Repository navigation
Conversation
R4 review-policy integration continuation — 12 October 2026Current source head: Merged current The review policy now states the intended Copilot configuration without claiming a Markdown proposal changes GitHub settings. Native exact-head validation, independent human approval, product signoff and retrospective owner acceptance are separate gates. The unified lowercase template retains contributor test evidence/security considerations and an explicit link to product-owner decisions. Validation: Markdown links, newlines and conflict-marker checks passed; both handoff/validation formats and exact-SHA/independent/product requirements were asserted; the inherited validation workflow YAML parses; Live read-only settings audit: active Keeper PR Validation ruleset already requires Keep draft with independent approval pending. Intended effort: Lite for documentation/process; no completed Copilot review is claimed. #7030 and this PR both add |
Current-head CI boundaryPolicy source |
Policy CI verification retryOn unchanged source |
Cloud review now depends on actual severity, uncertainty, scope and cost; human developer review stays optional. Verified routine documentation, noncritical copy or pure style may skip a separate provider review with reason/evidence, but policy/security/agent/workflow documents cannot Skip. Bounded normal changes use Lite; signing, keys, authentication, recovery/backup, pairing, transactions, migrations, workflows, permissions, security dependencies/copy, cross-service/complex changes and unknown risk use Balanced.
Use the least-cost adequate authorized route, reuse valid exact-head/base coverage, make one initial review after stable checks and batch material fixes before necessary re-review. Independent coverage is needed only when an actual risk/finding requires it and an installed, authorized route/scope/budget exists. If scope, quota, cap or activation is unavailable, record unavailable and use another already-authorized adequate route or hold the applicable gate. Do not downgrade critical review, add paid retries/fallbacks or infer fresh allowance. Existing caps and historical balances do not activate a reviewer or grant budget; ordinary within-scope/allowance review does not need repeated permission.
Actual findings/dispositions, reviewed SHA/base/coverage and skipped/pending/unavailable results must be recorded. Required CI/status checks, substantive security concerns, native/device validation, product signoff and operation-specific signing/deployment/release authorization remain intact. Existing comment-only human CODEOWNERS suggestions remain optional and require no access grants.
Policy/docs/templates/agent instructions only: no runtime, workflow, R5 implementation, permission, secret, budget, merge or deployment change. No new provider request or paid review is claimed. Current recorded Copilot ready-PR automation, plus mobile every-push review, does not implement conditional triage; Markdown does not fix settings or install mobile reviewer #7049. Keep source preparation and installed automation status separate.
Historical receipts remain tied to exact original commits. Record current-head validation separately; skipped/unavailable review is not a clean review.
Preserve contributor #7030's unified lowercase template, contributor test/security sections and any required add/add reconciliation.
Current conditional-policy head:
54f6d420202fe7fdbfa280c11196d850b032f731. An existing cloud agent who did not author these policy edits independently reviewed the exact prepared patch (manifest SHA-256a0bf37b7be612932af8911e329899178f7db123c6b66aa0cd2a492df108b6a5a); no blocking finding. This is cloud-agent source evidence, not a completed Copilot/Claude provider review or formal GitHub approval. Fresh exact-head CI evidence follows. Policies remain draft/unmerged and live GitHub rules are unchanged: administrator access is still needed to remove enforced human approval and implement conditional triggering. No ready transition or new provider/paid review was requested.Fresh exact-head CI: Fresh exact-head CI39733626667 passed all183 tests across17 suites. CodeQL39733626420 and aggregate checks passed. keeper/local-validation passed through the documented docs/GitHub metadata-only exemption; no native/device test is claimed. Lint job conclusion is success under existing nonblocking configuration, but the lint command exited1 with5453problems(4540errors,913warnings); no clean-lint claim or new suppression.