Skip to content

Empty MCP dispatch registry vs advertised traycer_* tool surface — agents report false capability loss and misroute spend #8

Description

@kyledempster7

devin CLI 3000.6.14, macOS arm64, gui/devin swe-2-max, Traycer host 1.3.1 — 2026-09-13 ~08:25 UTC.

Agent-side harm from session-injected MCP servers that never reach the dispatch registry (companion to traycerai/traycer#873, #1858, #1877).

Sequence observed this session:

  1. Resumed session's system prompt still advertised traycer_a2a/traycer-browser under "Available MCP Servers" and instructed the agent to use traycer_send_message, traycer_get_self, traycer_agent_selection_guide.
  2. mcp_list_servers returned {"servers":[]}; mcp_list_tools("traycer_a2a") → "not found in configuration".
  3. The agent reported "I cannot create persistent named agents" to the user — a false capability report. The traycer CLI fallback was functional the whole time, but the prompt-vs-registry mismatch is invisible until the agent burns turns discovering it.
  4. When pushed, the agent used traycer agent create — which is billable on creation — duplicating two seats the user had already provisioned. Root cause of the overspend was the agent reasoning from a tool surface that didn't exist.

Asks for devin-cli:

  • If injected servers fail to register in the dispatch registry, do not render their tool names/instructions into the prompt — the two must never disagree.
  • mcp_list_servers should return CLI-backed servers or a warning when the registry is empty but servers were injected.
  • Repro path: resume/compact a session that had traycer_a2a injected; observe prompt still advertises it while the registry is empty.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions