Repository navigation
Add seeded sandbox implementation E2E validation - #5255
Merged
Merged
Conversation
Trecek
force-pushed
the
impl-issue-5233-20261008-implementation
branch
from
October 8, 2026 15:02
f0f09ee to
017b3f1
Compare
Trecek
marked this pull request as ready for review
October 8, 2026 15:23
This was referenced Oct 9, 2026
Trecek
force-pushed
the
impl-issue-5233-20261008-implementation
branch
from
October 10, 2026 17:46
017b3f1 to
021bead
Compare
This was referenced Oct 10, 2026
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Adds a seeded sandbox implementation scenario to the MiniMax E2E harness. It resolves a fixed sandbox issue, runs the bundled implementation recipe, validates the owned PR and source/test changes at its captured head, and independently cleans up the PR, branch and proven issue claim after success or failure.
Pipeline selection requires a large PR touching the configured production paths and admits at most one pipeline within the existing test cap. Synchronous lifecycle hooks and transcript ownership evidence provide conservative concurrency measurements; missing evidence fails validation. Recipe findings support narrowly linked expected failures, which do not qualify as commissioning success.
Refs #5233.
Verification status — October25
Not ready to merge: #5324 blocks the recipe's original clone-plan/fresh-worktree handoff. It is filed with bug/recipe:remediation and explicit fix base develop, after two fresh adversarial reviews and parent primary-source verification. The separate reporter error is existing #5249.
The merged5317 repair from #5321 is integrated. This branch was rebased onto then-current develop7b07ccf0639cc27df63bdb9a3afd33e2641eed61/0.10.1298 and published at6e92c10657ac75b66dd0da3753a60d470b38ab2c. The config conflict retains sandbox base main and accepts develop's intentional removal of the old Sonnet override for Claude5.5/ClaudeCode2.1.296.
The repeat's original handoff fails120/123; mkdir alone then produces path_escape132/133. Plan copy203/204 and new worktree-local sealed bind207/208 permit implementation214/215. This is not forged authority; it is an agent-authored recovery that leaves the shipped handoff defect unresolved. Real post-recovery evidence includes persisted semantic bytes/server PUBLISHED GO, stage obligations, nine detached tests at PR43 headc434cb95992325a17bda967c1d8ba7d5c8f7071f, associated sandbox CI40249570623, complete lifecycle/ownership evidence and raw peak6. LOCAL-only review did not live-exercise the5317 hosted path.
Correction to earlier commissioning evidence
Old 40160081101 has actual strict-passing result bytes, but previously missed root121/122 shows the same containment rejection, followed by a worktree-temp symlink329/337 and Git info/exclude edit345/346 before implementation352/353 succeeds. Its eligibility as proof of an unchanged recipe is withdrawn. Raw historical peak6 remains an observation. No installed-source patch is asserted. The old failed repeat remains failed;5317's independently proven hosted receipt bug was subsequently repaired.
All current workflows, evidence workers/downloads and owned teardown are finished. PR43 is closed/unmerged; owned branch removed; fixed issue1 open/unclaimed with exact title/body and sandbox main unchanged. Legacy refs are preserved. No manual fixture/label repair, source fix, new source commit or third implementation dispatch was made.
Catalog peak_sessions8 remains provisional with no eligible evidence recorded. Repair5324 on develop, rebase and obtain legitimate current-head strict commissioning plus same-seed repeat before recording peak/run/commit/method provenance and updating the provisional-value test. Do not use a broad missing-result expected-failure annotation or the old measurement draft.
Develop advanced to881da05/0.10.1299 during verification with a doctor/installation-record fix; it does not change the containment chain. The persistent local Docker environment is updated to that revision with Claude2.1.296 and saved home/workspace volumes, stopped afterward. That local image is separate from this PR's recorded CI head; no local model run is claimed.
Latest assessment — 2026-10-26 exploratory bug hunt (not commissioning)
This update supersedes earlier local-runtime status. A real local MiniMax-M3.1-Flash implementation exploration at feature6e92c106 reached planning, dry walkthrough, implementation, tests, merge, authenticated audit publication, PR creation, hosted review and resolve-review. It used distribution0.10.1299/develop881da05 with unmodified feature package/harness source on process-local PYTHONPATH, retained2CPU/4GiB, and documented temporary workarounds. No new remote AutoSkillit E2E dispatch or eligible commissioning success is claimed.
The original harness result is FAILED (
passed:false, no expected findings): the real hosted review committed but its inline-comment endpoint could not satisfy strict coordinate reconciliation, leaving COMMITTED_PENDING_VERIFICATION and no receipt. The verifier correctly rejected it. In a separately preserved continuation, a temporary adapter in another source copy obtained authoritative PR-wide coordinates, filtered by review ID, and the real publisher reconciled the exact existing operation with ZERO new mutations. A separate actual MCP verifier accepted the canonical receipt for reviewed headc2dfdba/review-pr:0. The original failed result was not relabeled.The continuation validated final sandbox head0b9d47b6ab38a1f73cf1c53703fa2a325e5cc868: configured task test-check passed12 tests; original pinned nonempty P-7/P-8 stage obligations verified; actual wait_for_ci selected successful sandbox PR45 CI40270185914. Retained API metadata associates that exact top-level head with PR45 and sandbox repo1404112941, and its test-suite job passed. This is inner sandbox CI, not PR5255 commissioning CI.
Current repair tracking, all targeting DEVELOP rather than this feature branch:
Each new ticket received two adversarial reviews, parent inspection of actual cited text, corrections, and exact published body/label readback. Labels are bug + recipe:remediation. The three repairs have distinct source surfaces and can be processed in parallel, coordinating if file overlap appears.
The authentic audit GO covers its submitted16-row inventory at pre-resolver headc2dfdba; it omitted owned P-6 (focused unittest coverage), contrary to its model narrative claiming17. Actual diff plus initial/final tests independently establish P-6. This is the initial-inventory omission risk already acknowledged in closed #4177; the new occurrence is recorded there, not claimed as a complete audit or a newly proven parser failure. No second audit GO on final0b9d47b is claimed.
Owned PR45 is CLOSED/unmerged and its owned branch deleted after verification. Two fresh snapshots confirm fixed seed1 OPEN/unclaimed, unchanged title/body, unchanged main and legacy refs. The original failure label
failremains; failed clone/dispatch evidence is deliberately retained. Temporary experiment/helper containers were removed without deleting named volumes; persistent autoskillit-test-session is stopped. No manual seed body/label repair, AutoSkillit source commit, production-source patch, or catalog edit was made.Observed exploratory lifecycle peak6 was independently recomputed from fully closed session/agent intervals; it is INELIGIBLE calibration. Catalog peak_sessions8 stays provisional. After required repairs land on develop, rebase this PR and run the original scenario successfully twice against the same seed, checking original success artifacts, exact-head sandbox CI and teardown before recording eligible capacity/run/commit provenance.
Full local report:
/home/talon/projects/generic_automation_mcp/.autoskillit/temp/investigate/investigation_5255_bug_hunt_2026-10-26.mdWorktree:
/home/talon/projects/worktrees/impl-issue-5233-20261008-implementationBranch:
impl-issue-5233-20261008-implementationCurrent reassessment — 2026-10-26 repairs integrated
This supersedes the exploratory bug-hunt blocker status above. Repairs #5324, #5326, #5328 and #5329 are integrated into develop through PRs #5330, #5332, #5331 and #5333 respectively. Every file touched by those repairs matches develop unchanged in this branch, and all repair commits are ancestors of the published head.
Synchronized head:
7cfcf6d94a69c782e720cdfc5ae6fd9383e1dae9, incorporating develop39095b42744aaa877978371dd379936cb815836e/ package0.10.1305. An ordinary rebase conflicted replaying the branch's initial implementation commit across its prior synchronization merges. It was aborted without manual conflict edits; merging the current develop tip combined cleanly and preserved the earlier resolutions. This update is a merge, not a completed linear rebase. No independent production fix or capacity edit was added.Validation on the synchronized tree:
pre-commit run --all-files: PASS; commit hooks also passed.task test-local-gatewith conservative filtering/base origin/develop: PASS — 53,612 passed, 623 skipped, 26 xfailed, including lint, import contracts and Linux/Darwin mypy.An original hosted implementation retry without manual workarounds is now running at this exact head: E2E40437524860. The implementation job completed image build and entered
Run the E2E test; seed1 was claimed at2026-10-27T02:22:03Z. This proves the recipe started, not that planning, implementation or final verification has passed. The automatic PR E2E40437497975 skipped its run job and is not commissioning evidence.The known repair list no longer requires waiting for a source merge. Issue5329's GitHub ticket was still OPEN at the read, despite repair5333 being MERGED into develop; its code is present. No new bug ticket was filed by this reassessment.
Commissioning remains pending: inspect the original success artifact and actual phase evidence, full lifecycle coverage, initial audit inventory, exact-head sandbox CI and owned teardown. Then repeat against the same OPEN/unclaimed seed. No successful original implementation run or eligible measured peak is claimed yet; peak_sessions8 remains provisional and no provenance was invented.
Full reassessment:
/home/talon/projects/generic_automation_mcp/.autoskillit/temp/investigate/reassessment_5255_after_repairs_2026-10-26.mdWorktree:
/home/talon/projects/worktrees/impl-issue-5233-20261008-implementationBranch:
impl-issue-5233-20261008-implementation