Skip to content

fix(ci): ad-hoc sign hosted simulator app for Keychain acceptance - #7149

Closed
antuz123 wants to merge 425 commits into
sprintfrom
codex/r5-native-acceptance-20261024
Closed

antuz123 wants to merge 425 commits into
sprintfrom
codex/r5-native-acceptance-20261024

Conversation

@antuz123

@antuz123 antuz123 commented Oct 24, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

State: CLOSED_SUPERSEDED_NOT_ACCEPTED

Superseded by #7164, published source a23d9a9c92cb4cdddca03e07844a722805f74f24. This draft's complete source history is incorporated in that candidate.

This administrative closure grants no native, physical, security, combined R5 or release acceptance. All prior failures, NOT RUN items, handoffs, source-specific evidence and physical-scope decisions below remain unchanged. Continue work in #7164.


Frozen source d27007078808617a97ee460b592eefb44e7e5325 on integration8b56c6b51831e69f4b67a77754f431f5dcf4711c. Hosted window completed FAILURE / native acceptance NOT READY: 40065599904/attempt1. iOS then Android finished naturally; no job was cancelled or duplicated. The candidate source remains unchanged.

Actual exact-source results

Platform Passed scope Failed / incomplete
iOS job120788067210 Dependencies, driver readiness, build, new ad-hoc signature/effective-entitlement/identity checks, and full pre-UI installed bundle/executable byte comparison Startup smoke FAIL; persistence/workers/product checks SKIPPED
Android job120796675691 Build, startup smoke, native Realm/MMKV persistence probe, scoped source-bound R5 worker probes over native storage with disclosed controlled adapters, and repeated installed APK byte checks around completed phases First full-product first-wallet/relaunch sample FAIL(exit1); five-sample completion, separate Retry, key/PIN and companions incomplete

Metadata-only iOS readout#7152, run40070128621, recovered exact fixed observations: Maestro testcase ERROR; no owned startup-failure/error records; no recognized PIN/credential-error/Retry/logbox flags in one retained hierarchy;7Metro rows BEFORE_APP with warmupHTTP200 and zero APP_WINDOW rows. These observations and driver ConnectException markers do not prove process absence, startup cause or acceptance of the Keychain correction. Cause remains UNKNOWN. Original iOS ZIP12550480968/7339B/SHA2565891036cd8225b97c7edaff9bc057e2c70a8f8720e8f9def3ef0369de043d032; metadataSHAd18cabb86e5eb0a3de20f2cf31eb9ef17514f233f6c02e75c5660a8a00ca65db.

Android's exact failed UI command/current boundary facts are not exported in its public job log. Artifact12551461839/9596B/SHA256b9182e02a33b7e0568d73654b42d61f66bce8e425d65a6960aa0f4f2194ee13a preserves the metadata for bounded readout. The earlier044 installed-byte failure did not recur here; no Android correction or retrospective pass is claimed.

Bounded change and review

Six-file patch-only review,330additions/2deletions. The original044 iOS native Keychain rejection-34018 occurred after an unsigned build with unmeasured entitlements. This package signs only owned Debug/iphonesimulator output using ad-hoc identity-, verifies fixed synthetic CI entitlements and ad-hoc identity before built hashes, and rejects device/production bundles, extensions, aliases or unexpected entitlements. It changes no production entitlements or startup/Keychain error handling. Android only gains fixed installed-byte failure-stage diagnostics; all existing strict path/pull/hash checks remain.

Python368/368 host controls PASS; root independent source review CLEAR and independently reran7signing+9installed-byte controlsPASS. Actual simulator signature execution passed, but app acceptance remains failed. Producer/shared refs and original044 evidence remain preserved. No personal Mac, release signing, upload/distribution, merge, deployment or publication.

Codex local handoff

State: NEEDS_LOCAL
PR: #7149
Base: sprint
Head branch: codex/r5-native-acceptance-20261024
Head commit: d270070
Goal and acceptance criteria: Diagnose actual remaining startup/product failures from preserved observations before a separately coordinated future exact-source hosted window.
Changes made: Simulator-only ad-hoc signing/effective entitlement verification and fixed Android installed-byte failure diagnostics.
Cloud checks: Python368PASS; independentreviewCLEAR; exact-source40065599904 completedFAILURE with platform scope above; iOS bounded metadata readout7152PASS, observations only.
Required local checks: IOS, ANDROID, HARDWARE
Local checks requested: Hosted macOS/Android, no personal Mac; genuine physical checks remainUNRUN. No second native campaign selected.
Risks / known gaps: Startup/product causes UNKNOWN; full software matrix, physical checks, installed trusted-base acceptance and release gates incomplete. No release-readiness claim.

antuz123 and others added 30 commits October 13, 2026 03:25
redkeep-agents and others added 20 commits October 22, 2026 23:15
Source-review baseline only. Tree is exactly cd9d50a; second parent e343310 is preserved without producer rewriting. Its selected app and canonical collection changes are applied in separate reviewed descendants A and B. This baseline is not a native or release candidate.
Source-review join only. Tree is exactly B642fc14d1f2c3bd3451fe257642b01c6d1c07c95; second parent044ebb6ea2d465f6a70e9116e3feac5a604cd696 is preserved. Selected external thirteen-file work is exposed separately in C1 Android markers and C2 Maestro snapshot descendants. This join is not a native or release candidate.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Native selection record: one serialized hosted diagnostic window 40065599904/attempt1 is selected at frozen source d27007078808617a97ee460b592eefb44e7e5325. Root independently reviewed this exact patch CLEAR and independently ran seven simulator-signing plus nine installed-byte controls PASS. Author full Python controls368/368 PASS. Fresh global preflight found no active/queued native window; only nonnative CI/contracts and skipped PhaseA platform jobs existed. keeper/native-diagnostic was added exactly once; current route executes iOS then Android without cancellation. No other native run, source update or release operation is selected. Original044 failures remain preserved. Actual current native results are pending; host tests/review do not establish codesign/Keychain success or release readiness.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Exact-source iOS result / observation readout: d270 build, simulator ad-hoc signature/effective-entitlement checks and full pre-UI installed bundle/executable byte equality PASS. Startup smoke FAIL; later iOS persistence/workers/product checks SKIPPED. Metadata-only readout7152, 40070128621/a1, recovered fixed observations from original artifact12550480968/7339B/ZIP5891036cd8225b97c7edaff9bc057e2c70a8f8720e8f9def3ef0369de043d032; metadataSHA d18cabb86e5eb0a3de20f2cf31eb9ef17514f233f6c02e75c5660a8a00ca65db. Maestro testcase ERROR, no own startup-failure markers/error records, no recognized PIN/credential-error/Retry/logbox flags in one retained hierarchy. Seven Metro rows are BEFORE_APP (warmupHTTP200), zero APP_WINDOW rows. Missing observations and driver ConnectException markers are not process/cause proof; Keychain correction acceptance remains NOT VERIFIED. Reader source e7f52fc has matching before/after raw-source guards; readout supplies no native acceptance. Android continues in the original sole40065599904 window. No app source edit, second native run or release operation.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Terminal exact-source window: 40065599904/a1/d270 finished naturally FAILURE, no cancellation/rerun. iOS build/ad-hoc signature/effective entitlements/pre-UI installed bytes PASS; startup FAIL and later acceptance skipped (actual bounded readout7152 preserved). Android build/startup/nativeRealm-MMKV persistence/scoped R5 workers/repeated installed APK byte checks passed, then first full-product first-wallet/relaunch sample FAILED(exit1). Five healthy samples, Retry/key-PIN/companions remain incomplete. Android artifact12551461839/9596B/SHA256b9182e02a33b7e0568d73654b42d61f66bce8e425d65a6960aa0f4f2194ee13a retains the unexported exact failed-command/boundary facts for bounded readout. No Android product cause or earlier044 byte-failure fix is inferred. PR body now reports actual terminal scope; current head remains d270070. Native acceptance NOT READY; no second native window or release operation selected.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants