|
| 1 | +# N3 bounded pilot, gates G1–G4 — report |
| 2 | + |
| 3 | +**Result: `KILL-N3-PILOT` at G3.** On the pre-registered independent sample the PoC gives 0 product warnings, fewer |
| 4 | +than the required 5 ("not enough data for a GO"). The sample is not widened. G1 and G2 passed; G4 is not run. |
| 5 | + |
| 6 | +Rules: [`01-preregistration-g1-g4.md`](01-preregistration-g1-g4.md), committed in `797f74c5` before any PoC code. |
| 7 | +Authority: `ACCEPT-PASS-G0 / GO-G1-PREREG-AND-BOUNDED-EXECUTION / NO-PRODUCTION`. Time used: 20:23–21:00 +05 on |
| 8 | +2026-10-20, inside the one agent-day budget. |
| 9 | + |
| 10 | +Nothing in production, OwnIR, CI or goldens was touched. Third-party code was parsed only. Trees were exported with |
| 11 | +`git archive` from shallow fetches; nothing was restored or built (D13 isolation rule). The PoC itself was built |
| 12 | +outside `source/repos` with a nuget.org-only config and no package reference. |
| 13 | + |
| 14 | +## 1. Gate summary |
| 15 | + |
| 16 | +| Gate | Verdict | Evidence | |
| 17 | +|---|---|---| |
| 18 | +| G1 tiny PoC | **PASS** | 3/3 required pairs report on the buggy tree at a line the fix changes. Each fixed tree is silent on the touched code (§3) | |
| 19 | +| G2 negative controls | **PASS** | C1–C15 silent, and the 15 positive samples reported, on PoC v2 (`data/g1/controls_v2.tsv`) | |
| 20 | +| G3 independent precision | **KILL** | 27 repositories, **0** warnings (§4) | |
| 21 | +| G4 practical yield | not run | stopped at G3 | |
| 22 | + |
| 23 | +## 2. One implementation fix between the first and the scored run (disclosed) |
| 24 | + |
| 25 | +PoC v1 (`6a44d991`) was correct on the control file. On DotNetCloud#43 it produced 3 extra D3b warnings, from two |
| 26 | +departures from §3 of the pre-registration: |
| 27 | + |
| 28 | +- it accepted a call to a `void` same-class method as D3b, while §3 defines D3b as a discarded Task call |
| 29 | + (`_ = MAsync(…)`); |
| 30 | +- it took an `await` inside a nested lambda as the callee's first `await`. |
| 31 | + |
| 32 | +v2 (`602d4a89`) applies §3 as written and also records the capture line. No ownership or detachment rule changed. |
| 33 | +Control C15 covers this case; the pre-registration allows adding controls after the first run. v1 output is kept in |
| 34 | +`data/g1/warnings_v1.tsv`. |
| 35 | + |
| 36 | +One input mistake was also corrected before scoring. The buggy tree was first taken as the merge commit's parent. |
| 37 | +For mars-vista-api#26, which was rebase-merged from several commits, that parent already contains the fix. The |
| 38 | +scored run uses the PR's `base.sha`, and `base.sha` is an ancestor of the fix commit in all six pairs |
| 39 | +(`data/g1/pairs.tsv`). |
| 40 | + |
| 41 | +## 3. G1 — pairs |
| 42 | + |
| 43 | +Each warning's call line or capture line was checked against the fix diff with |
| 44 | +[`scripts/g1_touched.py`](scripts/g1_touched.py). The result is `data/g1/touched_v2.tsv`. |
| 45 | + |
| 46 | +| Pair | Buggy tree | Fixed tree | |
| 47 | +|---|---|---| |
| 48 | +| mars-vista-api#26 (required) | `UsageTrackingMiddleware.cs:63` S1×D3b: `_ = TrackUsageAsync(context, …)`, with `context` used after the callee's first `await`. Line removed by the fix | silent on the touched file | |
| 49 | +| DotNetCloud#43 (required) | `VideoIndexingCallback.cs:366` S3×D1: discarded `Task.Run` using `_seriesService`, capture line 371 removed by the fix. Holder `VideoIndexingCallback` and `IVideoSeriesService` are both proven scoped (R3, S3) | silent on the touched file | |
| 50 | +| DFY-BE#35 (required) | `AuthController.cs:70` S3×D3a: `_ = _notificationService.NotifyAdminsAsync(…)`, line changed by the fix | 0 warnings | |
| 51 | +| Vendorea#49 (reported only) | `AdminFtpIngestionController.cs:272` S4×D1, capture line 276 changed by the fix | 0 warnings | |
| 52 | +| microting#1669 (reported only) | silent: the holder `ContentHandoverService` is registered transient, which is not request-bound in this slice | silent | |
| 53 | +| escalated#162 (reported only) | silent: `WebhookDispatcher` is scoped, but `EscalatedDbContext` is registered by the consuming app, not in the repository, so S2 is unproven | silent | |
| 54 | + |
| 55 | +Warnings in the pair repositories outside the fixed code were not scored, and are recorded as possible further |
| 56 | +instances only. They are present on both trees: |
| 57 | + |
| 58 | +- mars-vista `UserApiKeyAuthenticationMiddleware.cs:153`: `context.RequestServices` inside a discarded `Task.Run`; |
| 59 | +- DotNetCloud `VideoController.cs:838` (D3a) and `:1462` (D1). |
| 60 | + |
| 61 | +## 4. G3 — the independent sample |
| 62 | + |
| 63 | +- **Input.** The 28 pre-registered repositories at their pinned SHAs, with saved facts from the `e7d33e33` |
| 64 | + extractor. dnSpy has no facts, because the extractor crashed on it in D11 (N13), so 27 were scanned. |
| 65 | +- **Result.** 0 warnings in 27 repositories (`data/g3/summary.tsv`, `data/g3/run.log`). The PoC saw 1,929 |
| 66 | + request-bound types and only 7 detached sites, all of them without a proven scope-owned use. |
| 67 | +- **Independent check that 0 is not a blind spot.** A plain grep was run for statement-level `Task.Run` / |
| 68 | + `Task.Factory.StartNew`, `_ = …Async(…)` and `QueueBackgroundWorkItem` in non-test paths |
| 69 | + (`data/g3/crosscheck_grep.tsv`). |
| 70 | + - It found 526 sites. 13 are in types whose name or base contains `Controller`, `PageModel` or `Hub`. |
| 71 | + - Of those, the real ASP.NET controllers are Jackett `ServerConfigurationController` (a static helper), Radarr |
| 72 | + `SystemController` (`_lifecycleService`) and Jellyfin `LibraryStructureController`. Jellyfin's |
| 73 | + `ILibraryManager` and `ILibraryMonitor` are `AddSingleton` (`ApplicationHost.cs:577`, `:583`). |
| 74 | + - The rest match by name only: Duplicati's `Controller` classes and a WPF gallery. |
| 75 | + - None captures a scope-owned object, so the PoC's silence matches the code. |
| 76 | + |
| 77 | +The sample is mostly libraries. Only about 7 of the 27 are request-serving web applications: OrchardCore, eShop, |
| 78 | +bitwarden, nopCommerce, Jellyfin, Radarr and Jackett. This was known when the sample was fixed, and the |
| 79 | +pre-registration forbids widening it after the run. |
| 80 | + |
| 81 | +## 5. What this does and does not show |
| 82 | + |
| 83 | +Confirmed: |
| 84 | +- The narrow slice (§2/§3) finds the three required real defects and stays silent on their fixes and on 15 |
| 85 | + negative controls. |
| 86 | +- Mature code in the fixed sample contains no instance of the slice: 0 by the PoC and 0 by an independent grep. |
| 87 | + |
| 88 | +Inference: the class recurs in young applications, as Phase 0 found (7 of 8 repos with 0–4 stars). Here it was not |
| 89 | +observed in mature code, which matches what D11 recorded for C10 (mature-code yield 0). |
| 90 | + |
| 91 | +Not shown: |
| 92 | +- Precision is unmeasured; there were no warnings to measure it on. |
| 93 | +- Yield on a sample of mature **web applications** only was not tested. |
| 94 | +- The silent S-unknown cases were not counted by kind: transient `IDisposable`, consumer-registered `DbContext`, |
| 95 | + transient holders, factory lambdas. |
| 96 | + |
| 97 | +## 6. Files |
| 98 | + |
| 99 | +- [`01-preregistration-g1-g4.md`](01-preregistration-g1-g4.md): the rules. |
| 100 | +- [`controls/N3NegativeControls.cs`](controls/N3NegativeControls.cs): controls C1–C15 and positive samples. |
| 101 | +- [`poc/`](poc/): the PoC (Roslyn, no package reference). |
| 102 | +- [`scripts/n3_run.py`](scripts/n3_run.py): the runner. |
| 103 | +- [`scripts/g1_touched.py`](scripts/g1_touched.py): the diff check. |
| 104 | +- `data/g1/`: pairs with SHAs, v1 and v2 warnings, the diff check and control output. |
| 105 | +- `data/g3/`: per-repository summary, run log and the grep cross-check. |
0 commit comments