diff --git a/lib/recode/task/alias_order.ex b/lib/recode/task/alias_order.ex
index f9be2418..06a6f7f6 100644
--- a/lib/recode/task/alias_order.ex
+++ b/lib/recode/task/alias_order.ex
@@ -214,7 +214,7 @@ defmodule Recode.Task.AliasOrder do
   defp lower_than?([value1 | _], [value2 | _]), do: lower_than?(value1, value2)
 
   defp lower_than?(value1, value2) when is_atom(value1) and is_atom(value2) do
-    String.upcase(to_string(value1)) < String.upcase(to_string(value2))
+    String.downcase(to_string(value1)) < String.downcase(to_string(value2))
   end
 
   defp sort_multi({:alias, meta1, [{{:., meta2, [aliases, opts]}, meta3, multi}]}) do
diff --git a/test/recode/task/alias_order_test.exs b/test/recode/task/alias_order_test.exs
index 1844159c..680c3548 100644
--- a/test/recode/task/alias_order_test.exs
+++ b/test/recode/task/alias_order_test.exs
@@ -67,16 +67,20 @@ defmodule Recode.Task.AliasOrderTest do
     code = """
     defmodule MyModule do
       alias Beta
-      alias __MODULE__
+      alias __MODULE__.Zulu
       alias Alpha
+      alias __MODULE__.Alpha
+      alias __MODULE__
     end
     """
 
     expected = """
     defmodule MyModule do
+      alias __MODULE__
+      alias __MODULE__.Alpha
+      alias __MODULE__.Zulu
       alias Alpha
       alias Beta
-      alias __MODULE__
     end
     """
 
@@ -96,9 +100,9 @@ defmodule Recode.Task.AliasOrderTest do
 
     expected = """
     defmodule MyModule do
+      alias __MODULE__, as: Charlie
       alias Alpha, as: Gamma
       alias Beta, as: Delta
-      alias __MODULE__, as: Charlie
     end
     """
 
@@ -355,9 +359,9 @@ defmodule Recode.Task.AliasOrderTest do
     test "reports an issue for unsorted aliases in multi with and without __MODULE__" do
       """
       defmodule MyModule do
+        alias __MODULE__.{UserSocket, Endpoint}
         alias Alpha.Bravo
         alias Alpha.Bravo.{Charlie, Delta}
-        alias __MODULE__.{UserSocket, Endpoint}
       end
       """
       |> run_task(AliasOrder, autocorrect: false)