Repository navigation
Description
Found while working on #64. It is on main (ef885cf), and the fix in #69 leaves corner bosses out.
What happens. With corner bosses (Base: bosses, for magnets or screws), the boss shells at each cell corner fill the housing of any joint cut from beneath where four cells meet, so the key, clip or tab can't go in. This covers floor and wall keys, the H-clip and the default dovetail. At 42 mm the housing is 100% filled.
With keys in the floor or puzzle tabs, the joint also adds a solid floor at least as tall as the 2.6 mm bosses. Every boss magnet pocket is then buried in solid, so no magnet can go in.
The page gives no sign of either. Checks doesn't warn, Download stays on, and the bad-edge count is no different from what boss plates already carry. Those plates show about 40 bad edges per piece from bosses meeting at shared corners, which the audit already sets aside as known.
Repro (Baseplates page, default 6 x 2 mm magnets from beneath, two 2 x 2 pieces):
- Bowtie keys in the floor:
#pi=42&w=168&d=84&mm=custom&ml=0&mr=0&mf=0&mb=0&bw=100&bd=400&cn=bowtie&km=floor&ki=bottom&mg=1&bm=bosses- The key recess (z 0 to 2.0 mm, 99.7 mm³ a piece) is 100% filled in both pieces. With a solid base it is empty.
- All 16 boss magnet pockets in each piece are buried: the keys force a 2.8 mm floor and the bosses are 2.6 mm tall.
- H-clip:
#pi=42&w=168&d=84&mm=custom&ml=0&mr=0&mf=0&mb=0&bw=100&bd=400&cn=hclip&ki=bottom&mg=1&bm=bosses- The clip pocket (z 0 to 2.3 mm, 14.9 mm³ a piece) is 100% filled. The pockets are open.
- Wall keys (
cn=bowtie&km=wall&ki=bottom) and the default dovetail (cn=dovetail) behave the same: the housing or notch is 100% filled, so the other piece's tab can't go in.
How far it reaches (pitches 36.13 to 55.7 mm, plain pairs and with half cells and margins):
- Every housing cut from beneath where four cells meet: bowtie, snap and puzzle key in the floor and in the wall, H-clip, dovetail notches and puzzle-tab notches.
- Wall keys, H-clip and dovetail are 100% filled at every pitch measured. Floor keys and puzzle tabs are 97 to 100% filled from 39.46 mm up, and 72 to 84% at 36.13 mm.
- Keys and H-clips put in from above aren't affected, because their housings start above the bosses.
- Magnets from beneath, magnets from above and screws all behave the same, since any of them builds the bosses.
- The magnet pockets are buried whenever the joint forces a floor at least as tall as the bosses: floor keys (2.8 mm) and puzzle tabs (2.6 mm).
Possible fix. Cut the joint's housing after the bosses are added, so the bosses can't fill it, and raise the bosses' pockets above a floor the joint adds. Alternatively, refuse bosses with a joint cut from beneath, and say why in Checks. Either way, the plate audit's boss cases should measure the housing, not only the bad edges.
Activity