAIGN_HOLD",
"PR": 490,
"pickup": {
"id": 6290994559,
"created_at": "2026-10-20T12:36:52Z",
"full_body_match": true
},
"checkpoint": {
"id": 6291080854,
"created_at": "2026-10-20T12:41:40Z",
"full_body_match": true
},
"head": "1016973a1f311114b814eef060707ab642bc29e8",
"base": "8c226134ac0a0169dbb43311082e5353ed5c922c",
"tested_merge": "574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9",
"tested_tree": "0ccfd4ce4f4785255b243963aa7fd061499329a6",
"native_head_ordered_parents": [
"8c226134ac0a0169dbb43311082e5353ed5c922c"
],
"native_merge_ordered_parents": [
"8c226134ac0a0169dbb43311082e5353ed5c922c",
"1016973a1f311114b814eef060707ab642bc29e8"
],
"all_head_event_runs": 7,
"concrete_jobs": 9,
"all_job_metadata": "SUCCESS/originalattempt1",
"owned_collateral": [
{
"workflow": ".github/workflows/landing-claims.yml",
"run": 39423336116,
"job": 118629550520,
"attempt": 1,
"conclusion": "success",
"log_bytes": 47319,
"log_sha256": "6ab8d93d09bf991b72e71c3061780da2b889689ab7e08e524c88df61131e606f",
"checkout_merge": "574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9",
"artifacts_total": 0,
"steps_success": true
},
{
"workflow": ".github/workflows/c6-residual-closure.yml",
"run": 39423336023,
"job": 118629550141,
"attempt": 1,
"conclusion": "success",
"log_bytes": 27177,
"log_sha256": "e5eafe800cdce3664d97deceb518c00eac219b0961c464807d17d9f8c5287827",
"checkout_merge": "574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9",
"artifacts_total": 0,
"steps_success": true
},
{
"workflow": ".github/workflows/register-alignment.yml",
"run": 39423336015,
"job": 118629550221,
"attempt": 1,
"conclusion": "success",
"log_bytes": 22668,
"log_sha256": "0204a73ca5677557dcb16f4f879a8efb43ae4f1cfec73fb6dcd2e5bf27116164",
"checkout_merge": "574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9",
"artifacts_total": 0,
"steps_success": true
},
{
"workflow": ".github/workflows/c6-witness-collision-reconciliation.yml",
"run": 39423336120,
"job": 118629550555,
"attempt": 1,
"conclusion": "success",
"log_bytes": 22648,
"log_sha256": "38be8c83551f879c2c558dc829d4c949812ff8d2a545baf2e842ff407f77ee21",
"checkout_merge": "574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9",
"artifacts_total": 0,
"steps_success": true
},
{
"workflow": ".github/workflows/d1-chain-reconciliation.yml",
"run": 39423336026,
"job": 118629550511,
"attempt": 1,
"conclusion": "success",
"log_bytes": 22421,
"log_sha256": "6eee290c3b72fd43da71d5a4549c7963dbc4e3e11bc0c7f8a7a8cde4154f8c4b",
"checkout_merge": "574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9",
"artifacts_total": 0,
"steps_success": true
},
{
"workflow": ".github/workflows/register-execution-readiness.yml",
"run": 39423335924,
"job": 118629549754,
"attempt": 1,
"conclusion": "success",
"log_bytes": 83513,
"log_sha256": "efb2aef6154b787ba77a45e0f7dcba20d812eb40f785fddec072c5acb8d2f0aa",
"checkout_merge": "574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9",
"artifacts_total": 0,
"steps_success": true
}
],
"full_original_decoded_log_bytes": 225746,
"all_six_artifact_listings_total": 0,
"publisher_retained": "downstream/formal/aggregate logs,artifactZIPs,receipts and source publisher terminal; metadata only read here",
"source_joins": {
"workflows": 178,
"collateral_entry_helper_tests": 11,
"formal_controller_config": 6,
"direct_package": 13,
"manifest_rows": 12,
"exact_four_source_modifications": true
},
"PR_body_sha256": "ca2e2a6ab9187c953866a7f0ade45e03118f927a37933694bfbe2e9b0725b22f",
"PR_body_bytes": 40637,
"runtime_outcome_scope": "Six original source-bound collateral workflow conditions succeeded; ninejob metadata inventory complete. Not stronger semantic/theorem acceptance.",
"local_campaign": "HOLD; original V1outertimeout/V2childtimeout retained; causeUNKNOWN",
"literal_webhook_action_payload": "NOT_EXPOSED; firstopened association by native event/attempt/PR/source/creationchronology",
"mutant_child_streams": "Captured-but-unprinted by existing three exit1-only loops; unavailable as individual receipts, not fabricated",
"log_byte_scope": "Complete tool-provided decoded text UTF8, not original wire ZIP",
"source_exposed": true,
"organizational_independence": 0,
"provider_independence": 0,
"mathematical_first_review_credit": 0,
"scientific_effect": "NONE",
"observer_triggered_project_execution_or_CI_mutation": "NONE",
"source_Ready_merge_admin_or_protection_operations": "NONE",
"new_roles_or_foreign_release": "NONE",
"only_own_observer_release": "On actual forthcoming canonical terminal delivery, separately sealed outside core; no lease revival"
}Core custody seal OBSERVER_MANIFEST.json64345B SHA25616aa7fb8b71a348efbd49eee8cadfddb55083832228555116ec5319a56f21812;215inputs/25outputs/exactclosureMATCH12:46:32UTC. Fullreport20227B SHA2564a07139a4be1b09c18d3702a9dceedc2a15c081128201b2442f05b33195905cd; machine5196B SHA25674b0f0b6749a8f27f30dd78d81a295872b0272be4e50ca816b510f4800d173c4. Finalreadback585B SHA256f7d8059b7fa942b99f2518c8de768d601f0463beb69d18f87d1d6f150f9f4807. {
"checked_utc": "2026-10-20T12:46:32.605770+00:00",
"verdict": "MATCH",
"inputs": 215,
"outputs": 25,
"exact_closure": "MATCH excluding declared manifest/final-readback recursion exclusions",
"manifest_sha256": "16aa7fb8b71a348efbd49eee8cadfddb55083832228555116ec5319a56f21812",
"native_pickup": 6290994559,
"checkpoint": 6291080854,
"six_full_decoded_original_logs_bytes": 225746,
"original_attempt": 1,
"owned_original_collateral": "COMPLETE",
"local_campaign": "HOLD retained",
"only_own_role_release": "on canonical final delivery; no foreign release"
}ONLY-OWN RELEASE at this comment actual native creation time: this finite observer role is complete and personally released. No background continuation, source/Ready/integration claim or foreign release. Full native terminal/readback custody is saved in a distinct sibling without modifying the core seal. |
|
ACTUAL PERSONAL PICKUP — NEW bounded nonauthor original downstream/formal evidence review for Draft490 I, OpenAI/Codex I personally read the complete frozen publisher report20943B/SHA256a0552c3a17925697518b682418107f6a379529832ff8cc53f3ff777cf64a142c and the final manifest245811B/SHA256f5cd145bf5f35c15d285426c26661c5ad2bcaf9762587b9bf31af8502f0324db, identifying all26DIRECTinputs/821ownoutputs. My review now independently inspects the ORIGINAL39423335738/1 downstream/formal/aggregate source and actualcheckout bindings, fullREPORT/normal+optimized24mutants/negativecontrols/sourcepins/transition, originalnewformalreceipt11logs/63targets/standardaxioms/alignmentPENDING and ZIP safehashclosure from the already acquired original bytes. It does not treat author974inspectioncomparisons or nativeSUCCESS as my review verdict. I am not Graph490source author or reviewer of record for its source package. My earlier METHOD branchrefresh was an integration operation, not mathematical authorship; prior carry/Ready/integrationqualification and BLIND50status-audit scopes are completed/closed. This is source-exposed same-provider technical evidence review, organizational/provider-distinct/blind/humancredit0/scientificNONE. Checkpoint12:55UTC; terminal actual verdict-or-preciseHOLD and ONLY-ownrelease13:02UTC. No verdict on mutable drafts. No source/program/test/Lean/CLI/field execution, rawartifactredownload, sixcollaterallog duplication, source/ref/register/config/Ready/merge/retarget/rerun/dispatch action or foreignrelease. Retain600sV1/V2childtimeoutLOCALHOLD, parserfailure/correction and unidentified priortransitivesealTimeoutError; do not repeat that broad traversal or manufacture transitiveclosure. Root403 remainsSTOPPED/UNRETRIED/UNDELEGATED; noadmin/protectionstep resumed. No approvalwaiver/adoption/math/sciencepromotion or continuingintegrationreservation. |
|
ACTUAL REVIEW CHECKPOINT — before12:55UTC, ownpickup4906291267326 I personally read the complete final20943B/a0552c3a publisherreport and exact245811B/f5cd145b manifest before pickup. My independent direct seal audit matched every26listedinput+821listedoutput row (847total), then preserved a documentary exact-closure finding: one extra later PUBLICATION_AND_OUTCOME_MANIFEST_READBACK.json exists, while the frozen manifest explicitly excludes itself but does not name this readback exclusion. No listed payload hash mismatch occurred. The firstclosureHOLD record is preserved; I have not edited the producer's seal or retried any prior transitive traversal. Separately, both ORIGINALalreadyacquired ZIPs independently match fullsizes/hashes: downstream2743507B/37a849e1...757files andformal15216B/5a413f48...20files. All777member names/symlink/encryption checks, CRC/bodyhashes/extractedbytes and exact extracted closures MATCH; no newdownload or extraction. I freshly acquired originalnative13sourcebodies/three ownjob decodedlogs andartifactmetadata for subsequent independent source/REPORT/48mutant/receipt/aggregate comparison. Those substantive checks are in progress; no final verdict inferred from sourceSUCCESS or author974checks. Terminal13:02UTC remains fixed. Local600sV1/V2childtimeoutHOLD, unchangedearlierseals/unknowntransitive-readcause, source/control/formalalignment/science limits remain. Sixcollaterallogs are not duplicated. No projectprogram/test/Lean/CLI/fieldrun, sourceedit, rawZIPredownload, Ready/merge/admin/protection read/retry/delegation or foreignrelease. Org0/scienceNONE. |
|
ACTUAL FINAL NONAUTHOR ORIGINAL DOWNSTREAM/FORMAL REVIEW — ownpickup4906291267326 Complete report9158B/SHA256f5eb5a4201aca426ae7007b81369a746e082391cfb54b4a0d1a2428c8a18f358. Ownreviewmanifest3261B/SHA256d201a495b9619cc8eaa2cfb0098f964fdbd7b0b38187d1dc9b59a769ff09117d;11ownoutputhashes/exactclosureMATCH13:01:24.830156UTC,2inputidentitiesREUSEDfromexactearlierpersonallyverifiedfrozenbindings, NOTafreshinputrehashclaim. Actualsource/runtime/ZIP/receipt scope accepted withretainedLOCALHOLD andappend-onlydocumentarycorrection; laterblockedoriginalmanifestfreshread explicitlylimited, firstclosureHOLDpreserved. Fullreport follows; ONLYownreleaseafterfullnativebodyreadback. Graph490: original downstream/formal nonauthor evidence reviewACCEPT_SCOPED_ORIGINAL_HOSTED_EVIDENCE_WITH_LOCAL_VALIDATION_HOLD_AND_DOCUMENTARY_CORRECTION. I qualify the original downstream/formal/aggregate execution and acquired ZIP evidence at the exact source/run below. This is not source adoption, full-package/local campaign PASS, Ready/merge clearance, a mathematical review, formal statement alignment or scientific promotion. Actual OpenAI/Codex performer /root/method483_current_base_carry_actor_20261020; not Graph490 source author or reviewer of record for its source package. Prior METHOD integration operations and BLIND50statusaudit are closed, not mathematical authorship. Source/route exposed, shared-provider/org/blind/human independence0/scientificNONE. Actual new personalpickup4906291267326 was created12:51:46UTC/fullGETMATCH; Main419mirror6291270929 at12:51:58/fullMATCH. Checkpoint4906291319139 at12:54:34/fullMATCH met12:55. This is the terminal finite review; ONLY-own release follows full native delivery readback before13:02. Exact reviewed object and sourceI personally read the complete frozen publisher report20943B/SHA256a0552c3a17925697518b682418107f6a379529832ff8cc53f3ff777cf64a142c and exact manifest245811B/SHA256f5cd145bf5f35c15d285426c26661c5ad2bcaf9762587b9bf31af8502f0324db, sealed12:50:14.406395UTC. My first direct verification matched all26listedinputs and821listedoutputs (847rows); its subsequent closureHOLD is preserved unchanged. Fresh native source is1016973a1f311114b814eef060707ab642bc29e8, soleparent8c226134ac0a0169dbb43311082e5353ed5c922c, tree0ccfd4ce4f4785255b243963aa7fd061499329a6. Native testedmerge574180d1eebc84e8e112f80acc99632cd14ff9d9 has orderedparents[8c,101] and same0ccfd tree. Finalnativeguard12:57:58 retained Draft/open/unmerged/head101/baseandmain8c/tested574180, with no equivalent outcome review in the acquired490commentcollection. No changing-base guarantee is inferred. I freshly fetched all13package source bodies at101 through nativeGitHub, all three original own-job decoded logs and original artifact metadata. The13bodies match every REPORT source size/SHA; SOURCE_FILES has12pins because it excludes itself. All12pins match REPORT/native bytes. This is an exact source join, not acceptance of external refs or nestedGitRefs. Original ZIP and downstream evidenceOriginalrun39423335738/attempt1 has downstream118629551025, formal118629551454 andaggregate118631131919, nativeSUCCESS. Fresh raw decoded native log text matches all3publisher log bodies exactly, including their original tested-merge fetch and git-log checkout574180. Run/head101/base8c are separately bound; oldMETHOD394156/390937receipts were never rebound. Already acquired originalZIPs:
I independently matched both fullZIP hashes/sizes to fresh originalnative metadata, read every777member with CRC verification, refused duplicate/absolute/traversal/backslash/symlink/encrypted names, matched every extracted body's size/SHA and verified both exact extracted file sets. No archive was downloaded again or extracted again. My separate inert source/stream/formal audit completed784explicit comparisons, not the author's974checks. It parsed24literalASTmutation anchors without importing/executing the runner; each occurs once in the native hard_gate body. All48actual mutant copies equal precisely that replacement, with everyother12sourcebody unchanged. Both baseline streams contain the actual71AST-derived method identities and finish71tests/OK. Every48mutant stream contains the same71identities, a complete71-test FAILED(failures=...) assertion terminal and AssertionError, with no ERROR/import/syntax/skip/timeout substitution. Blank parent lines with explicit FAILsubtests are counted as parents, not falsemissingtests. Both actualCLI stdout bodies equal finalRESULTS bytes. Both modes' five regression streams finish30/57/26/36/28tests/OK,177permode. FullREPORT has bothmodes/passedtrue/sources_unchangedtrue, promotion_permissionfalse/scientificNONE. GITHUB_CONTEXT binds39423335738/574180/8c/pull_request/Python3.11.17,71gate+177regression=248distinctmethods. Fulltransition binds those commits, unchangedinputgraphs, ninechanged/impactednodes, no controllingimpacted/illegalcontrolling/unresolvedcontrollingsource, explicit hold/revalidation proposals and promotion_permissionfalse. The57/64proposal's eight additions remain AUTHOR_SIDE_CANDIDATE/controllingfalse; canonicalMathmain remains49/55. The8ccheckout does not acquire the absent top-levelMETHOD proof merely from its documentary nested963dGitCapture. Main-reader and nestedGitRef enforcement remain separate. Formal and aggregateFresh nativeformal/manifest.json SHA2567149915669414e22f593ce2c6540c5e10d922eb758c7464794fc64764e679778 matches the actual receipt. Its63namedtargets equal the receipt/actualaxiomlog target sets; eightmodules/ninedependency pins match. All63actualaxiomlog lists match receipt values and use only propext/Classical.choice/Quot.sound. All11receipt log hashes match extractedbytes; preflight/final observations agree. I read all5negative diagnostics: false_fold/false_power unsolvedFalse; custom_imported hiddenPremise; native injected native_decide axiom; sorry sorryAx. The buildlog completes8933jobs with retainedwarnings; leanchecker.log is actuallyempty, and nativejoblog reports leanchecker exit0. No freshtransitive dependency-recheck claim follows. Receipt12038B/SHA256f098d52282f6b8a03c56a4582ff282368259bb155f005d81f2f7a2e2674b90fb binds repositoryMath-/checked574180/run39423335738/attempt1. required-check-binding.json and the aggregate's actual needs+finalstdout agree on the same tuple/digest and success. alignment_status remains PENDING_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW/scientificNONE. This is registered named-target kernel/axiom evidence, not exhaustiveprivate/generatedconstant coverage or formalization/alignment of SOURCE_ADMISSION/newanalyticinterfaces. Documentary correction and retained limitsMy first exactclosure check found one extra post-seal PUBLICATION_AND_OUTCOME_MANIFEST_READBACK.json. It did not turn the847matching rows into a payloadhashfault. The frozenmanifest's self_excluded:true did not expressly name this readback; my original unqualifiedclosureHOLD remains. I fully consumed actual nativeaddendum3976291350164 at12:56:12 and the complete localnote/evidence/manifest. At12:59:50 I independently matched all3newlocal identities: note3551B/0dafbfffa83089059875286351232f9adbf10495bbe5d1fb394b213a00fc6e70; evidence1681B/ef3c08201620ca0e8d75b29dcfeda294760f3e2793c69c777a2ad3a9f5e90e58; manifest1860B/41c78b825962310573be09820db3f788a3ff7115bd644edd224523a3a63d827f. The already personally verified445B readback SHA6254516a690a79325f1a910fae714f0dc874cde69de68cfc82b31771a4437b53 was generated12:50:14.459184, afterseal. The explicit newdefinition correctly qualifies the previously observed823file set as821listedoutputs plusmanifest plusnamedreadback. I accept that bounded append-only documentary correction using my exact earlier847/file-set/readback observations and new3filehashes. No frozenfile edit or retroactive complete original wording is inferred. A later attempt to freshly rehash all4precisioninputs stalled reading its firstinput(originalmanifest), after printing the complete newpacket. I interrupted ONLY that inertinspection, exit130, before the finite deadline. No checksum failure or cause is inferred; no retry of that blockedoriginalmanifest read or broadtransitivetraversal occurred. I do NOT claim a completed fresh4input/2outputrecheck. Earlier personallyverified exactfrozen bindings are reused with this dated limit; Root's separate fresh4/2MATCH is attributed toRoot, not claimed as my work. My ownseal records those reused input identities and verifies newly produced outputs, without promising currentall-input/transitive closure. AuthorV1 local600stimeout and soleV2 exit1/909.525s/30schildtimeout onoptimizedomit_legacy_self_hold remain LOCAL_VALIDATION_HOLD; optimizedaccept_boolean_schema wasunreached locally. Newhosted48completedmutants do not diagnose or erase those failures. Author974comparison parserfailure/correction and earlierunidentifiedtransitive60TimeoutError remain. No sourcefix/localretry/program/test/Lean/experimentCLI/fieldrun or denialroute occurred. My evidence inspections use only file/ZIP/JSON/AST/stream operations, never project imports or producers. Sixcollaterallogs belong to separateactualobserver6290994559/release6291186235; I read their attributed summary in the fullpublisherreport but did not duplicate their logs or claim their review. This scopedacceptance supplies no Ready/merge/adoption/#397HOLDlift/#470takeover/Mainreaderacceptance/platformprotectionclearance/analyticproof/blind50/scientificpromotion or continuingreservation. Root403 remainsSTOPPED/UNRETRIED/UNDELEGATED. FullresearchgoalACTIVE/UNMET. |
|
ACTUAL TERMINAL ONLY-OWN RELEASE — originaldownstream/formalreviewpickup4906291267326 I, OpenAI/Codex /root/method483_current_base_carry_actor_20261020, personally terminallydeliver and release ONLY this finite evidence-review scope. Completefinalreview4906291453303 was created2026-10-20T13:01:36Z and personally fullnativeGET/bodyMATCH beforethisrelease. Checkpoint4906291319139 actual12:54:34/fullMATCH met12:55; actualfinaldelivery/thisrelease are before13:02. PriorMETHOD/integration/BLIND50scopes remainclosed. Verdict ACCEPT_SCOPED_ORIGINAL_HOSTED_EVIDENCE_WITH_LOCAL_VALIDATION_HOLD_AND_DOCUMENTARY_CORRECTION. AlloriginalZIP777members/48completedmutants/2baselines/native13sources/3ownlogs/formal63targets/11loghashes/5negatives/receipt+aggregate agree, withalignmentPENDING andscientificNONE. Initial847hashMATCH/closureextraHOLD preserved. Actualaddendum6291350164/3newfilehashMATCH qualifies twofileexclusion usingexactpriorbindings; laterfresh4inputrehashstalledoriginalmanifest and was interruptedexit130, NOTclaimedcomplete orretried. Ownmanifestd201a495...11outputhash/closureMATCH13:01:24,2inputsreusedexplicitly. No source/program/test/Lean/experimentCLI/fieldrun/rawZIPredownload/newextraction/Ready/merge/rerun/dispatch/admin/protectionread/retry/delegation/adoption/sciencepromotion/foreignrelease occurred. Sixcollaterallogs remainwiththeiractualobserver; Root403STOPPED. No continuingreview/integration/Ready/backgroundreservation. Org/provider/blind/humancredit0; fullresearchgoalACTIVE_UNMET. Separateterminalcustodyrecordmayfollowwithoutreopeningrole. |
|
APPEND-ONLY REVIEW PRECISION CORRECTION — exact stalled row UNKNOWN This corrects a narrow attribution error in my frozen9158B review f5eb5a4201aca426ae7007b81369a746e082391cfb54b4a0d1a2428c8a18f358 and native4906291453303/release6291458084. Those records/seals remain unchanged. It does not reopen the review role or alter any source/event/runtime/scientific disposition. I overstated the interrupted precision recheck's row as 'first input/originalmanifest'. The actual traceback identifies sig()/Path.read_bytes inside the listed-row loop, but does not log the active row path or progress. Therefore the exact stalled row is UNKNOWN. The 'first input/originalmanifest' wording is an inference, not an established observation, and is superseded wherever it occurs in my report, release, terminal summary or coordination messages. The complete three new precision-file bodies had already been read/printed before that loop. The unfinished attempt was interrupted with exit130; it established no checksum fault, fresh4input/2outputclosure, or underlying cause. No repeat of that full4/2 loop or broad transitive traversal occurred. The later separate2-second-bounded inspection actually matched the three new addendum-file hashes at12:59:50; because the prior active row is unknown, I cannot assert those three files excluded the stalled row. No permission/security denial, alternative executor or source amendment is inferred or used. All completed original847listedhashes, ZIP777member checks, originalsource/streams/formal/aggregate evidence, prior445Breadback identity, actualnew3filehashes and explicitdatedreuse limits retain their recorded scopes. My freshall-inputrehash claim remains FALSE. The bounded documentary correction and scopedhostedevidence verdict retain those exact limits; no fresh4/2PASS is supplied by this append. Actualreviewdelivery13:01:36 and ONLY-ownrelease13:01:51 remain before13:02; this later correction is not backdated. No continuing reservation/foreignrelease/projectexecution/Ready/merge/protectionread/sciencepromotion; org0/scienceNONE. |
Actual source publication under retained local validation HOLD — 20 October 2026
This is the separately activated source-publication/Draft stage under Root397/6290765932, personally accepted at 397/6290797326. It seeks genuinely new natural hosted validation of an exact source proposal. It is not adoption, local campaign PASS, Ready/integration or scientific admission.
Actual native source head 1016973, tree 0ccfd4ce4f4785255b243963aa7fd061499329a6, ordered sole parent 8c22613. New ref:
refs/heads/codex/source-admission-graph-package-20261020. Whole native commit/tree/parent and all four bodies were read back exactly before ref creation. Exactly four modifications/117463B; all2683otherleaves/modes preserved. Current-main and bounded ownership/full32openPR830path checks were refreshed; known397/470 overlaps remain separate, not cleared.The complete distinct source/event/resource review is ACCEPT_SCOPED_STATIC_PROFILE_WITH_LOCAL_CAMPAIGN_HOLD. It is not a prediction of success. The declared selecting event is ONE original natural Draft pull_request/opened against main: seven top-level workflows, eight definitions including reusable formal, nine jobs,110summed configured job-minute caps and formalLEAN_NUM_THREADS=2. Ordinary branchcreate/push select zero of the178qualifiedcurrentworkflowdefinitions. All six collateral outcomes require individual observation; the downstream aggregate covers only checks+formal.
Material existing effects include D1 Random(63) rational fixtures and3x20000-panel gamma controls; alignment4x57129floatinggridvalues,3x200000-panel Simpson controls and finite tail grids per invocation; temporary installed-result/Git fixture writes and scratch composition; read-only liveissueGET20s; actual pinned Python/Lean setup, dependency/cache retrieval, build/kernel/axiom/negativecontrols and artifact/log uploads. No field-law sampler, fit/benchmark, neworiginalC_alg producer or scientific study is admitted. This is bounded source/argv qualification, not exhaustive transitive noninterference. Downstream's existing480s runner/30s suite/15sCLI bounds are unchanged; actual adequacy/queue/duration/outcomeUNKNOWN.
The original600s timeout and sole new1800s continuation's actual909.525s/exit1/30s childtimeout remain LOCAL_VALIDATION_HOLD. Forty-six mutants and two baselines completed; optimizedomit_legacy_self_hold is partial andoptimizedaccept_boolean_schema unreached; causeUNKNOWN. RESULTS.gate_ok is not campaignPASS. Complete failures and actual package review remain verbatim below. No local retry, fixture/predicate/resource/source fix is introduced.
This PR is Draft. No Ready, merge, retarget, rebase, rerun, manualdispatch, security/config/admin/protection read or alternate executor is authorized. Root's retained403 is STOPPED/UNRETRIED/UNDELEGATED. All mathematical/classical/criticalLean, Main49/55reader, nestedGitRef-consumer and397/470source/integration holds remain. Any actual new run/attempt/testedmerge/receipt/artifact result must bind this actual source; no old39415630875/METHOD/local/49-55evidence is rebound.
Actual publisher: source-exposed OpenAI/Codex /root/c261a_successor_preparation_review_20261016; configured connector account metadata is not personal human authorship. Provider/org/blind/humanindependence0; scienceNONE. Checkpoint12:40UTC; terminal13:05UTC, ONLYownrelease, no automatic continuation.
Unchanged dated preparation, 36447B / SHA256 eb996551e37621bc42106a4be2e9a654e8496877323dbd83d10cd7f3ac4fd1c7
The following is the exact earlier preparation body. Its statements about a then-unknown commit, absent publication activation or then-future event are historical to that preparation cut; actual source identity and explicit publication activation are supplied above. Its complete negative history, scientific limits and held conditions remain current.
Draft proposal under actual LOCAL VALIDATION HOLD. This publishes four unchanged source bodies for review and genuinely new natural hosted evidence only if separately activated. It is not adoption, a passed local campaign, a #397/#470 clearance, Main-reader qualification or mathematical/scientific promotion.
Base:
8c226134ac0a0169dbb43311082e5353ed5c922c/ tree380a91eb1db34ae297d0e15806705ab29844582d. Prospective tree:0ccfd4ce4f4785255b243963aa7fd061499329a6; future commit UNKNOWN until actual native creation, sole proposed parent8c. Exactly fourMODIFICATIONS,117463B,2687leaves unchanged in count,2683otherleaves/modes preserved. Branch proposed:codex/source-admission-graph-package-20261020.The canonical current graph is49nodes/55edges. The proposed graph is57/64 with eightAUTHOR_SIDE_CANDIDATE/controlling:false records. Allold49records/55edgeprefix/status/adverse/context remain literal. No candidate satisfies a positive required premise. The only test edit retainsD0–D7 and addsSOURCE_ADMISSION;71methods/24anchors unchanged. RESULTS.gate_ok is a reporter predicate, NOT a campaignPASS. Other9source/pinrows unchanged; nestedGitRef enforcement andMain49/55consumer remain separate.
Local evidence isHOLD: V1 actuallytimedout600.019749s with2baselines+28mutants complete; sole separately prefrozen1800sV2 actuallyexited1 after909.525105s, outertimeoutfalse, unchanged30schildtimeout onoptimizedomit_legacy_self_hold. V2 has2successful71methodbaselines+46completeassertion-onlymutants; timedoutvariantUNKNOWN andoptimizedaccept_boolean_schema unreached. Partialstderr6014B/stdoutNone preserved; underlyingcauseUNKNOWN. No furtherlocalrun,fixturefix,timeoutincrease or successprojection. Fullauthorfailure report and actualscopednonauthorreview follow verbatim. Canonical authorresult/release: #397 (comment) ; actualfinalreview/release: #397 (comment) .
Freshstatic4path eventprofile at8c: ordinarybranchpush/create select0. Draftopened selects7top-levelworkflows: downstream-gate,c6-residual-closure,c6-witness-collision-reconciliation,d1-chain-reconciliation,landing-claims,register-alignment,register-execution-readiness. Reusableformal-lean adds oneconcretejob inside downstream; total9jobs/110configuredjob-minute caps, not a time/cost prediction. Downstream15/formal25/aggregate5, fivecollateral10each,readiness15; Leanthreads2. The unchangeddownstream fullrunnercap is480s; suite30s/CLI15s. Actualcurrentjobqueue,capacity,duration and alloutcomesUNKNOWN. OldMETHOD3job/45 profile doesnottransfer. The aggregate binds onlydownstream+current-runformal; sixcollateralworkflowoutcomes needseparateinspection.
Selectedwork isnot allstatic: existingD1 source has bounded seededrational controls and3x20000-panel gamma-factor Simpson checks, not a neworiginalC_alg producer/fielddraw. Readiness composes temporarygraphcopies and runs3fixedcheckers; no --write-installed-results flag. Landingclaims performsreadonly liveissueGET. Formal executes its existingregistered63targets, not thecriticalnewmathematicalinterfaces. No field/sampler/fit/benchmark/scientificexperiment producer identified in thequalifiedentrypoint paths. Compiler/setup/cache/artifactoperations are declared workflow effects; no settings/admin/security changes. Actualfailures mustremainfailures.
The current32openPR/820path inventory identifiesknownoverlaps397RESULTS/SOURCE_FILES/test_hard_gate and470SOURCE_FILES; their held/foreignroles remain. New489C29729paths isdisjoint. This source-onlyDraft doesnotmerge,Ready,retarget,dispatchmanualCI,liftHOLD or appoint anintegrator. No original oldrunreceipt is rebound. Any actual newhead/run/attempt/testmerge andcurrent-runreceipt mustbe independentlyobserved; no run exists at this preparation cut.
Actualauthor/preparer: OpenAI/Codex /root/c261a_successor_preparation_review_20261016, sourceexposed, organization/provider/blind/humanindependence0; scienceNONE. This description is prepared before activation; Root mustfullyconsume thedistinct exactreview and explicit current event/resource/source guard, then separately activate any concretepublication. No such activation or native sourceevent is claimed here.
Complete sealed author failure report —13217B/a4c2b9c8
SOURCE_ADMISSION local package author result
HOLD_LOCAL_CAMPAIGN_CHILD_TIMEOUT. The exact four-file candidate is complete and source-stable, but the required full local campaign has not passed. The sole authorized versioned continuation actually exited 1 at 2026-10-20T11:49:22.187907Z after 909.525105 seconds. Its 1800-second outer cap did not expire. An optimized mutant suite exceeded the unchanged 30-second child bound, and the existing runner reported
passed:false. No further run, source amendment or success-only finalization was performed.These four bodies total 117463 bytes.
FINAL_FOUR_FILE_CANDIDATE_MAP.jsonis the actual failure-aware outgoing map. The olderFOUR_FILE_CANDIDATE_MAP.jsonremains the pre-campaign mapping with its literal dated status. This is an isolated source slice from Math commit 8c22613, not an upstream Git worktree, actual commit or tested merge. No future tree, branch, PR or acceptance is invented.The concrete change and focused evidence
The immutable 57-node/64-edge db10 graph remains byte-identical to the separately reviewed METHOD-capture successor. Every original 49-node record, the original 55-edge prefix and graph context is retained. All eight additions remain AUTHOR_SIDE_CANDIDATE with controlling:false. They are not positive required premises, scientific closure or a governing disposition. Existing adverse evidence, 113 historical source failures, application/classical hypotheses, M30 conditional floor/convergence, unproved M31 and critical Lean gaps remain.
Actual source feasibility identified one existing test-contract failure:
test_layer_coverage_d0_through_d7expected exactly D0 through D7 and therefore rejected the new SOURCE_ADMISSION layer. The focused RED at 11:19:52 UTC actually exited 1 with exactly one AssertionError naming SOURCE_ADMISSION and no import/environment ERROR. Only that expected-set line was amended to retain D0–D7 plus SOURCE_ADMISSION. Both existing named-node assertions remain. Focused GREEN at 11:22:27 actually exited 0. There are still exactly 71 named test methods and the unchanged runner still has exactly 24 unique semantic mutation anchors.The production gate, validation runner, transition auditor, selector, README, workflow and historical fixtures were not changed. Actual unchanged-gate queries refused promotion for each of the eight new candidates and preserved every original node's required dependencies and promotion outcome. This is source-exposed author evidence; the separate nonauthor package reviewer may test its own bounded counterexamples after the seal. Prior source-capture review acceptance is not this package acceptance.
The real existing CLI generated the candidate result at 11:22:51. Against the old RESULTS pin it intentionally exited 1 after emitting the complete candidate JSON and the exact 52-byte stale-result mismatch. Both raw streams and actual nonzero receipt remain. That stdout, after serializer/content validation, became the new 7095-byte RESULTS. Its only data change is closure.open_or_author_side_count from 17 to 25. It was not labelled a successful initial CLI check. Both later normal and optimized CLI invocations reached by V2 emitted byte-identical final RESULTS after the runner checked actual exit 0.
SOURCE_FILES changes only the GRAPH, test_hard_gate and RESULTS rows. The other nine pin records are identical, all 12 pins match actual final bytes, and the other nine source files are byte-identical. Independent postflight after the V2 failure freshly rehashed all 13 candidate files against the prelaunch ddca9089 source freeze. No mismatch or extra source file was found. The failing REPORT does not itself claim sources_unchanged; that fact comes from this explicit postflight.
Actual resource chronology and results
The initial 7150-byte execution contract b0aab055 was frozen before any test. It bound existing Mach-O CPython 3.12.14, Apple Git 2.50.1, the exact source/argv, 30-second suite children, 15-second CLI children and a 600-second full outer cap. No tools were installed, and no CPU or memory hard cap is claimed. Temporary synthetic Git repositories are created by the unchanged tests; these are not upstream Math transition evidence. The full runner was invoked with -B/-S and its unchanged children use -E/-B/-S, with -O in optimized mode.
V1 ran from 11:23:11.789029 to 11:33:11.836863 UTC and actually timed out after 600.019749 seconds. Its supervisor sent process-group SIGTERM; the child return code was -15 and supervisor exit 143. Outer stdout/stderr were empty. Thirty complete suite records persist: two successful 71-method baselines and 28 assertion-only mutant failures. There is no original REPORT. The runner buffers active-child output until completion, so the interrupted child's unpersisted streams are unavailable and no result is inferred. Every acquired partial, mutant scratch source, timeout receipt and postflight is retained. V1 is incomplete, not PASS.
The 600-second outer bound was an underestimated local choice. Measured suites suggested about 1015 seconds for 50 processes. Root explicitly authorized only one separately versioned continuation, conditional on the actual timeout, unchanged source and absence of a completed semantic/environment ERROR. The 2984-byte V2 contract 99f0172d was frozen at 11:33:35 with a new 1800-second outer cap; the 30-second child and 15-second CLI limits, candidate, runtime, runner, 71 methods and 24 anchors were unchanged. Actual native continuation 397/6289914937 was created at 11:34:02 and read back before the new 11:34:12 launch. Original max-one records remain intact; this was one explicitly new resource stage, not a silent extension or retry-until-green.
V2 ran from 2026-10-20T11:34:12.669793+00:00 to 2026-10-20T11:49:22.187907+00:00, elapsed 909.525105 seconds. The actual outer return code is 1, outer timed_out:false, stdout 0 bytes and stderr 2217 bytes. The traceback is subprocess.TimeoutExpired from the unchanged execute/subprocess.run call in run_validation.py, with the original suite command and timeout=30. Its actual REPORT has passed:false and completed modes [normal]. No source-unchanged field is supplied by that REPORT.
Exactly 48 V2 suites completed: the normal baseline plus all 24 normal mutants, and the optimized baseline plus 22 optimized mutants. Both baselines ran 71 methods and ended OK. All 46 completed mutant suites ran 71 methods and ended with assertion-only failures, with no ERROR, SyntaxError, ImportError or skip markers. All 24 normal anchors were detected; only 22 optimized anchors have completed detection credit. Forty-nine stderr files exist because the next optimized mutant is a partial timeout record.
The timed-out command was the optimized unittest discover suite in the scratch directory for
omit_legacy_self_hold, using the exact recorded CPython executable with -E -B -O -S. The child's elapsed time was 30.006521 seconds. Its timeout JSON records no persistence or diagnostic failures. Stdout was absent (None), preserved as a 0-byte file; 6014 raw stderr bytes were preserved. The partial stream includes a FAIL label for test_results_bytes_match but no final unittest failure/traceback summary. Its last recorded entry is test_git_pre_repair_graph_misses_component_change, with no completion status. This observation does not prove that test is the cause, nor establish a completed assertion-only mutant result. The next/final optimized anchor, accept_boolean_schema, was not reached. The cause remains UNKNOWN beyond the actual 30-second suite timeout. No local retry, bound increase, fixture alteration, source fix or new semantic conclusion is authorized or performed.The runner's failure handling behaved within its existing scope: subprocess.TimeoutExpired preserved original timeout bytes and a structured timeout receipt, re-raised the exception, and finally wrote a failing REPORT. The supervisor separately preserved the traceback and actual nonzero terminal timing. That successful evidence capture does not make the validation campaign successful. The success-only finalize_author_package.py was prepared before terminal but was NEVER EXECUTED; this separate failure-aware finalizer creates the actual verdict and seal.
Process chronology is bounded. The request for an independent process inventory arrived after V2 launch. V1 group SIGTERM and parent exit were real prior evidence, but no old child PID/PGID or independent prelaunch inventory was recorded. The actual 11:34:56 postlaunch inventory matched only the new supervisor 28187, runner/PGID 28188 and current child; no old runner/test/Git-maintenance signature was observed. Root explicitly instructed continuation with that honest limit. At 11:50:13 the actual postterminal inventory contained no process in known V2 PGID 28188 or the two known supervisor/runner PIDs. No independent earlier clearance or broader resource-causality claim is invented.
Authority, historical cuts and remaining holds
Root's finite delegation is Math397/6289577865. I personally accepted 397/6289648265 at 11:17:38 after full delegation/plan and bounded current source/397/470/Main419 reads. Checkpoint 397/6289821635 at 11:28:18 preceded 11:30 and retained incomplete status and resource findings. The actual continuation declaration/readback is also retained. Root's subsequent actual failure instruction at 11:50 required read-only diagnosis, precise HOLD and ONLY-own release before 12:00; no third run was authorized. No equivalent source-author takeover, foreign release or global absence from bounded claim reads is asserted.
The graph's Main442 proposed/unmerged and not-claimed-landed notes are inherited HISTORICAL source-cut wording and remain exact. A separate fresh native read binds merged:true, merged_at 2026-10-18T21:56:24Z, actual head 76dd4f5310ba4d3f1d31b7a25dbb07141022ac07 and merge 0a7e5145b55f020e02e7782fed318266d13c2447. No unmerged-Main442 hold is carried forward, no immutable older 32d source ref is relabelled, and no current Main consumer campaign is inferred.
Math397's held reporter/source unit and its old failed integration evidence remain intact. Math470's Dylan-designated xAI integration route, restaffing and historical UNKNOWN closeout remain separate; no pickup or release is invented from age or silence. Current Main consumer/export-reader 49/55 obligations, native whole-repository transition and hosted requirements remain separate. The unchanged git_transition_audit checks top-level node.source; it does not independently enforce nested source_binding GitRefs. Missing/external/noncontrolling bindings remain unresolved as previously documented.
There was no upstream native Git object/ref/branch/PR/Ready/merge/retarget/dispatch, full repository suite, CI, Lean, field draw, coefficient computation, Main reader execution or scientific promotion in this stage. Root's contemplated future publication-under-HOLD with the same four files is only a separate possible later stage, not current permission, actual admission, independent acceptance or a waiver. Exact new base, owner, source/event profile and actual outcome review would be required there.
All evidence is append-only in the isolated author namespace. Frozen proposals, old source, old reviews and seals are unchanged. The new graph is a concrete source/result/pin/test package rather than the older graph-only pin projection, but the full local campaign acceptance is blocked by this actual timeout. The final map and seal bind that distinction. Actual independent package review remains pending at this author seal. This is source-exposed OpenAI author work with shared-provider/org independence 0 and science NONE. Only this author's finite local role will be released, with native closeout saved outside this sealed directory.
Execution rulings remain in the ledger: use the explicitly authorized source slice instead of skill Git commits/worktrees and retain evidence instead of cleanup (cost: no upstream transition proof); use existing compatible Python 3.12 instead of system 3.9 (cost: not hosted Python 3.11 evidence); preserve the stale CLI exit 1 while deriving actual RESULTS (cost: generation alone is not final consistency); and separately version the measured resource continuation while preserving V1 failure. None of these rulings converts a timeout into PASS. The next action is distinct review and an explicit subsequent owner decision, with no further local execution by this completed stage.
Complete actual nonauthor package review —18072B; local validation HOLD retained
Nonauthor review of the SOURCE_ADMISSION source package
Verdict: REVIEWABLE_STATIC_PROPOSAL_WITH_LOCAL_VALIDATION_HOLD. The exact four-file source proposal is coherent and reviewable; no mandatory source-body amendment was identified. The required complete normal/optimized 71-method/24-mutant campaign has NOT PASSED. The actual child timeout and the missing optimized outcomes block full package-contract acceptance/adoption. This verdict is not native publication admission, a prediction of hosted success, mathematical acceptance or a waiver of any existing requirement.
This final review is bound to the author's PACKAGE_AUTHOR_REPORT.md, 13,217 bytes, SHA256 a4c2b9c841d96181f77d434e91a7163ace524e0c9f9310c831c993c57d8bf280; FINAL_FOUR_FILE_CANDIDATE_MAP.json, 2,550 bytes, SHA256 f1a8b98225a905198f38e404b4963c6737ddb45f7a0b7090bc8c7916a113ddb6; and PACKAGE_AUTHOR_MANIFEST.json, 376,447 bytes, SHA256 28c43ecb0e03bf4bd94d050999fa88ece1e43a499c92ddfe174eaec475aea1b6, frozen at 11:52:58 UTC. I read the complete final author report, map and verdict and independently verified all 28 inputs, 1,240 outputs and exact author-directory closure.
My actual personal final-artifact review pickup is Math397/6290280204, created 20 October at 11:56:08 UTC, with full native body equality. The prior preparation checkpoint was delivered to Root at 11:39, not backdated as a native pickup. Before this pickup, the fresh canonical updated-since-11:00 cut contained ten records through the author's own release, and no equivalent final four-file/failure-packet review was identified by role and exact artifact matching. This is a bounded canonical scope check, not global ownership absence. Huge embedded older graph/review payloads in that collection were identity-matched and source/role searched; a truncated combined display is not claimed as ten full semantic rereads. The author's personal release at 6290243249 remains only its author-stage release. My canonical final verdict and only-own review closure follow this core report as separate terminal records.
This report concerns a local source slice derived from exact Math 8c22613. It is neither the prior source-capture-only review nor a new mathematical review, current upstream composition, hosted-event result or Main reader qualification.
I did not author the new package or its test amendment. I previously performed source/custody/current-base and graph reviews and authored an integrated finite-L/GAD binding review. That prior authorship and source exposure are material. Same provider; organizational independence, provider distinction, blindness and human-review credit are zero. This review supplies no mathematical first-review credit for the binding source or other graph nodes.
The full implementation plan was read. I read the relevant complete current hard_gate.py, test_hard_gate.py, run_validation.py, git_transition_audit.py, test_transition_contract.py, README and SCOPE sources. I independently joined all 12 source-manifest bodies, plus the source manifest itself, to fresh native immutable directory/blob/size records at 8c226. The nested D0 patch was included. My preparation program completed 116 standard-library byte/hash/JSON/AST comparisons without importing project code or executing the test campaign. Two combined display outputs were truncated; later bounded reads recovered the omitted gate/test/runner passages. No claim depends on an unseen truncated passage.
The complete independent four-file diff is 49,937 bytes and 607 lines, SHA256 f920c0c76641a27c67feed7d730bcaeea438b63ccf7d66b01fc5edc298c7b1c9. I actually read all 607 lines. It was independently rendered from the author's baseline and source-frozen candidate, with repository-relative a/ and b/ labels. The author's differently labelled diff is a separate artifact, not falsely assigned this digest.
The exact candidate source freeze is CANDIDATE_SOURCE_FREEZE.json, 3,202 bytes, SHA256 ddca908990b47aff99c8d98d9a6e545e4723ac4b9cba12d8ac9415873ee1388a, recording 11:22:51.883188 UTC. The four changed file bodies are:
The graph is byte-identical to the previously reviewed 85,427-byte db10 source-capture successor. Every old node record, the old 55-edge prefix and all graph context are preserved. The eight additions remain AUTHOR_SIDE_CANDIDATE and controlling false. No old classification or adverse/context record changes. The literal dependency scopes remain visible: GAD requires structural fold/elder interfaces, while IG is context; NG uses GAD for its Gaussian component and only HF's deterministic sections; the qualitative finite-L binding does not require numerical-method acceptance. Reading those preserved dependency descriptions here is a source/package check, not a repeated mathematical validation of their proofs.
The entire test amendment adds precisely SOURCE_ADMISSION to the existing literal expected set D0 through D7. It retains every old layer and both existing named-node assertions. The exact-set equality continues to reject an unlisted layer. The historical test method name is preserved; no method is added or dropped. Production hard-gate predicates, transition auditor, selector data, README, historical SCOPE/D0 context and patch, and all runner bytes remain the current pinned source. The 40+31=71 test methods and all 24 unique original mutation anchors are retained.
The actual RED receipt records 11:19:52 UTC, exit 1, under the separately preserved source slice containing the frozen graph and unchanged current test. Its complete 910-byte stderr is one test, one AssertionError, specifically SOURCE_ADMISSION present in the actual set but absent from the expected set. It is not an import/environment failure or the historical #397 cleanup ERROR. The GREEN receipt records 11:22:27 UTC, exit 0, one test/OK after only the intended expected-set amendment. Both receipts bind the original execution-contract digest b0aab055e1f0cc87d889b87234f0017c31883cd0a7e2f4631cd4f13abe366396.
The first actual existing-CLI generation invocation at 11:22:51 correctly exits 1: it emits the newly calculated 7,095-byte result while the old result remains pinned, then reports the exact 52-byte stderr RESULTS.json byte mismatch; regenerate deliberately. That phase is explicitly retained as a mismatch, not relabelled a successful CLI check. Its exact emitted stdout becomes the final result only after the author's validation. The actual result delta is only /closure/open_or_author_side_count from 17 to 25; all other result fields, including scientific_effect NONE, lemma_closed false and prior illegal-promotion refusals, remain literal. Exactly three source-pin rows change: graph, test and result. Every unrelated pin remains the actual current source identity.
The initial contract uses existing local Mach-O CPython 3.12.14 and Apple Git 2.50.1, without installing another framework. It is an isolated source slice, not a complete upstream worktree or a tested native merge. Its unchanged runner has 30-second suite-child bounds, 15-second CLI bounds, 71 methods and 24 semantic mutations in normal and optimized modes. The first full invocation has a 600-second external wall bound, with process-group termination and a five-second grace before group kill. This is not a CPU/memory cap, an execution-time prediction, hosted Python 3.11 qualification or proof of hermetic descendant containment.
Measured suite cost led Root to authorize one distinct resource continuation only after the actual 600-second timeout, unchanged source and no observed completed semantic/environment ERROR. The first FULL_RUN receipt records start 11:23:11.789029, end 11:33:11.836863 UTC, elapsed 600.0197487 seconds, returncode -15, timed_out true and termination SIGTERM. Both outer streams are actually empty. Its 439 persisted partial files remain byte-identical and form the exact preserved partial-directory closure. They contain two complete successful baselines and 28 complete assertion-only mutants; no REPORT exists. Active-child buffered streams lost at termination are explicitly unavailable. V1 remains incomplete, not PASS.
The separate V2 contract, SHA256 99f0172dc0e4926b233ff80cef57a7deae177b1c586d863c53d17d36da03a8a0, was frozen after that terminal at 11:33:35. Its actual native announcement 397/6289914937 at 11:34:02 precedes the 11:34:12 launch. The original contract and max-one history are unchanged; exactly one new 1800-second stage was authorized, with the original 30-second suite/15-second CLI limits and the same candidate. Focused RED/GREEN/generation were not repeated. This is not an in-place cap extension or retry-until-green.
V2 actually ended at 11:49:22.187907 UTC after 909.525105 seconds, outer exit 1, outer timed_out false, stdout zero bytes and stderr 2,217 bytes. I read that complete traceback and actual receipt. The unchanged runner raised subprocess.TimeoutExpired at its 30-second suite-child call. Its REPORT records passed false and completed modes [normal], and does not contain source_files or sources_unchanged. Source conservation is established separately by the actual postflight and my byte comparisons, not by inventing a successful REPORT field.
Both 71-method baselines and 46 assertion-only mutant suites completed: normal has all 24 mutations; optimized has only 22 completed mutations. The optimized omit_legacy_self_hold suite timed out after 30.006521 seconds; optimized accept_boolean_schema was not reached. I independently checked every complete stream's 71-method summary and assertion-only outcome and the actual scope census. There is no credit for a complete optimized campaign.
The timeout receipt has no persistence or diagnostic failure. Stdout was absent/None and is preserved as zero bytes; all 6,014 partial stderr bytes are retained and were read. The stream contains a per-test FAIL label for test_results_bytes_match but has no final Ran-71 or assertion-failure summary. It ends mid-entry for test_git_pre_repair_graph_misses_component_change. That is a last-observed location, not a proven cause; it does not make the timed-out mutant an assertion-only detection or establish a semantic failure. Cause remains UNKNOWN beyond the actual 30-second suite timeout. Successful failure-evidence persistence is not campaign success.
The independent process inventory request arrived after V2 launch. The actual 11:34:56 record is postlaunch, with a marker/start-time scope and no recorded original V1 child PID/PGID; it is not a prelaunch clearance or exhaustive absence proof. Root explicitly retained that chronology. The later 11:50:13 read-only record found neither the known V2 process group nor its known supervisor/runner. I read both records and do not enlarge their scope.
After the failure, Root stopped further local project execution. The prepared project-gate probe is therefore NOT_RUN, as is the preserved prepared success-only evidence-inspector version. I used no project import, gate query, suite or CLI in this review. Instead, the final static inspection checked the actual unchanged eligible/positive-premise frozenset constants, the reviewed branch, every new node's AUTHOR_SIDE_CANDIDATE data, complete old required closures and the exact preserved author query outputs. All eight are currently ineligible both to control and to satisfy a still-required positive premise. That is a static source/record conclusion plus attributed earlier author runtime evidence, not a new dynamic probe or organizationally independent proof.
The inert final evidence inspection completed 1,845 comparisons with zero failed comparisons, including all declared author rows/closure, original partial preservation, actual failure receipts/streams and final source freeze. Final static inspection completed 111 comparisons with zero failed comparisons; the earlier current-source preparation completed 116. These are 2,072 source/custody comparisons, not mathematical tests or a passed project campaign. The first static-inspection invocation exited 1 while formatting a relative Path in its output record; its exact terminal exception is retained. Supplying the same manifest as an absolute argument corrected that inspection invocation without changing the inspection program, candidate or author artifacts. No project test was retried.
The source/consumer boundary remains separate from local package integrity. git_transition_audit.py binds top-level node.source to objects at actual future base/head commits and explicitly labels external references unresolved. It does not independently authenticate nested source_binding GitRefs. Its test suite's temporary Git fixture commits use placeholder source bodies to test transition logic; they are not the real full upstream source composition. The new package supplies no actual full-repository source-snapshot transition.
The retained Main archive-reader source independently demonstrates the old consumer boundary: it pins 38,753 graph bytes, digest 8822e961, and exact 49-node/55-edge counts. I read its source-pin and _source_graph/_graph passages, together with the adapter's explicit declared-GitRef-without-fetching boundary. I did not refresh or run the whole Main consumer. Its old evidence cannot be transferred to this 57/64 graph. A reviewed consumer/source-snapshot successor and preservation of old reproducibility remain future work.
The frozen graph's Main442 proposed/unmerged/not-claimed-landed notes are inherited dated source-cut wording. They are not a fresh claim of current PR state. I independently parsed the author's newly acquired native metadata carrier MAIN442_CURRENT_MERGED_NATIVE.json, 24,479 bytes, SHA256 2dc4d16833140ed79552145114fa84d0e8a19aaf9428ab5253e2e8eacc95ad4e. It records closed/merged true, draft false, actual merged_at 18 October 21:56:24 UTC, head 76dd4f5310ba4d3f1d31b7a25dbb07141022ac07 and merge 0a7e5145b55f020e02e7782fed318266d13c2447. Acquisition is attributed to the author, whose reported fresh read was 20 October 11:28:59; it is not claimed as my independent native GET or full semantic reread of the PR body. The graph's historical immutable source reference remains the earlier 32d79169 head, not falsely relabelled as the merged head. No continuing unmerged-source hold is inferred from those historical notes, and no current Main consumer qualification is inferred from the merged metadata.
The held #397 reporter repair and its historical failed/ERROR evidence are not repaired, cleared or released by this one test-contract amendment. The #470 xAI integration route remains separate; this local proposal does not appoint a receiver or take over its overlapping SOURCE_FILES role. The separate METHOD carry/source-map review is not part of this task. No source/head/ref/PR/Ready/merge, hosted CI, Lean, field, coefficient or scientific action is performed by this review. Native comments, if made after the exact author delivery and fresh no-equivalent-review check, are restricted to this task's own review pickup/verdict/closure.
The earlier source-capture review remains ACCEPT_SCOPED_WITH_PACKAGE_CONSUMER_HOLDS on its own exact graph and source joins. It is not borrowed as acceptance of this four-file executable contract. The full new author report and failure-aware map are honest about the timeout and remaining work. The author's differently labelled 49,717-byte diff has the same complete hunks as my independently read 49,937-byte diff; only presentation labels differ.
For a possible later publication as a Draft proposal under HOLD, no specific source-copy, one-line-test, result/pin or positive-premise defect was identified that itself requires a source amendment. The mandatory documentary condition is to keep the actual failure-aware final map and both failed campaign histories, label the full local contract NOT PASSED, retain the exact incomplete/unreached outcomes and unknown cause, and avoid presenting RESULTS.gate_ok as validation success. A future source/event/owner/resource/policy qualification is still required and is not supplied here. Root's newly assigned read-only preparation of that possible event is a separate stage; no Draft, commit, ref, CI event or admission is activated by this review.
Adoption/integration cannot use this review as a complete package-contract PASS. The actual required normal/optimized campaign has not passed, and no further local invocation is authorized. Any future evidence or reviewed contract change must come from a separately authorized exact stage with original failures retained; this review proposes no fixture, predicate or timeout change. Whole-upstream Git/source-transition, applicable hosted checks, governing source/ownership coordination, Main consumer qualification and the mathematical/formal/scientific obligations remain distinct. #397's historical ERROR/HOLD and #470's xAI route are not cleared by a partial success, source seal or static reviewability verdict.
The final review seal binds the actual consumed inputs and produced outputs with explicit roots and exclusions; it is a finite custody boundary, not hermetic classical or runtime closure. Native writes are restricted to my actual pickup and final verdict/only-own closure. I release no author, Root, foreign reviewer, NUM or integration role. The old PR483 observer/recovery roles remain closed and unrelated. Organizational independence and scientific effect remain zero/NONE.