You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
packaging: which Linux distributions and versions Rust OBS builds and tests for
#2365
AppImage: built in a glibc 2.28 image (build-aux/appimage/manylinux/Dockerfile). check-glibc-floor.sh fails the build if anything needs a newer glibc. It bundles Qt, FFmpeg and its own glibc, and uses the host's glibc and libstdc++ when they are newer. On paper it runs on Ubuntu 24.04 (glibc 2.39), 22.04 (2.35), Debian 12, RHEL/Rocky 8+, and the rolling distros.
So unlike upstream OBS 33, we already support Ubuntu 24.04 through the AppImage.
The gap: the AppImage is only started on CI's ubuntu-26.04 runner. No job runs it on 24.04, 22.04 or a glibc-2.28 distro, so 'runs on 24.04' rests on the glibc floor check, not on a test. Running test-appimage.sh in an ubuntu:24.04 container on the release gate would turn the claim into a tested fact. That job is cheap: it starts the AppImage, it doesn't rebuild it.
What each choice costs
24.04 .deb: a second deb build against 24.04's Qt 6.4 and FFmpeg 6.1. CMake sets no minimum Qt version, so whether the frontend builds against 6.4 is untested. If it does not, the .deb would have to bundle Qt. The AppImage already covers these users, so I'd skip it.
Correction to my comment above: the AppImage was already tested beyond the CI runner. My search missed .github/workflows/appimage.yaml, whose release-gate matrix runs it on almalinux:8 (the glibc 2.28 floor), ubuntu:22.04 and archlinux:latest. #2357 (merged) added ubuntu:24.04 and closed #2353. Ubuntu 24.04 users are now covered by a tested AppImage, and the README lists the tested distributions.
reacted with thumbs up emoji reacted with thumbs down emoji reacted with laugh emoji reacted with hooray emoji reacted with confused emoji reacted with heart emoji reacted with rocket emoji reacted with eyes emoji
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Moved from issue #2230 by the coordinator (listed under "Might move to Discussions" in #2234).
From the Hacker News thread on OBS Studio 33 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50218430). Part of the meta issue.
Discussion candidate.
What users said
A user was surprised that OBS 33 dropped Ubuntu 24.04.
Comments: 50224337
Discussion prompt
Which distros/versions do we target (24.04 LTS or newer only), and what does each choice cost in Qt, FFmpeg and CEF versions?
If there is no agreed design, move this to Discussions (coordination.md section 5).
@zackees (issue comment):
Facts for the discussion, from master on 2026-10-25. No decision is made here.
What OBS-Studio-Rust ships today
release-rust.yaml:65,614; since release: Name the .deb after the Ubuntu release it needs #2324 the file is named after the Ubuntu release it needs). Ubuntu 24.04 users can't install it.build-aux/appimage/manylinux/Dockerfile).check-glibc-floor.shfails the build if anything needs a newer glibc. It bundles Qt, FFmpeg and its own glibc, and uses the host's glibc and libstdc++ when they are newer. On paper it runs on Ubuntu 24.04 (glibc 2.39), 22.04 (2.35), Debian 12, RHEL/Rocky 8+, and the rolling distros.org.freedesktop.Platform26.08, which brings its own libraries and doesn't care about the host distro version.So unlike upstream OBS 33, we already support Ubuntu 24.04 through the AppImage.
The gap: the AppImage is only started on CI's
ubuntu-26.04runner. No job runs it on 24.04, 22.04 or a glibc-2.28 distro, so 'runs on 24.04' rests on the glibc floor check, not on a test. Runningtest-appimage.shin anubuntu:24.04container on the release gate would turn the claim into a tested fact. That job is cheap: it starts the AppImage, it doesn't rebuild it.What each choice costs
@zackees (issue comment):
Correction to my comment above: the AppImage was already tested beyond the CI runner. My search missed
.github/workflows/appimage.yaml, whose release-gate matrix runs it onalmalinux:8(the glibc 2.28 floor),ubuntu:22.04andarchlinux:latest. #2357 (merged) addedubuntu:24.04and closed #2353. Ubuntu 24.04 users are now covered by a tested AppImage, and the README lists the tested distributions.All reactions