Skip to content

ci: reconcile frozen cloud release dependency inputs and setup handoff - #7096

Draft
antuz123 wants to merge 250 commits into
sprintfrom
codex/r5-cloud-release-reconciliation
Draft

antuz123 wants to merge 250 commits into
sprintfrom
codex/r5-cloud-release-reconciliation

Conversation

@antuz123

@antuz123 antuz123 commented Oct 22, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

The protected release stack correctly rejected CocoaPods1.16.2 Gem inputs paired with its inherited CocoaPods1.15.2 Pod lock. This isolated preparation pairs reviewed Ruby inputs with the reviewed native Pod/Nitro inputs, preserves that rejection, and adds Nitro-drift controls. No lock was regenerated. Release authorization remains disabled.

Published branch: codex/r5-cloud-release-reconciliation
Exact head: 945a0ee3c6af68eed70e412f948dcaab2f876150
Base: sprint
Reconciliation-only comparison. Base1748b4fcb is byte-identical to #7086; its separate cherry-pick preserves that producer. The ordinary sprint diff inherits separately reviewed R4/R5 packages.

The change keeps #7078 Gemfile/lock unchanged and copies only package.json/yarn.lock/ios/Podfile.lock from #7082/3eb92fc. Selected inputs: CocoaPods1.16.2, Xcodeproj1.27.0, Nitro0.36.5. The read-only checker reports five hashes and fixed false authorization/acceptance flags. Controls reject the original mismatch, manifest/Yarn/Pod Nitro drift, and quoted/combined duplicate Yarn selectors without changing inputs. Frozen Ruby contract paths cover every paired input. No native route or dispatch is added.

Committed deliverables:

24 October readback: this branch/PR/remote still agree on the exact head above. Worktree clean, zero unpublished commits, no direct replacement PR found. Current #7068 integration 8b56c6b51831e69f4b67a77754f431f5dcf4711c already contains all five dependency files byte-for-byte, verified by original Git blob identities; do not duplicate or reapply the dependency tuple. This older preparation branch is not the full current native app candidate. Native execution remains with its existing coordinator; no build/retry/dispatch/cancellation or source substitution was performed by this resume.

Actual validation on this source: Node22.23.3 contracts67 PASS; Python25 PASS; Ruby3.3.8/Bundler2.5.22 frozen118-gem install/check/load/project parse PASS; fake Ruby32runs175assertions PASS; frozen Yarn1.22.22 install/six isolated patches PASS; actual Nitro Yarn SHA512 and metadata-only Pod checksum PASS; actionlint4 PASS with unavailable shellcheck/pyflakes disabled; whitespace PASS. Fresh read-only input checker PASS with all five hashes unchanged. These are dependency/source/fake checks, not native or signing/store acceptance.

Completed exact-head hosted results:

Fresh safe metadata still returns exactly three environments (copilot, Env, keeper-claude-review); keeper-release-ios/android remain absent. Secret-name and variable-name reads still return403. Custody/signing/store identities, usable read identities and fresh store histories remain UNKNOWN. No credential values were requested or printed.

Current provenance successors are separate review packages: #7099 includes #7087 and implements analysis-origin binding; #7145/#7148 prepare installed parent/window admission and its authority-race correction; #7143 authenticates separate private origins; #7144 corrects per-suite source-proof scopes. Do not duplicate them or interpret their synthetic controls as installation/live acceptance. Additional nonsecret setup is KEEPER_CANONICAL_PRIVATE_WINDOW_JSON, requiring a separately reviewed finite installed profile; current installed policy/allowlists remain empty. KEEPER_CANONICAL_PIN_READ_TOKEN still needs separately approved least-privileged provisioning and live read preflight. Original public/private artifacts, complete canonical parents, official GAS-check/analysis linkage, effective protected enforcement and native/physical acceptance remain blockers. B1's private origin marker stays unminted.

The earlier handoff used NEEDS_CLOUD_VALIDATION, which the legacy gate rejects. The metadata below corrects the format only. NEEDS_LOCAL is the legacy label for missing IOS/ANDROID evidence; it does not require the owner's personal Mac, grant a waiver, or claim checks passed.

Codex local handoff

State: NEEDS_LOCAL
PR: #7096
Base: sprint
Head branch: codex/r5-cloud-release-reconciliation
Head commit: 945a0ee
Goal and acceptance criteria: Preserve reviewed frozen dependency compatibility and fail-closed release preparation; obtain genuine exact combined-source acceptance through the existing native coordinator.
Changes made: Reviewed Pod/Nitro tuple, read-only alignment report/drift controls, expanded frozen contracts and exact administrator/operator handoff.
Cloud checks: Node67/Python25/frozenRuby118/fakeRuby32-175/frozenYarn/sixpatches/Nitrochecks/actionlint4/diff PASS; hosted Ruby/preparation/backend/Tests PASS; overall CI automatic-backup matrix and official CodeQL security check FAIL.
Required local checks: IOS, ANDROID
Local checks requested: Hosted macOS/Xcode and Android acceptance only through the separately coordinated exact full-app source/window. Do not dispatch from this resume or use the older preparation app tree. No personal Mac or platform waiver.
Risks / known gaps: Dedicated release environments absent; signing/store custody and histories UNKNOWN; canonical parent/original provenance/installed profile/security linkage/protected enforcement and native/physical acceptance incomplete. Authorization disabled.
Release readiness: NOT READY; execution_allowed:false.

No signing, upload, credential/protection/configuration change, deployment, merge or publication of a release is authorized or performed. Producer branches and their original evidence remain preserved.

antuz123 and others added 30 commits September 25, 2026 21:28
Enable the release branch test trigger and repair the inert recovery provenance fixture exposed by that run. No production app code changes.
redkeep-agents and others added 21 commits October 19, 2026 13:34

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Cloud-only preparation validation

State: NEEDS_CLOUD_VALIDATION
Tested preparation head: 945a0ee3c6af68eed70e412f948dcaab2f876150

Frozen Yarn1.22.22/Node22.23.3 install PASS; six existing patches PASS only in an isolated dependency tree; all five source inputs unchanged. Actual Nitro0.36.5 package passes Yarn SHA512 and metadata-only CocoaPods1.16.2/RN0.83.9 spec checksum 5115360c2954442d8a6a4fafe836f7a5458815df. Frozen Ruby3.3.8/Bundler2.5.22 installed118gems, check/load/Xcode-project parse PASS; final Pod lock metadata parse PASS. Node67/Python25/fakeRuby32runs175assertions/actionlint4/whitespace PASS. The quoted/combined Yarn ambiguity found during independent source review is fixed and negative controls pass.

Exact-head hosted frozen Ruby 39832976533, attempt1, SUCCESS. Other general CI/native/security acceptance is not claimed. No pod install, native app build, signing, upload/provider operation or dispatch performed by this task.

Native-owner selection of one full combined source and hosted window remains pending coordination on #7082. #7084/#7085 coordination includes existing #7095/#7087 candidates. Dedicated environments absent; custody/signing/store identity UNKNOWN after safe metadata403. Exact one-time setup and reusable cloud-only procedure are committed. B1 unchanged/unminted; execution_allowed:false. No merge, deployment, credential/protection change or personal Mac dependency.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Native window coordination: the sole active app-acceptance source remains #7082 3eb92fc8a622a3e09926d49f47243c163e32d009, existing run39824790868 attempt2. Explicit latest-attempt job120011570058 has driver readiness PASS and app build running; Android remains its serialized continuation. This task did not trigger the retry and is adopting it. No mid-run source/Gem/input adoption or competing app build.

Current input SHA256s, verified byte-identical to3eb92fc: package.json0497b2aaeb76372a6f21721f28ebd42ec2877155a090580b23ace2e017fab6a8; yarn.lock60ef283fd7cfb1ac0a940216864d7a779e8449fd245c213d3148b92b97435b7b; ios/Podfile.lockb72b31df28a9dececdab9781d5d96785b2081e63cc1d7475941ecfbc624777b3; Gemfile7dac66befc114a51371e0fa1e03f2fe78fc30ded2fe9e363c36f3c4822bd1d9e; Gemfile.lock50772325dc74619d284e5eedf7f1f1a55fa0dba69edc140b33ef5e6908d8c51f. These are the currently running source inputs, not a claim that your reviewed frozen Ruby tuple has been integrated or accepted.

#7094 a319936 holds reviewed diagnostic preparation with its preflight label removed before push. No new native work is queued there. #7088/#7093 are visible separate additions; adopt/wire only in a deliberate later checkpoint if current evidence requires it, preserving exact-source receipts. Signing/release preparation stays separate and disabled.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Native-owner coordination update: original selected #7082/3eb92fc/run39824790868 attempt2 remains active through its existing Android120035062245 (build in progress), untouched. Its iOS driver/build passed, then simctl install timed out before UI; receipt #7082 comment6349304953. No Gem or app dependency changes were injected.

New setup evidence #7082 comment6349525136 demonstrates bootstatus can pass while listapps/Preferences queries still time out, then listapps responds later. Isolated #7094 correction checkpoint c79ab7c adds bounded read-only app-service readiness plus metadata-only startup diagnostics, keeping the exact3eb app/dependency tuple and existing Maestro/install deadlines. Hosted contracts39841406805 PASS108 Node/139 Python. A single setup-only correction check39841528773 is active; both Keeper app jobs SKIPPED. This is not a combined app acceptance pass or daemon-root-cause claim.

After that check and the original Android execution finish naturally, I will record one exact new-source app window before dispatch. Your frozen Ruby tuple remains separate reviewed preparation; it is not being silently substituted into an active run. No competing Android/app builds, release operation, personal Mac, merge, signing/upload or deployment.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

24 October checkpoint publication verified: branch codex/r5-cloud-release-reconciliation, PR #7096, commit 945a0ee3c6af68eed70e412f948dcaab2f876150. Clean worktree; remote equals HEAD; zero unpublished commits. No duplicate branch/PR or code change needed.

All five reviewed dependency Git blobs already match current #7068 integration 8b56c6b51831e69f4b67a77754f431f5dcf4711c exactly. Fresh read-only input checker PASS, hashes unchanged. Exact-head hosted Ruby39832976533/preparation39832976577/backend39832976570 and CI Tests PASS; CI remains FAILURE in the automatic-backup matrix, and official CodeQL security check120015424429 FAILS despite successful workflow execution. No native pass is transferred.

The PR handoff now uses the gate's required State: NEEDS_LOCAL; the former NEEDS_CLOUD_VALIDATION was a metadata-format error. This corrects no platform/security result and requests no personal Mac or new native run. Existing native coordinator retains the only source/window.

Fresh environment inventory still has only copilot,Env,keeper-claude-review; dedicated iOS/Android release environments absent. Secret/variable metadata403; signing/store custody/read identities/histories UNKNOWN. New provenance successor setup/adoption requirements (#7099/#7143/#7144/#7145/#7148) are recorded in the refreshed PR body, including the nonsecret reviewed-window JSON and currently empty installed policy. Do not duplicate those packages.

Remaining blockers: genuine exact-source native/full canonical parent acceptance and original artifacts; protected installation/finite policy/read identities/security linkage; separately authorized administrator/custodian setup and safe identity/store metadata. B1 remains disabled and execution_allowed:false. No build/dispatch/retry/cancellation, signing/upload, credential/configuration change, deployment or merge performed by this resume.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants