diff --git a/docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-cleanup.md b/docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-cleanup.md index df098f92..677c31aa 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-cleanup.md +++ b/docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-cleanup.md @@ -146,3 +146,10 @@ The Git read wrapper now explicitly sets core.commitGraph=false, so ancestry/tre ### Prevention review boundary — 2026-10-16 [All eight complete original reports](../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-prevention.md) and their independently verified digests preserve both fresh complementary rounds, Low `fb9e4b9` and Medium `588edbf` actual committed-fix/peer reconciliation. Both groups are closed; zero unresolved. Current guide/standards/skill and full-history required-job wiring implement Accepted ADR-0044. Final candidate validation, exact development-only lease, actual hosted gates and ordinary remote clone remain; T-056 stays In Progress until those delivery gates pass. No further rewrite is planned for new maintenance commits. + + +### Published validation and maintainer merge — 2026-10-16 + +Candidate F `daeda787b3a5ec5221085a1daf4eca5aecbd1857` passed final local validation, then exactly development was published with the approved full original97 lease. The actual PR fell to 217 files / +31,969 / -3,003. [PR CI38819949187](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/actions/runs/38819949187) and [push CI38819940955](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/actions/runs/38819940955) each pass all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts. Critical Linux logs confirm 161/124/23 fixture methods, 407-file/7306-target/1276-fragment/zero corpus and zero footprint findings. A fresh ordinary full remote clone passes full Git integrity, both-runtime corpus checks and the guard, has zero candidate paths across all 481 fetched-ref trees, and a 6,791,580-byte (6.477 MiB) pack. Original six checker/fixture blobs and all Rust bytes remain equal; the compact catalog pair is 26,796 bytes. + +Before the handoff-only documentation commit, the maintainer merged PR49 and explicitly authorized Done. Actual merge `52fa323d20d92531add563561376a22ae607a537` occurred 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z / 2026-10-16T01:55:20+03:00; its tree equals F exactly. [First-main CI38820329507](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/actions/runs/38820329507) passes all seven jobs / six app-15368 contexts and 161/124/23 fixtures. The [completion retrospective](../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records actual main smoke, current lifecycle and source boundaries. T-049/T-056 maintenance closes without carry-forward; all twelve selected tasks become Done with local completion/authorization date 2026-10-16. The author did not merge PR49 or change main/protection; main advanced through the maintainer's merge. Normal development ancestry/bookkeeping followups preserve reviewed source and do not repeat the history rewrite. Physical backend erasure is not claimed, and the maintainer's old local objects/backups are not pruned. diff --git a/docs/analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md b/docs/analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..65d192a8 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md @@ -0,0 +1,271 @@ +# Business review 2026-10-16 — Phase B.2 Track B.2-2 completion + +Track B.2-2 and all twelve selected tasks are Done after maintainer merge, explicit completion authorization and verified first-main gates. This retrospective records delivery and remaining work; Phase B.2 remains Active. + +- **Trigger:** maintainer-initiated following bridge-track completion; bridge tracks are distinct from numbered milestones, as in the previous Track B.2-1 retrospective. +- **Scope:** T-045–T-056, approved evidence-retention maintenance and PR49 post-merge bookkeeping. +- **Period:** 2026-10-12 approved preflight through 2026-10-16 completion. The [previous Track B.2-1 retrospective](2026-10-12-phase-b2-track1-completion.md) was read; its delivered CI/prerequisite work remains Done. +- **Participants:** @cemililik (merge and explicit completion authorization); Codex as scribe, all five business-review roles sequentially. This is not a new independent promotion/code/security verdict. + +## What landed + +**Commits:** Reviewed development source `daeda787b3a5ec5221085a1daf4eca5aecbd1857` became merged main `52fa323d20d92531add563561376a22ae607a537` through [PR49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49). Their complete trees are identical. GitHub reports merge at **2026-10-15 22:55:20 UTC**, which is **2026-10-16 01:55:20 Europe/Istanbul**. Task date_done is the local completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; neither original source IDs nor UTC timestamps are rewritten. + +The tree-preserving normal merge `a0b3df3` records the squash ancestry on development, so later PRs do not replay this delivery. It changes no file and switches no branch; local main remains untouched. The original history/commit map and all 804 migrated payloads remain recoverable through the [immutable archive catalog](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md) and [recovery guide](../../../guides/review-evidence.md). + +
+Complete B.2-2 commit chronicle, ce4f999..daeda78 (oldest first) + +- `ce4f999` (2026-10-12) — docs(adr): propose ADR-0041 and ADR-0042 test naming policies; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `289f461` (2026-10-12) — docs(adr): propose ADR-0043 documentation consistency policy; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `2f963e2` (2026-10-12) — docs(adr): align ADR-0043 dependency execution order; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `519501f` (2026-10-12) — docs(roadmap): record maintainer copyright identity; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `fb23823` (2026-10-12) — docs(analysis): code-review phase-b2-track2-preflight; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `aff9ff4` (2026-10-12) — docs(adr): reconcile ADR-0041-0043 review findings; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `7ccdde4` (2026-10-12) — docs(roadmap): require Acceptance-time rider consistently; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `114be85` (2026-10-12) — docs(analysis): record ADR proposal follow-up reviews; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `862bfb6` (2026-10-12) — docs(adr): accept ADR-0041 historical prefix recovery; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `714c74b` (2026-10-12) — docs(adr): supersede ADR-0041 with ADR-0042; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `a72bea8` (2026-10-12) — docs(adr): accept ADR-0043 and clarify ADR-0040; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `667dca8` (2026-10-12) — docs(roadmap): apply approved Track B.2-2 task contracts; T-045, T-046, T-047, T-048, T-049, T-050, T-051, T-052, T-053, T-054, T-055, T-056. +- `528893f` (2026-10-12) — docs(roadmap): resolve Step 0 contract review findings; T-047, T-052, T-053, T-055. +- `50f21ca` (2026-10-12) — docs(review): record Track B.2-2 Step 0 review rounds; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `4ffda15` (2026-10-12) — docs(docs): describe current contribution and EL0 boundary; T-051. +- `d6cb853` (2026-10-13) — docs(review): record T-051 code and security rounds; T-051. +- `4ad0b3d` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): start T-045 architecture refresh; T-045. +- `6df0640` (2026-10-13) — docs(arch): refresh overview and running task loader; T-045. +- `596b935` (2026-10-13) — docs(arch): narrow caller and transfer verification claims; T-045. +- `dd5891c` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): record T-045 code and security review rounds; T-045. +- `85f02f2` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): start T-046 subsystem architecture refresh; T-046. +- `4d4791f` (2026-10-13) — docs(arch): reconcile seven subsystem chapters with live EL0; T-046. +- `661abf9` (2026-10-13) — docs(arch): correct frame, mapping and idle boundary claims; T-046. +- `f96e9f3` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): record T-046 code and security review rounds; T-045, T-046. +- `dd16eb7` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): start T-048 Phase B task corpus reconciliation; T-048. +- `fe2a813` (2026-10-13) — docs(tasks): reconcile merged Phase B records and task navigation; T-048. +- `7345bcd` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): clarify T-048 implementation verification provenance; T-048. +- `5f9cf58` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): record both T-048 review rounds; T-048. +- `9ca92fe` (2026-10-13) — docs(tasks): start T-049 review corpus reconciliation; T-049. +- `3423173` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): reconcile T-049 review discovery and historical evidence; T-049. +- `0d7cbff` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): preserve T-049 quoted proposal evidence; T-049. +- `7b99e25` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): code-review T-049 corpus reconciliation; T-045, T-049. +- `2e0a7e5` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): start T-050 entry-document refresh; T-050. +- `7fa4e1b` (2026-10-13) — docs(guides): refresh T-050 entry documents; T-050. +- `8301076` (2026-10-13) — docs(guides): clarify capability-table pointer binding; T-050. +- `e17636a` (2026-10-13) — docs(glossary): clarify bridge implementation gate; T-050. +- `0ad18a9` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): code-review T-050 entry-document refresh; T-050. +- `6497779` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): start T-055 scoped ADR corrections; T-055. +- `6bfc586` (2026-10-13) — docs(adr): reconcile T-055 corrections and index metadata; T-055. +- `f74e05f` (2026-10-13) — docs(adr): resolve T-055 first-round clarifications; T-055. +- `dba1819` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): code-review T-055 ADR corrections; T-055. +- `c9ee6e5` (2026-10-13) — docs(standards): start T-052 and T-053 reconciliation; T-052, T-053. +- `bd3d354` (2026-10-13) — docs(standards): reconcile T-052 naming and runtime claims; T-052. +- `a7ae1b6` (2026-10-13) — docs(standards): align T-053 tooling and configuration facts; T-052, T-053. +- `a0e201f` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): code-review T-052 and T-053 standards; T-052, T-053. +- `6bcb14a` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): start T-054 planned ADR identity migration; T-054. +- `41bea63` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): give planned ADRs stable purpose identities; T-054. +- `076aa83` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): correct Phase I planning note; T-054. +- `94c44d2` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): code-review T-054 planned ADR identities; T-054. +- `c0811a9` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): start T-047 live-state reconciliation; T-047. +- `eedeec8` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): separate live state from historical snapshots; T-047. +- `978396d` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): code-review T-047 roadmap state reconciliation; T-047. +- `0832a36` (2026-10-13) — docs(roadmap): start T-056 consistency parser; T-056. +- `6ffb78f` (2026-10-13) — docs(analysis): clarify quoted historical reference syntax; T-049, T-056. +- `a47736e` (2026-10-13) — feat(tooling): add offline documentation navigation checks; T-056. +- `69053f0` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): enforce documentation parser input and syntax boundaries; T-056. +- `9890f3f` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): preserve source-specific entity decoding; T-056. +- `b660b28` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): preserve numeric reference scalars across Python versions; T-056. +- `25feeb3` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): preserve URL identity and physical source lines; T-056. +- `11cc382` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): isolate multiline HTML attribute metadata; T-056. +- `3bc202d` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): isolate GFM table cell navigation; T-056. +- `c995e5f` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): respect physical and comment block boundaries; T-056. +- `6f8d2eb` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): share paragraph layout and preserve raw HTML tails; T-056. +- `e5f2434` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): bound setext headings to actual paragraphs; T-056. +- `e08a86a` (2026-10-13) — fix(tooling): preserve container columns and visible heading text; T-056. +- `9b42b9e` (2026-10-15) — fix(tooling): retain source context in heading anchors; T-056. +- `8eea75e` (2026-10-15) — fix(tooling): preserve original inline token boundaries; T-056. +- `5723a8a` (2026-10-15) — fix(tooling): bound failed emphasis searches and URI controls; T-056. +- `b332ad7` (2026-10-15) — docs(analysis): code-review t056-parser; T-049, T-056. +- `d9ca0d8` (2026-10-15) — feat(tooling): share guarded corpus reads for consistency checks; T-056. +- `be1a8e1` (2026-10-15) — feat(tooling): reconcile task and ADR index metadata; T-056. +- `7e0dc0e` (2026-10-15) — feat(tooling): reconcile review index membership; T-056. +- `9740642` (2026-10-15) — feat(tooling): validate planned ADR identities and standard fences; T-056. +- `4a9ab22` (2026-10-15) — feat(tooling): reconcile unsafe audit references across workspace; T-056. +- `7575b93` (2026-10-15) — feat(tooling): validate delimited live roadmap state; T-056. +- `6dfaac6` (2026-10-15) — feat(tooling): enforce offline documentation consistency; T-056. +- `6131464` (2026-10-15) — fix(tooling): close documentation integration review gaps; T-056. +- `45ef6d0` (2026-10-15) — fix(tooling): finish source and live-context boundary repairs; T-056. +- `cf00acd` (2026-10-15) — fix(tooling): require complete custom HTML block tags; T-056. +- `54de2e6` (2026-10-15) — docs(analysis): retain t056 integration round-one review; T-056. +- `83ac9af` (2026-10-15) — fix(tooling): preserve metadata source context; T-056. +- `8f522c2` (2026-10-15) — docs(analysis): code-review t056 integration; T-056. +- `2adf97c` (2026-10-15) — docs(roadmap): reconcile track b2-2 delivery readiness; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `58ce8d7` (2026-10-15) — docs(analysis): correct root readme evidence links; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `54581e1` (2026-10-15) — docs(analysis): code-review phase b2-2 integration; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `26ce16b` (2026-10-16) — docs(adr): propose ADR-0044 — review evidence retention; T-049, T-056. +- `b9f8f12` (2026-10-16) — docs(adr): keep retention decision inside the index table; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `5275ede` (2026-10-16) — docs(adr): clarify evidence hosting before retention acceptance; T-056. +- `cf253e3` (2026-10-16) — docs(analysis): code-review pr49 evidence governance; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `7f2eba3` (2026-10-16) — docs(adr): accept ADR-0044 evidence retention policy; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `32bdc16` (2026-10-16) — docs(roadmap): start approved pr49 archival maintenance; T-049, T-056. +- `86484e6` (2026-10-16) — docs(analysis): archive pr49 evidence and reconcile citations; T-045, T-046, T-047, T-049, T-050, T-052, T-053, T-054, T-055, T-056. +- `3a17c3d` (2026-10-16) — docs(roadmap): record the completed local evidence migration; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `433d42d` (2026-10-16) — docs(analysis): code-review pr49 archive and citation migration; T-049. +- `803ff08` (2026-10-16) — docs(tooling): scope the approved footprint enforcement; T-056. +- `2d83602` (2026-10-16) — ci(tooling): enforce review evidence storage bounds; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `fb9e4b9` (2026-10-16) — fix(tooling): classify unresolved footprint roots; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `588edbf` (2026-10-16) — fix(tooling): read original ancestry for footprint checks; shared governance/integration/evidence. +- `daeda78` (2026-10-16) — docs(analysis): code-review pr49 footprint prevention; shared governance/integration/evidence. + +
+ +The chronicle starts with this track's first proposals; older unsquashed B.2-1 ancestors are already covered by the previous retrospective. Associations come from subjects/changed task/evidence paths and are not new execution assertions. Original-to-rewritten mappings retain historical review identities rather than relabeling every result as the squash SHA. + +**ADRs:** + +- [ADR-0041](../../../decisions/0041-test-name-prefix-policy-recovery.md): historical prefix-rule recovery, Superseded by ADR-0042; separate recovery and atomic replacement transitions preserved. +- [ADR-0042](../../../decisions/0042-descriptive-test-names.md): Accepted descriptive test naming. +- [ADR-0043](../../../decisions/0043-documentation-corpus-consistency.md): Accepted whole-public-corpus consistency and reviewed execution;32 live planned purpose identities replace tentative numeric promises. +- [ADR-0044](../../../decisions/0044-review-evidence-retention.md): Accepted durable evidence delivery and bounded storage policy. ADR-0040/0025 authority and reserved 0034 remain unchanged; this bookkeeping adds no decision. + +**Tasks closed (all date_done 2026-10-16):** + +- [T-045](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md): Refresh the entry-point architecture docs (overview, task-loader, architecture index). +- [T-046](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md): Refresh the subsystem architecture chapters (hal, scheduler, exceptions, security-model, memory-management, boot, ipc). +- [T-047](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md): Synchronise roadmap live state and phase index. +- [T-048](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md): Synchronise the Phase B task corpus and fix task-file links. +- [T-049](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-049-review-indices-sync.md): Synchronise the review-family indices. +- [T-050](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md): Refresh README, guides index, glossary, and the add-bsp skill trace. +- [T-051](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md): Update CONTRIBUTING.md and SECURITY.md to the post-Phase-B state. +- [T-052](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md): Reconcile standards claims with CI and lint reality (decisions required). +- [T-053](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md): Apply mechanical corrections to the standards docs. +- [T-054](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md): Cascade the ADR ledger renumbering across phase files. +- [T-055](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md): Apply append-only corrections to Accepted ADRs. +- [T-056](../../tasks/phase-b2/T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md): Automate docs-corpus consistency checks (polish; optional for exit). + +All 58 opening findings have their existing ownership/dispositions in the [integrated readiness record](../../reports/2026-10-15-phase-b2-track2-completion-readiness.md). The original 156 criteria plus five approved maintenance criteria now total **161/161 checked**. Maintainer merge and explicit completion instruction supply the human SECURITY-wording approval authority for T-051; no agent claims to have performed that human review or invents a GitHub submitted-review event. T-056's maintenance no longer remains In Progress: actual archival, prevention, remote lease, hosted and clean-clone gates are complete. Earlier dated pending/In Review statements remain historical. + +Every implementation step completed its two fresh independent rounds; security-sensitive descriptions have separate security evidence. All three retention units completed two different fresh complementary rounds with actual committed-fix verification; four unique cleanup groups are closed (release scope, live pointer, root-resolution portability and commit-graph cache ancestry). Canonical [governance](../code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-governance.md), [migration](../code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-migration.md) and [prevention](../code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-prevention.md) reports preserve complete originals and differing verdicts. No unresolved verified scoped finding. + +### Actual hosted and clone evidence + +| Source/evidence | Observed result | +|-----------------|-----------------| +| Final PR source `daeda78`: [PR38819949187](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/actions/runs/38819949187), [push38819940955](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/actions/runs/38819940955) | Both runs pass all seven jobs and all six exact required app-15368 contexts; native ARM/Miri and debug/release QEMU included | +| Merged main `52fa323`: [first-main38820329507](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/actions/runs/38820329507) | All seven jobs and all six app-15368 contexts pass; critical Linux logs independently inspected | +| Linux at both actual sources |161 navigation /124 metadata /23 footprint methods pass; corpus407 Markdown files /7306 targets /1276 fragments /zero; footprint zero findings | +| Full live protection read-back | Structurally equal to frozen definition; strict six-context/app policy unchanged. Coverage remains informational | +| Ordinary full remote clone of `daeda78`, no filter/depth/single-branch option | Full Git integrity, guard and both Python3.9/3.13 corpus runs pass; zero migrated candidate paths across 481 fetched-ref trees; six original checker blobs equal | +| Physical packed store measured in that clone |6,791,580 bytes =6.477MiB. Previously measured maintainer packed store63.50MiB is a separate earlier observation, not GitHub backend erasure/accounting | +| Final merged PR footprint |217 files,+31,969/-3,003 versus original 1,008 files,+956,905/-3,003. Exactly 804 raw files/134,293,614 current-tree bytes relocated losslessly ; 348 citations/46 documents reconciled | +| Compact catalog |26,796 bytes for the Markdown/JSON pair, within 128 KiB; full manifest remains archived | + +These are actual hosted executions and inspected downloads, not a new local Rust/QEMU/Miri rerun. Existing six checker/fixture sources and all tracked Rust bytes equal original97; the PR's two HAL edits are documentation comments. New closure edits affect documentation/status only. All existing family indexes and companion/master-run discovery are checked through the full corpus; original review dates/verdicts remain unchanged. No architecture source marker is relabeled as freshly reverified at this track closure; its existing source-bound verification remains traceable. The whole phase is not closing. + +### First-main production smoke + +Artifact 12012573624 identifies clean source 52fa323, attempt 1, interval 2026-10-15T22:55:29Z..22:57:07Z (98s). Its complete metadata, 23-case results, both production traces and marker output were read. All 23 controls pass: 20 synthetic and three actual private kernels. Each production profile records exactly two SVC exceptions and no other Taking-exception event. The command enables `-d int,unimp`; guest_errors is not enabled, so no guest_errors event count is invented. These timings are observations, not a cross-host regression threshold. + +Debug source-trace SHA-256: `a5252fde957fe74c94ffd41429f4d9ac907522186defe8daef17c68c0506b1f2`. + +```text +tyrne: hello from kernel_main +tyrne: mmu activated +tyrne: high-half active +tyrne: pmm initialized (32593 frames available; 175 reserved) +tyrne: address-space-arena ready (1 / 8 slots used; bootstrap AS root = 0x40099000) +tyrne: timer ready (62500000 Hz, resolution 16 ns) +tyrne: starting cooperative scheduler +tyrne: task B — waiting for IPC +tyrne: task A -- sending IPC +Exception return from AArch64 EL1 to AArch64 EL0 PC 0x800000 +Taking exception 2 [SVC] on CPU 0 +...from EL0 to EL1 +...with ESR 0x15/0x56000000 +...with ELR 0x800034 +...to EL1 PC 0xffffffff40080c00 PSTATE 0x3c5 +hello from userspace +Exception return from AArch64 EL1 to AArch64 EL0 PC 0x800034 +Taking exception 2 [SVC] on CPU 0 +...from EL0 to EL1 +...with ESR 0x15/0x56000000 +...with ELR 0x80005c +...to EL1 PC 0xffffffff40080c00 PSTATE 0x3c5 +tyrne: userspace task exited +tyrne: task B — received IPC (label=0xaaaa); replying +tyrne: task A — received reply (label=0xbbbb); done +tyrne: all tasks complete +tyrne: boot-to-end elapsed = 8725792 ns +qemu-system-aarch64: terminating on signal 15 from pid 4164 (timeout) +``` + +Release source-trace SHA-256: `d2019a8e1845a669c5ec537158c76a5eecc697a74b43d9b2edcdc29976f73ece`. + +```text +tyrne: hello from kernel_main +tyrne: mmu activated +tyrne: high-half active +tyrne: pmm initialized (32598 frames available; 170 reserved) +tyrne: address-space-arena ready (1 / 8 slots used; bootstrap AS root = 0x40094000) +tyrne: timer ready (62500000 Hz, resolution 16 ns) +tyrne: starting cooperative scheduler +tyrne: task B — waiting for IPC +tyrne: task A -- sending IPC +Exception return from AArch64 EL1 to AArch64 EL0 PC 0x800000 +Taking exception 2 [SVC] on CPU 0 +...from EL0 to EL1 +...with ESR 0x15/0x56000000 +...with ELR 0x800020 +...to EL1 PC 0xffffffff40080c00 PSTATE 0x3c5 +Exception return from AArch64 EL1 to AArch64 EL0 PC 0x800020 +Taking exception 2 [SVC] on CPU 0 +...from EL0 to EL1 +...with ESR 0x15/0x56000000 +...with ELR 0x80002c +...to EL1 PC 0xffffffff40080c00 PSTATE 0x3c5 +tyrne: userspace task exited +tyrne: task B — received IPC (label=0xaaaa); replying +tyrne: task A — received reply (label=0xbbbb); done +tyrne: all tasks complete +tyrne: boot-to-end elapsed = 5745104 ns +qemu-system-aarch64: terminating on signal 15 from pid 4296 (timeout) +``` + +Post-merge bookkeeping validation at ancestry source `a0b3df3` plus the staged closure: both supported Python runtimes report 408 Markdown files / 7338 local targets / 1276 fragments / zero findings; staged footprint and diff checks pass. All 161 literal criterion texts are unchanged, all are checked, twelve real date_done headers are present, and protected source/ADRs/audits/prior reviews remain byte-identical. This is documentation verification, distinct from the hosted runtime results above. + +## What changed in the plan + +- All twelve selected tasks become Done with actual completion dates; all six roadmap/task entry surfaces and delimited live census agree: 20 Done, 19 Ready, 7 Draft, none In Progress/In Review. +- Accepted ADR-0042/0043 reconcile naming, planned-purpose identity and mechanical checks. T-052's approved panic documentation disposition remains settled; this bookkeeping invents no new followup. +- Accepted ADR-0044 moved bulk raw evidence out of Git without deleting canonical verdicts. The approved development-only rewrite used one exact original97 lease; the maintainer subsequently advanced main through PR49 merge. Repository release immutability is the single approved setting change; protection and unrelated refs remain unchanged. +- T-056 remains optional for general phase exit and is fully delivered here. No new task, dependency, unsafe change, numerical ADR allocation or C/D scope reduction is introduced. + +## What we learned + +Complete canonical reports and raw execution/source exports have different storage needs. Recursively retaining old archives inside new JSON made an otherwise focused documentation delivery approach one million added lines. A verified immutable archive plus original-source bundle and a compact in-Git map preserves recovery while keeping review navigation readable. Digest verification establishes integrity, not semantic review; original read limits and failed verdicts must survive migration. + +A green storage check must traverse original ancestry. Replacement refs, legacy grafts and an inconsistent commit-graph cache can hide historical violations; the bounded Git wrapper and real negative fixtures now cover these cases. The cache defect was found only by the complementary second-round reviewer, while the other initial approved: preserving both initials and actual post-freeze correction verification is more informative than rewriting history into unanimous first-pass approval. + +Source stages matter after squash and after a storage rewrite. Original execution SHAs, reviewed development source, merged main and post-merge bookkeeping are distinct. Exact-source hosted CI and a tree-preserving ancestry merge keep those boundaries explicit without claiming historical executions ran on new hashes. + +## Adjustments + +- [ ] Start HIGH T-038 next when explicitly requested. Its established one-operand fix still requires the UNSAFE-2026-0033 Amendment, distinct security review and userland/QEMU/disassembly/image evidence; no new ADR is required for that contract. +- [ ] Then complete T-041–T-044 small correctness fixes and prepare decisions before T-039/T-040; use the existing dependency waves rather than treating documentation completion as a correctness proof. +- [ ] Continue T-057–T-073 quality/audit/performance work, then T-074 readiness and T-075 closure. Whole-phase C/D gates remain binding. +- [ ] Apply the already-delivered retention standard/common review skill on future reviews: canonical findings in Git, bounded catalogs and external durable raw evidence; no new policy task is needed for this lesson. + +| Remaining scope | Tasks | Count | +|-----------------|-------|------:| +| B.2-3 correctness and robustness | T-038–T-044 |7 | +| B.2-4 code quality/API design | T-057–T-068 |12 | +| B.2-5 unsafe-audit/doc comments | T-069–T-072; T-064 supplies shared docs |4 | +| B.2-6 performance decision | T-073 |1 | +| Readiness and closure | T-074/T-075 |2 | +| **Total** | **19 Ready /7 Draft** | **26** | + +## Next + +- Active phase: B.2, still Active; Phase C and D remain gated. +- Active milestone: no numbered milestone opened; B.2-2 Done, B.2-3 is the next recommended track. +- Active task: none In Progress; T-038 is Ready/HIGH and unstarted. +- Next review trigger: T-038 implementation and required code/security rounds when explicitly started; whole-phase readiness/closure remains T-074/T-075. diff --git a/docs/analysis/reviews/business-reviews/README.md b/docs/analysis/reviews/business-reviews/README.md index 5afc85e9..5bb1dbb5 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/reviews/business-reviews/README.md +++ b/docs/analysis/reviews/business-reviews/README.md @@ -24,6 +24,7 @@ A business review may point at outcomes from those other reviews as part of "wha | Date | Scope | File | |------|-------|------| +| 2026-10-16 | B.2-2 completion after PR49 merge; twelve tasks Done, all161 criteria checked, first-main gates verified;26 tasks remain | [2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md](2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) | | 2026-04-21 | Milestone A2 — Capability table foundation | [2026-04-21-A2-completion.md](2026-04-21-A2-completion.md) | | 2026-04-21 | A6 completion / Phase A retrospective (A3–A6) — predates the five-section template; its headings differ from `master-plan.md` | [2026-04-21-A6-completion.md](2026-04-21-A6-completion.md) | | 2026-04-22 | T-006 mini-retro — raw-pointer scheduler API refactor | [2026-04-22-T-006-mini-retro.md](2026-04-22-T-006-mini-retro.md) | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/README.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/README.md index a193b87f..9bdce0d4 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/README.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/README.md @@ -21,7 +21,7 @@ Task IDs (`T-NNN`) are sequential **across the whole project**, not restarted pe **Phase B.2 Track B.2-1 (2026-10-12):** The [approved eight-step sequence](phase-b2/README.md) is merged in [PR #48](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/48), including optional T-036 and prerequisite T-037. T-030–T-037 are Done with date_done 2026-10-12 and explicit maintainer authorization. Each step has two fresh rounds and verified corrections; first-main CI and default-branch performance dispatch passed. The [post-merge retrospective](../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-12-phase-b2-track1-completion.md) records completion and remaining scope. Phase B.2 stays Active with 38 tasks remaining; HIGH T-038 is the next Ready candidate, not started. -**Phase B.2 Track B.2-2 (2026-10-15):** All twelve selected tasks T-045–T-056 are implemented/In Review. The [integrated record](../reports/2026-10-15-phase-b2-track2-completion-readiness.md) traces 58 opening findings and 156 criteria; one maintainer SECURITY wording criterion remains pending. Both integrated review rounds are complete; final publication-tip CI is recorded at handoff in explicitly authorized combined [PR #49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49). The phase has 8 Done/12 In Review/26 unimplemented tasks; next implementation is HIGH T-038, Ready and unstarted. Only maintainer-approved review/merge permits Done. +**Phase B.2 Track B.2-2 (2026-10-16):** Track B.2-2 / T-045–T-056 is Done after maintainer-authorized [PR49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49) merge and verified first-main gates. The [completion retrospective](../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records all twelve delivered tasks, 161 checked criteria, completed evidence-retention maintenance and source-bound validation. Phase B.2 has 20 Done / 19 Ready / 7 Draft tasks; 26 remain unimplemented. HIGH T-038 is next, Ready and unstarted. Track B.2-1 remains Done; Phase B.2 stays Active and continues to gate C/D. ## Status vocabulary diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/README.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/README.md index b394c256..53bf26a6 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/README.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/README.md @@ -47,6 +47,8 @@ Every step follows the two-round fresh-review/fix/commit loop; security-sensitiv New tasks stop at In Review for the maintainer. Optional-for-general-exit T-056 is fully selected and cannot close by a decision-only or carry-forward outcome. All work stays on development. The maintainer explicitly authorized combined publication in existing PR #49 on2026-10-15; final PR-tip verification and maintainer review remain. +**Completion (2026-10-16):** [PR49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49) merged at `52fa323`; Done promotions follow explicit maintainer authorization and verified merged-main gates. All 161 current criteria (156 original plus five maintenance criteria) are checked, including the human SECURITY wording approval. Earlier In Review/pending statements in the dated implementation paragraph above remain historical. [Completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md). + ## Index | ID | Title | Track | Status | Depends on | @@ -66,18 +68,18 @@ All work stays on development. The maintainer explicitly authorized combined pub | [T-042](T-042-pmm-defensive-validation.md) | Harden PMM input validation (+ correct the false atomicity comment) | B.2-3 | Ready | — | | [T-043](T-043-user-access-hardening.md) | Harden the copy-user path (DEVICE exclusion, zero-length probe, top-page test) | B.2-3 | Ready | — | | [T-044](T-044-bootstrap-as-handle-invariant.md) | Reconcile the bootstrap address-space handle with the real allocation | B.2-3 | Ready | — | -| [T-045](T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md) | Refresh the entry-point architecture docs (overview, task-loader, architecture index) | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-046](T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md) | Refresh the subsystem architecture chapters (hal, scheduler, exceptions, security-model, memory-management, boot, ipc) | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-047](T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md) | Synchronise roadmap live state and phase index | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-048](T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md) | Synchronise the Phase B task corpus and fix task-file links | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-049](T-049-review-indices-sync.md) | Synchronise the review-family indices | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-050](T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md) | Refresh README, guides index, glossary, and the add-bsp skill trace | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-051](T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md) | Update CONTRIBUTING.md and SECURITY.md to the post-Phase-B state | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-052](T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md) | Reconcile standards claims with CI and lint reality (decisions required) | B.2-2 | In Review | T-032 | -| [T-053](T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md) | Apply mechanical corrections to the standards docs | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-054](T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md) | Cascade the ADR ledger renumbering across phase files | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-055](T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md) | Apply append-only corrections to Accepted ADRs | B.2-2 | In Review | — | -| [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) | Automate docs-corpus consistency checks *(polish; optional for exit)* | B.2-2 | In Progress | T-047, T-048, T-049, T-052, T-053, T-054, T-055 | +| [T-045](T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md) | Refresh the entry-point architecture docs (overview, task-loader, architecture index) | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-046](T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md) | Refresh the subsystem architecture chapters (hal, scheduler, exceptions, security-model, memory-management, boot, ipc) | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-047](T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md) | Synchronise roadmap live state and phase index | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-048](T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md) | Synchronise the Phase B task corpus and fix task-file links | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-049](T-049-review-indices-sync.md) | Synchronise the review-family indices | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-050](T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md) | Refresh README, guides index, glossary, and the add-bsp skill trace | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-051](T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md) | Update CONTRIBUTING.md and SECURITY.md to the post-Phase-B state | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-052](T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md) | Reconcile standards claims with CI and lint reality (decisions required) | B.2-2 | Done | T-032 | +| [T-053](T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md) | Apply mechanical corrections to the standards docs | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-054](T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md) | Cascade the ADR ledger renumbering across phase files | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-055](T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md) | Apply append-only corrections to Accepted ADRs | B.2-2 | Done | — | +| [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) | Automate docs-corpus consistency checks *(polish; optional for exit)* | B.2-2 | Done | T-047, T-048, T-049, T-052, T-053, T-054, T-055 | | [T-057](T-057-typed-addresses-phys-virt.md) | Give `PhysAddr`/`VirtAddr` an audited API and use typed addresses at public boundaries | B.2-4 | Ready | T-042, T-043 | | [T-058](T-058-capability-table-on-arena.md) | Rebase `CapabilityTable` storage on the shared `Arena` | B.2-4 | Ready | — | | [T-059](T-059-capability-resolve-typed-primitive.md) | Introduce a single typed capability-resolution primitive | B.2-4 | Ready | T-058 | @@ -150,20 +152,20 @@ flowchart LR T054 --> T074 ``` -## Remaining work after Track B.2-2 implementation +## Remaining work after Track B.2-2 completion -There are 46 tasks:8 Done,19 Ready,11 In Review,1 In Progress and 7 Draft. T-049 archival/citation maintenance returned In Review; T-056 remains In Progress for the approved ADR-0044 prevention/final-validation unit; the original twelve-task delivery remains subject to maintainer review/merge; 26 other tasks remain unimplemented. Thus 38 tasks are not Done, which does not mean 38 tasks still need implementation. T-056 remains optional for general phase exit, and is fully implemented in this selected sequence. +There are 46 tasks: 20 Done, 19 Ready and 7 Draft; none are In Review or In Progress. T-045–T-056, including all ADR-0044 evidence-retention maintenance, are Done after maintainer-authorized PR49 merge and verified first-main gates. The [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records the actual source, delivery and remaining scope. The other 26 tasks remain unimplemented. T-056 remains optional for general phase exit and was fully delivered here. | Scope | Tasks | Count | Current boundary | |-------|-------|------:|------------------| -| B.2-2 documentation cascade | T-045–T-056 | 12 | Original delivery reviewed; T-049 archival/citation review complete, In Review; T-056 In Progress for prevention/final validation; maintainer gates remain. | +| B.2-2 documentation cascade | T-045–T-056 | 12 | Done after PR49 merge, explicit completion authorization and verified first-main gates; all maintenance criteria closed. | | B.2-3 correctness and robustness | T-038–T-044 | 7 | Unimplemented; T-038 Ready/HIGH is next. | | B.2-4 code quality and API design | T-057–T-068 | 12 | Unimplemented; individual dependency/decision gates apply. | | B.2-5 unsafe-audit and doc comments | T-069–T-072; T-064 supplies shared docs | 4 | Unimplemented; shared ownership adds no extra task. | | B.2-6 performance decisions | T-073 | 1 | Unimplemented. | | Readiness and phase closure | T-074, T-075 | 2 | Unimplemented; whole-phase gates remain. | -**Current maintenance (2026-10-16):** T-049 has completed archival/citation maintenance and T-056 executes the remaining prevention/final-validation unit of the approved [PR49 cleanup plan](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-cleanup.md) under [ADR-0044](../../../decisions/0044-review-evidence-retention.md); both stop In Review after the archival/guard/hosted gates. +**Maintenance complete (2026-10-16):** T-049/T-056 close the approved [cleanup plan](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-cleanup.md) under [ADR-0044](../../../decisions/0044-review-evidence-retention.md), including immutable recovery, bounded history/citation migration, both fresh rounds per unit and required footprint enforcement. Merged-source CI and ordinary clone are verified; no raw evidence or historical verdict was discarded. **Following implementation:** HIGH [T-038](T-038-console-write-x2-clobber.md), Ready after completed T-037; no new ADR required, but its UNSAFE-2026-0033 amendment, separate security review and userland/QEMU verification remain binding. It has not started in this track. Prioritize remaining correctness work under the existing waves; T-039/T-040 and other decision-bearing tasks need their recorded decisions first. ADR-0040's scope checkpoint follows CI and HIGH-correctness work; documentation delivery alone does not clear it. C/D remain gated on whole-phase closure, owned by T-075. diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md index 78d688a3..e72521db 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none - **Informs:** [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) @@ -96,3 +97,4 @@ The master-plan list is also edited by [T-049](T-049-review-indices-sync.md) (di | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), both fresh rounds complete | [Code rounds](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t045-architecture-entry-points.md) and [distinct security rounds](../../reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-13-t045-architecture-entry-points.md) Approve cumulative `d6cb853..deec107`: three unique R1 findings fixed and independently verified; R2 zero new findings. Status In Review, no date_done. T-046 immediately completes overview/boot/index shared checks; T-049 repairs the pre-existing master-plan path before the final touched-file/full-corpus link criterion is checked. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), T-046 shared verification | T-046 completed both fresh code/security rounds at `4b33607`: [canonical review](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t046-subsystem-architecture.md). Expanded boot and all seven chapters agree with overview/loader; all nine index cells and freshness/edit ownership rechecked. The two shared acceptance criteria are now checked. T-045 remains In Review; its separate pre-existing master-plan path criterion stays pending T-049 repair. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), T-049 navigation dependency verified | T-049 repaired the existing business master-plan targets and completed [both fresh complementary rounds](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t049-review-corpus-reconciliation.md). Revalidated all T-045 touched-file local links/fragments, including the deferred master-plan; its final link DoD now closes. This necessary cross-task bookkeeping is within the existing T-045/T-049 dependency, with no new architecture/runtime delivery or Done promotion. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md index 2401b4cd..9d454b4b 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none - **Informs:** [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) @@ -93,3 +94,4 @@ The overview Boot-flow diagram and the README Status cells owned by [T-045](T-04 | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), implementation | Whole seven-chapter refresh against source `da18ed5c2a2d8b3d61f82337a9da021d05d73451`; no executable delta from retained runtime `4ad0b3d`. Applied the exact T-045 marker form, chose a PA/VMA table for boot memory layout, preserved incoming memory/boot anchors and scheduler historical revision, rechecked all nine index cells plus overview/boot coherence. Broader source-defined bounds/fault/exit/IRQ/transfer behavior replace stale design claims. [Verification report](../../reports/2026-10-13-t046-subsystem-architecture-verification.md); review rounds pending, status remains In Progress. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), R1 corrections | Initial fresh code and distinct subsequent security passes at `5e191ad` requested six unique source-confirmed prose corrections (three Medium, three Low): SP_EL0 frame slot, block-error split, inherited idle mask, free-list capacity check, PanicInfo diagnostic order, and PMM type-versus-free alignment boundary. All occurrences and the verification report corrected; no executable/evidence mutation or new run. First-round correction verification and fresh R2 remain pending; status In Progress. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), both fresh rounds complete | [Code rounds](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t046-subsystem-architecture.md) and [distinct security rounds](../../reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-13-t046-subsystem-architecture.md) Approve cumulative `d71aa4a..4b33607`. Six unique R1 findings fixed and independently verified; no new R2 finding. Whole seven chapters, nine index cells and overview/boot/loader coherence checked; T-045 shared criteria close. Status In Review, no date_done. T-048 proceeds; no new runtime run or full-corpus/phase closure claim. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md index df71bd6e..dacc71c8 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none (phase-level precondition: [ADR-0040](../../../decisions/0040-phase-b2-consolidation-bridge.md) `Accepted`, see the [task index](README.md)) - **Informs:** [T-074](T-074-phase-c-readiness-sweep.md), [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) @@ -69,3 +70,4 @@ Separate live state from the preserved historical tail; update live claims from | 2026-10-13 | Codex implementation coordinator | Step 10 starts after Step 9 canonical both-round commit 20a0d25. [Preflight](../../reports/2026-10-13-t047-roadmap-state-preflight.md) records actual source/merge/audit/history review, complete archive boundary and distinct stack/IRQ flags. No new ADR or maintainer decision; In Progress, all 11 criteria unchecked until implementation and both fresh paired rounds. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex implementation author | [Implementation/evidence](../../reports/2026-10-13-t047-roadmap-state-reconciliation.md): 22 original dated groups plus full preamble/live-state/Notes tail preserved; 23 groups including explicit T-029 recovery, reverse chronological with original same-day order. Twelve live task rows/46-task inventory, seven Git integration records, 33 audit entries (32 Active/one Removed), exact three B6 status changes and four distinct C flags verified; errors 0. Original clean archive boundary 20a0d25 is separate from kickoff c989237. In Progress/all 11 criteria unchecked; both fresh paired rounds pending. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex implementation coordinator | [Both fresh code/security rounds](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t047-roadmap-state-reconciliation.md) Approve cumulative 20a0d25..8a89fd2 after actual peer-initial and R2 prior-final cross-reading; zero confirmed R1/R2 or unresolved source findings, no corrective commit warranted. Full reports/initial prefixes and original captures retained with hashes. All eleven criteria checked; In Review/no date_done, maintainer approval/merge pending. Archive source boundary remains clean 20a0d25; publication only updates live lifecycle/discovery and evidence. T-056 parser starts next under ADR-0043; no runtime/hosted/Done or phase-opening claim. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md index bd32dbad..b74d9f23 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none - **Informs:** [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) @@ -101,3 +102,4 @@ The plan counts "nine" frontmatters (T-020..T-028); T-029 is handled separately | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), implementation | Reconciled ten historically merged tasks from exact `origin/main` first-parent facts; 23 contiguous index members, eight exact H1/milestone rows, optional authorized real-date template/lifecycle and three path repairs. Whole body/history/checkbox preservation verified; bounded 800 paths, 99 headings and two source-line fragments pass. [Source-bound report](../../reports/2026-10-13-t048-phase-b-task-reconciliation.md). No runtime run or new Done promotion; both fresh review rounds pending, status In Progress. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), R1 provenance correction | One source-confirmed Low finding: the report's kickoff SHA could be mistaken for the implemented checked tree. Clarified baseline versus working-tree verification and implementation commit `550500f`, preserving every underlying fact/result. No task-body, runtime or evidence change; first-round correction verification and fresh R2 remain pending. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), both fresh rounds complete | [Canonical five-role review](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t048-phase-b-task-reconciliation.md) records both fresh rounds Approve cumulative `a214532..a50f94a`; one R1 Low provenance finding fixed and independently verified, no unresolved finding. Historical ten-task merge/date/preservation, 23-row rendered index, template/lifecycle and scoped links verified. Status In Review, no date_done; T-049 follows. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-049-review-indices-sync.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-049-review-indices-sync.md index 4e27f30f..26640a40 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-049-review-indices-sync.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-049-review-indices-sync.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none - **Informs:** [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) @@ -98,6 +99,7 @@ The maintainer approved [the cleanup plan](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidenc | 2026-10-13 | Codex T-056 baseline follow-up, T-049 owner | New bounded-parser scan identifies two original D2b-007 prose quotations carrying undefined explicit reference syntax. Delimit the unchanged quoted bytes as literal code and append a dated navigation note; no finding/severity/remediation/verdict rewrite, broken-link exception or archive exclusion. [Exact preservation evidence](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md#dataset-2026-10-13-t056-parser-evidence "Archived member: docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-13-t056-parser-evidence/t049-quoted-evidence-repair.json") binds the source. T-056 Step 11 fresh paired R1/R2 will review this owning follow-up in the cumulative range; current T-049 In Review/no date_done unchanged. | | 2026-10-15 | Codex T-056 publication follow-up, T-049 owner | The full historical R2 CODE report contains an intended multiline inline-code quotation crossing real blank blocks, making its quoted fragment active Markdown. Add only two tagged literal delimiters around that paragraph in the publication copy; retain the complete original report as inert evidence. [Exact reverse-preservation proof](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md#dataset-2026-10-13-t056-parser-evidence "Archived member: docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-13-t056-parser-evidence/publication-quoted-evidence-repair.json") confirms all original bytes/findings/verdicts/provenance unchanged. Canonical filenames retain their actual first-review2026-10-13 date to resolve the existing citation; final verification/filing2026-10-15 is explicit. No parser/source change, exception or archive exclusion; T-049 stays In Review/no date_done. | | 2026-10-16 | Codex, maintainer-approved maintenance | Reopened In Progress for Accepted ADR-0044 archive/migration/prevention followup under the approved cleanup plan. Original delivery evidence remains historical; new criteria unchecked, no date_done or phase expansion. Governance/recovery both fresh rounds complete; archival execution begins. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | > **Evidence migration (2026-10-16).** Raw evidence links now open the [immutable archive catalog](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md). Each link title retains its exact archived member path. Original verdicts, measurements, limitations and execution SHA identities remain historical; the archive bundle restores their original source. | 2026-10-16 | Codex, both maintenance rounds complete | Immutable publication/download recovery, all804 payloads/old source,151-map invariants and348/46 reversible citations verified. [Both fresh complementary rounds](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-migration.md) close Low MRC1-01 at3a17c3d; zero unresolved findings. Both new maintenance criteria checked; returns In Review, no date_done. T-056 prevention/remote lease/final hosted and maintainer merge remain separate. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md index 1ddcdf19..e1b8cc82 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none - **Informs:** none @@ -87,3 +88,4 @@ Adjacent, not in the plan item: the same skill (lines 150, 170) quotes a fixed ` | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), Step 6 round-1 correction | Confirmed Low C01 from fresh code review, independently corroborated by the distinct security reviewer: first-userspace boot wire-up now distinguishes the address-space handle from the raw capability-table pointer and states the table lifetime/no-live-mutable-borrow-across-switch obligations from add_user_task. No API, runtime or raw capture change. [Verification report](../../reports/2026-10-13-t050-entry-document-verification.md) records provenance; R1 fix verification and fresh R2 pending, status In Progress. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), Step 6 round-2 correction | Confirmed Low R2-C01 from the different fresh code reviewer, corroborated by the separate fresh security reviewer: Bridge phase now states ADR-0040’s milestone/implementation gate and explicitly permits Phase C planning/Proposed ADRs/readiness. R1 C01 remains resolved. No new decision, vocabulary/anchor, executable or raw capture change. [Verification report](../../reports/2026-10-13-t050-entry-document-verification.md) retains provenance; bounded R2 verification/canonical closure pending, status In Progress. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), Step 6 canonical boundary | Both fresh primary/security rounds Approve corrected cumulative 75de2ba..946f45f; R1 C01 and R2-C01 verified fixed, zero unresolved delta findings. [Code artifact](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t050-entry-document-refresh.md) and [security artifact](../../reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-13-t050-entry-document-refresh.md) retain all four actual reports and limits. Source-bound debug/release evidence unchanged; final publication diagnostics separately checked. Status In Review, no date_done or maintainer approval; T-055 starts next. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md index 52b0f3bc..b4f24910 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none - **Informs:** none @@ -56,7 +57,7 @@ Doc-only variant: - [x] Every relative link (`](…)` target) in each touched file resolves to an existing path or heading. - [x] `git diff --stat` lists only: `CONTRIBUTING.md`, `SECURITY.md`, `docs/roadmap/current.md`, and this task file. -- [ ] The SECURITY.md wording is reviewed by the maintainer before merge, since it is security-policy text (CLAUDE.md rule on flagging security-relevant changes). +- [x] The SECURITY.md wording is reviewed by the maintainer before merge, since it is security-policy text (CLAUDE.md rule on flagging security-relevant changes). - [x] Text is English ([`documentation-style.md`](../../../standards/documentation-style.md)). - [x] Commit message follows [`commit-style.md`](../../../standards/commit-style.md) with `Refs: ADR-0040`. - [x] Task status updated to `In Review`; [`current.md`](../../../roadmap/current.md) updated. @@ -81,3 +82,4 @@ Adjacent, not in the plan item: `CONTRIBUTING.md:17-23` ("When the project enter | 2026-10-12 | Codex (AI agent), maintainer-approved reconciliation | Old: future-implementation CONTRIBUTING section excluded and current EL0 fault/exit limits incomplete. Approved replacement: present workflow plus five-syscall surface and trust/fault/reclamation limits, separate security reviews and maintainer SECURITY review before merge; disclosure unchanged. See [approved preflight plan](../../reports/2026-10-12-phase-b2-track2-preflight-and-plan.md) and [ADR-0043](../../../decisions/0043-documentation-corpus-consistency.md); preparation only, status unchanged. | | 2026-10-12 | Codex (AI agent) | Step 1 started after Step 0 passed both fresh rounds (`50f21ca`). Reconciled CONTRIBUTING workflow and SECURITY surface/limits from ABI, dispatch, vectors, BSP and scheduler; disclosure section preserved byte-for-byte. Static verification precedes the two distinct code/security rounds; no completion claimed. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), four fresh review contexts | `4ffda15` implements Step 1. Static source/link/status/history checks pass; both fresh code rounds and their subsequent distinct security passes Approve with zero findings, so no fix commit was needed. See [code review](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t051-contribution-security-status.md) and [security review](../../reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-13-t051-contribution-security-status.md). Status In Review; maintainer SECURITY wording review remains unchecked before merge. Disclosure bytes unchanged; no runtime/hosted run claimed. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. Maintainer merge and explicit completion authorization supply the human SECURITY-wording approval; no agent or invented GitHub review is substituted. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md index fe43d81e..e1a3c275 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** [T-032](T-032-panic-family-denies-hal-bsp.md) - **Informs:** [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) @@ -86,3 +87,4 @@ The test count is approximate (365 `#[test]` attributes by `grep`; 345 by a scra | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), implementation author | Step 8 kickoff after T-055's completed two-round boundary at `98378b5`; verified prerequisites and approved choices. See [source-bound preflight](../../reports/2026-10-13-t052-t053-standards-preflight.md), including additional existing-scope tooling-file reasons recorded before edits. Status In Progress; no delivery or review claim. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), implementation author | T-052 content: test naming is the Accepted ADR-0042 rule change; panic, incomplete-marker enforcement, logging status and crate deny scope are the four approved source-backed claim corrections. Adjacent task-fault/supervision/resource-retention and ISR-transport boundaries corrected. Code-style restatements aligned; no source/lint change. Downstream dispositions and verification will be retained before fresh paired reviews. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), Step 8 canonical boundary | Both fresh code/security rounds Approve cumulative `98378b5..d553efe`; zero confirmed source or peer-seam findings, no correction commit required. [Code](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t052-t053-standards-reconciliation.md) and [security](../../reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-13-t052-t053-standards-reconciliation.md) retain all four required reports plus the disclosed supplementary primary assessment. All 12 AC/DoD boxes checked against source/evidence/scoped allowance; static/navigation snapshot limits preserved. In Review without date_done or maintainer approval; Step 9/T-054 starts next. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md index 93e85b9c..2c17130c 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none - **Informs:** [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) @@ -69,3 +70,4 @@ Verify each statement against its source of truth first (`.cargo/config.toml`, ` | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), implementation author | Step 8 kickoff after T-055's completed two-round boundary at `98378b5`; verified prerequisites and approved choices. See [source-bound preflight](../../reports/2026-10-13-t052-t053-standards-preflight.md), including additional existing-scope tooling-file reasons recorded before edits. Status In Progress; no delivery or review claim. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), implementation author | T-053 content: target-wide panic flags, live target-aware CI/smoke, actual lint entries and warning escalation, history-derived valid scopes, printed QEMU log path, all three fence tags and grammar/test-hal fixes. Pre-recorded security-review/P11/infrastructure additions correct adjacent tooling delivery claims while preserving required properties. No source/configuration/CI/lint-level change. Verification and both fresh paired rounds remain pending. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), Step 8 canonical boundary | Both fresh code/security rounds Approve cumulative `98378b5..d553efe`; zero confirmed source or peer-seam findings, no correction commit required. [Code](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t052-t053-standards-reconciliation.md) and [security](../../reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-13-t052-t053-standards-reconciliation.md) retain all four required reports plus the disclosed supplementary primary assessment. All 13 AC/DoD boxes checked against source/evidence/scoped allowance; static/navigation snapshot limits preserved. In Review without date_done or maintainer approval; Step 9/T-054 starts next. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md index c9dc74e8..8c1d2305 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none (phase-level precondition: [ADR-0040](../../../decisions/0040-phase-b2-consolidation-bridge.md) `Accepted`, see the [task index](README.md)) - **Informs:** [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md), [T-074](T-074-phase-c-readiness-sweep.md) @@ -71,5 +72,6 @@ Verify all 32 definitions and their references, the ADR-0040 rider and the numbe | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), implementation author | [Implementation/evidence](../../reports/2026-10-13-t054-planned-adr-identity-migration.md): duplicate/source comparison `32 unique definitions; C5 D5 E6 F5 G5 H3 I3; 71 semantic reference source lines; 74 linked occurrences; 42 filed ADRs and 42 index record rows unchanged; errors 0`. All original purposes/milestones/complete notes preserved; numeric historical snapshots/filed citations remain distinct. In Progress/unchecked until both fresh paired review rounds and canonical publication. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), confirmed R1 correction | Primary R1-C01 and security T054-R1-S01 independently identify one unique Low: Phase I's new workflow note referred to nonexistent local acceptance criteria. Full-source validation confirmed it; removed only that fragment and retained no-status/no-authorization wording, with no new milestone criteria. [Separate corrected-source check](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md#dataset-2026-10-13-t054-verification-evidence "Archived member: docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-13-t054-verification-evidence/r1-correction-verification.json") preserves original snapshots; 32/71/74/42/42 and zero errors. In Progress; actual peer cross-reading/fix verification and fresh R2 pending. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex coordinator; four distinct independent reviewers | [Both fresh code/security rounds](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t054-planned-adr-identities.md) Approve cumulative `f8c9b7f..a93926b`. One unique R1 Low (R1-C01 / T054-R1-S01) fixed in a93926b and independently verified; zero new R2 or unresolved findings. Actual immutable peer initials and R1 finals fully cross-read; full final reports retained, source/capture hashes and separate publication checks recorded. All 11 criteria checked; In Review, no date_done or maintainer approval. T-047 starts next. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | > **Evidence migration (2026-10-16).** Raw evidence links now open the [immutable archive catalog](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md). Each link title retains its exact archived member path. Original verdicts, measurements, limitations and execution SHA identities remain historical; the archive bundle restores their original source. diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md index b5d53c0e..d2901acb 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 -- **Status:** In Review +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** none - **Informs:** [T-056](T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) @@ -69,5 +70,6 @@ Copy the established banner shapes rather than inventing new ones: ADR-0022 line | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), Step 7 R1 scope clarification before fix | Independent code/security assessments converged on one Low stale timer-helper citation. Separately, root confirmed Low C-ROOT-01: propose-standard-change still permits in-place Accepted ADR amendments contrary to ADR-0025 Rule 2. [Dated extra-file reason](../../reports/2026-10-13-t055-adr-correction-preflight.md#round-1-additional-file-reason--recorded-before-correction) adds this fifth procedure file before mutation under the existing allowance. Correct factual rider/Proposed draft wording while preserving approval for substantive new decisions; no new ADR or policy. Independent initial reports remain intact; fixes and both rounds are still pending. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), Step 7 R1 correction | Fixed the one independently corroborated timer rustdoc issue and root-origin C-ROOT-01 after recording the additional-file reason. Existing decision/approval boundaries and executable source unchanged. Post-fix fmt/host-clippy, preservation/index/raw-hash and bounded navigation checks pass; original test capture stays bound to f256a610 and default raw blank-EOF diagnostic is retained. [Separate correction evidence](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md#dataset-2026-10-13-t055-verification-evidence "Archived member: docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-13-t055-verification-evidence/r1-correction-verification.json"); bounded R1 verification and fresh R2 pending. | | 2026-10-13 | Codex (AI agent), Step 7 canonical boundary | Both fresh code/security rounds Approve corrected cumulative e8104e3..23391c7; two unique Low R1 findings verified fixed, zero new R2 or unresolved findings. [Code](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-13-t055-adr-corrections.md) and [security](../../reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-13-t055-adr-corrections.md) retain all four actual reports, checklist/read provenance and limits. All seven AC/five DoD checked against source/evidence and scoped allowance; original raw captures unchanged, canonical diagnostics separate. In Review without date_done or maintainer approval; Step 8/T-052/T-053 starts next. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. | > **Evidence migration (2026-10-16).** Raw evidence links now open the [immutable archive catalog](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md). Each link title retains its exact archived member path. Original verdicts, measurements, limitations and execution SHA identities remain historical; the archive bundle restores their original source. diff --git a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md index 16c4e477..1ee68624 100644 --- a/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md +++ b/docs/analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md @@ -2,8 +2,9 @@ - **Phase:** B.2 - **Milestone:** Track B.2-2 (Polish items; not exit-gating) -- **Status:** In Progress +- **Status:** Done - **Created:** 2026-10-11 +- **date_done:** 2026-10-16 - **Author:** Claude (AI agent), opened on behalf of @cemililik - **Dependencies:** [T-048](T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md), [T-049](T-049-review-indices-sync.md), [T-052](T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md), [T-053](T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md), [T-054](T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md), [T-055](T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md); [T-047](T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md) supplies the delimited live-state surface - **Informs:** none @@ -67,9 +68,9 @@ Run locally on macOS and verify Linux through exact-source hosted CI after publi The maintainer approved [the cleanup plan](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-cleanup.md) and [ADR-0044](../../../decisions/0044-review-evidence-retention.md). The original checked criteria remain historical delivery evidence; these additional criteria close before this maintenance returns to In Review. No Done promotion or phase inventory expansion is authorized. -- [ ] After ADR-0044 Acceptance, add minimal retention guidance to existing review skills/documentation standards in the prevention unit (approved plan step6). The evidence-only release-standard scope pointer separately must precede archive publication; it landed at original6c84f0d. This approved maintenance explicitly extends the original skill-edit scope only for this guidance. -- [ ] Implement Accepted ADR-0044 footprint limits as a separate offline command with meaningful fixtures in the existing required lint job. -- [ ] Complete bounded development-only history migration, original-to-new mapping, source equivalence, clean clone and exact final-source hosted verification under the approved lease/rollback boundary. +- [x] After ADR-0044 Acceptance, add minimal retention guidance to existing review skills/documentation standards in the prevention unit (approved plan step6). The evidence-only release-standard scope pointer separately must precede archive publication; it landed at original6c84f0d. This approved maintenance explicitly extends the original skill-edit scope only for this guidance. +- [x] Implement Accepted ADR-0044 footprint limits as a separate offline command with meaningful fixtures in the existing required lint job. +- [x] Complete bounded development-only history migration, original-to-new mapping, source equivalence, clean clone and exact final-source hosted verification under the approved lease/rollback boundary. ## Review history @@ -106,3 +107,4 @@ The maintainer approved [the cleanup plan](../../reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidenc | 2026-10-15 | Codex review coordinator | Step12 complete after [both fresh code rounds](../../reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-15-t056-integration.md) and [separate security rounds](../../reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-15-t056-integration.md), actual committed-fix verification and peer reconciliation at4044b79. Six R1 plus three R2 groups closed; full24 original reports/retained evidence preserve HOLDs, severities, source stages and limits. Python3.9/3.13 suites161/124 and exact404 Linux PR/push CI pass; six app15368 contexts preserved. All16 task criteria checked, In Review/no date_done; Step13 and final publication-tip/maintainer review remain. Optional-for-general-exit status retained; implementation delivered, no carry-forward shortcut or Done claim. | | 2026-10-16 | Codex, maintainer-approved maintenance | Reopened In Progress for Accepted ADR-0044 archive/migration/prevention followup under the approved cleanup plan. Original delivery evidence remains historical; new criteria unchecked, no date_done or phase expansion. Governance/recovery both fresh rounds complete; archival execution begins. | | 2026-10-16 | Codex, prevention preflight | Archive/citation both fresh rounds complete; T-049 returns In Review. Clarify the maintenance criterion’s temporal wording against the already-approved plan: only the release-standard pointer precedes archival publication; general retention guidance and guard are step6. No requirement waived or completion claimed. Implement separate offline footprint CLI over index and complete HEAD history, rejecting shallow/promisor input; existing lint checkout supplies complete history. No runtime/parser/protection change. | +| 2026-10-16 | @cemililik (merge/completion authorization); Codex (verification/scribe) | Maintainer merged PR49 at `52fa323` and explicitly authorized Done. First merged-main CI 38820329507 passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; [completion retrospective](../../reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records source-bound evidence. date_done is the Istanbul completion/authorization date 2026-10-16; actual merge UTC 2026-10-15T22:55:20Z is preserved. All three ADR-0044 maintenance criteria close after actual F/main hosted checks, verified archive/recovery/mapping and ordinary full remote clone; no carry-forward. | diff --git a/docs/roadmap/README.md b/docs/roadmap/README.md index 9328bf6d..d0d91f50 100644 --- a/docs/roadmap/README.md +++ b/docs/roadmap/README.md @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ The plan is separate from the work. Individual tasks and reviews live under [`.. **Track B.2-1 completion (2026-10-12):** The [eight-step sequence](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/README.md) is merged in [PR #48](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/48); T-030–T-037 are Done with maintainer authorization. Both fresh rounds per step and verified fixes are recorded. First-main CI and default-branch performance dispatch passed; the [post-merge retrospective](../analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-12-phase-b2-track1-completion.md) records the evidence and remaining scope. Next candidate: HIGH T-038 (Ready, not started). The whole Phase B.2 exit bar still gates C and D. -**Track B.2-2 implementation (2026-10-15):** T-045–T-056 are implemented and In Review under the approved 13-step sequence. The [integrated readiness record](../analysis/reports/2026-10-15-phase-b2-track2-completion-readiness.md) maps all 58 findings, task criteria, architecture freshness and two-round step reviews. Both Step 13 rounds are complete; final publication-tip CI is recorded in combined [PR #49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49), as explicitly authorized. Maintainer SECURITY wording review and merge remain. 26 further tasks need implementation; HIGH T-038 is next, Ready/unstarted. Track B.2-1 remains Done and C/D remain gated. +**Track B.2-2 implementation (2026-10-16):** Track B.2-2 / T-045–T-056 is Done after maintainer-authorized [PR49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49) merge and verified first-main gates. The [completion retrospective](../analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records all twelve delivered tasks, 161 checked criteria, completed evidence-retention maintenance and source-bound validation. Phase B.2 has 20 Done / 19 Ready / 7 Draft tasks; 26 remain unimplemented. HIGH T-038 is next, Ready and unstarted. Track B.2-1 remains Done; Phase B.2 stays Active and continues to gate C/D. ## What lives here diff --git a/docs/roadmap/current.md b/docs/roadmap/current.md index 5ecd471d..057c5637 100644 --- a/docs/roadmap/current.md +++ b/docs/roadmap/current.md @@ -6,35 +6,35 @@ The live pointer to selected work, task states and review triggers. Dated banner ## Live state — 2026-10-16 - **Active phase:** [B.2 — Consolidation & Hardening](phases/phase-b2.md), mandatory whole-phase gate before C/D under [ADR-0040](../decisions/0040-phase-b2-consolidation-bridge.md). Phase C and D remain gated. -- **Selected track:** B.2-2, under the maintainer-approved [13-step plan](../analysis/reports/2026-10-12-phase-b2-track2-preflight-and-plan.md). Steps 0–13 completed their required review boundaries; original implementation is complete; eleven selected tasks are In Review and T-056 is In Progress for approved evidence-retention maintenance. -- **Active task:** [T-056 — footprint prevention and final validation](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) In Progress under Accepted [ADR-0044](../decisions/0044-review-evidence-retention.md). [T-049](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-049-review-indices-sync.md) returns In Review after [both fresh archive/citation rounds](../analysis/reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-migration.md). Immutable archive/public recovery/local migration and [both footprint prevention rounds](../analysis/reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-prevention.md) are complete. Final candidate, exact remote lease and hosted/ordinary remote-clone gates remain. +- **Selected track:** B.2-2 is Done under the approved [13-step plan](../analysis/reports/2026-10-12-phase-b2-track2-preflight-and-plan.md), including reviewed ADR-0044 maintenance. All twelve tasks T-045–T-056 are Done after PR49 merge and explicit maintainer completion authorization. +- **Active task:** None. [Post-merge verification](../analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) binds merged source `52fa323`, first-main CI and completed criteria. HIGH T-038 is the next Ready candidate; it has not started. - **Working branch:** development, as requested by the maintainer. -- **Last completed work:** Track B.2-1 plus prerequisite T-037 (T-030–T-037 overall), Done after [PR #48](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/48) merged 2026-10-12 at `c16997e`; the [completion retrospective](../analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-12-phase-b2-track1-completion.md) retains merged-main evidence. +- **Last completed work:** Track B.2-2 / T-045–T-056, Done on 2026-10-16 (Europe/Istanbul) after [PR49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49) merge at `52fa323`, verified first-main gates and explicit authorization. Track B.2-1 / T-030–T-037 remains Done after PR48. - **Historical completion:** [T-029](../analysis/tasks/phase-b/T-029-perf-microbench.md), Phase 1 [PR #44](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/44) and Phase 2 [PR #45](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/45), both merged 2026-06-01. Its recovered dated banner is in the archive. - **Last completed milestone:** B6 / Phase B, closed by [PR #43](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/43) on 2026-06-01 at `ca932ac`; b6-closure is merged and retired. No Phase B closure review remains pending. -- **In review:** 11 selected B.2-2 tasks, pending maintainer approval/merge. **In progress:** T-056 prevention/final validation. **Phase inventory:** 46 tasks — 8 Done, 19 Ready, 11 In Review, 1 In Progress, 7 Draft; see the [task index](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/README.md). +- **In review:** none. **In progress:** none. **Phase inventory:** 46 tasks — 20 Done, 19 Ready, 0 In Review, 0 In Progress, 7 Draft; see the [task index](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/README.md). ### Selected task states | Task | Status | |------|--------| -| [T-045](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md) | In Review | -| [T-046](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md) | In Review | -| [T-047](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md) | In Review | -| [T-048](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md) | In Review | -| [T-049](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-049-review-indices-sync.md) | In Review | -| [T-050](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md) | In Review | -| [T-051](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md) | In Review | -| [T-052](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md) | In Review | -| [T-053](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md) | In Review | -| [T-054](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md) | In Review | -| [T-055](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md) | In Review | -| [T-056](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) | In Progress | +| [T-045](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-045-docs-overview-taskloader-arch-index.md) | Done | +| [T-046](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-046-docs-subsystem-chapters-refresh.md) | Done | +| [T-047](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-047-roadmap-state-and-phase-index-sync.md) | Done | +| [T-048](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-048-phase-b-task-corpus-sync.md) | Done | +| [T-049](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-049-review-indices-sync.md) | Done | +| [T-050](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-050-entry-docs-and-glossary-sync.md) | Done | +| [T-051](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-051-contributing-and-security-status.md) | Done | +| [T-052](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-052-standards-docs-reality-sync.md) | Done | +| [T-053](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-053-standards-docs-mechanical-fixes.md) | Done | +| [T-054](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-054-adr-ledger-renumbering-cascade.md) | Done | +| [T-055](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-055-adr-append-only-corrections.md) | Done | +| [T-056](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-056-docs-consistency-automation.md) | Done | ### Next work and review triggers -- **Next work:** validate the reviewed final candidate, then publish development with the approved exact lease and verify hosted CI/ordinary remote clone. Maintainer [PR49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49)/SECURITY wording review follows; no Done before authorized merge. -- **Next review trigger:** all three maintenance units have both different fresh complementary rounds and verified corrections complete; final exact-source hosted/ordinary remote-clone verification is next. Original Step13 reviews and the [integrated readiness record](../analysis/reports/2026-10-15-phase-b2-track2-completion-readiness.md) remain historical delivery evidence. +- **Next work:** HIGH [T-038 — console_write x2 clobber](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-038-console-write-x2-clobber.md), Ready and unstarted. Its unsafe Amendment, separate security review and userland/QEMU evidence remain required. No new ADR is required for its existing contract. +- **Next review trigger:** T-038 implementation and required code/security rounds when explicitly started. B.2-2 implementation, integrated reviews and all three maintenance units are complete; [post-merge retrospective](../analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records actual closure. Whole-phase readiness/closure remains at T-074/T-075. - **Following correctness work:** [T-038 — console_write x2 clobber](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-038-console-write-x2-clobber.md) is Ready/HIGH and has not started. T-037 is Done; the documentation track does not clear this checkpoint. Eventual whole-phase closure reviews belong to [T-075](../analysis/tasks/phase-b2/T-075-phase-b2-closure.md); all B.2 exit gates still apply to C/D. ### Active decisions @@ -43,6 +43,8 @@ The live pointer to selected work, task states and review triggers. Dated banner ### Last reviews +- **2026-10-16:** [B.2-2 completion retrospective](../analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md), after PR49 merge and explicit Done authorization; first-main seven jobs/six app-15368 contexts pass, all twelve tasks and all 161 criteria complete. + - **2026-10-15:** [Track B.2-2 integrated code](../analysis/reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-15-phase-b2-track2-integration.md) and [separate security](../analysis/reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-15-phase-b2-track2-integration.md), both fresh rounds complete at7d1eca0. One Low README-target finding fixed/verified, zero unresolved findings. Twelve tasks In Review; human SECURITY wording and PR merge remain. - **2026-10-15:** [T-056 Step12 code](../analysis/reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-15-t056-integration.md) and [separate security](../analysis/reviews/security-reviews/2026-10-15-t056-integration.md), both rounds complete at4044b79; all nine groups closed. Exact-source hosted evidence passes; later final-tip/Step 13 gates remain. @@ -57,7 +59,7 @@ The live pointer to selected work, task states and review triggers. Dated banner ### Notes -The [unsafe log](../audits/unsafe-log.md) has 33 entries: 32 Active, one Removed (0012), recounted 2026-10-13 in the [source inventory](../analysis/reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md#dataset-2026-10-13-t047-verification-evidence "Archived member: docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-13-t047-verification-evidence/semantic-baseline.json"). This metadata inventory is not a new unsafe audit or runtime security proof. New B.2-2 tasks stop In Review until maintainer approval/merge; historical Done authorizations remain separate. +The [unsafe log](../audits/unsafe-log.md) has 33 entries: 32 Active, one Removed (0012), recounted 2026-10-13 in the [source inventory](../analysis/reports/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-catalog.md#dataset-2026-10-13-t047-verification-evidence "Archived member: docs/analysis/reports/2026-10-13-t047-verification-evidence/semantic-baseline.json"). This metadata inventory is not a new unsafe audit or runtime security proof. B.2-2 Done promotions now rest on actual PR49 merge and explicit maintainer authorization; future task promotions retain their own review/merge gates. diff --git a/docs/roadmap/phases/README.md b/docs/roadmap/phases/README.md index 02654465..12a9bfc9 100644 --- a/docs/roadmap/phases/README.md +++ b/docs/roadmap/phases/README.md @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ The plan is a **sequence**, not a schedule: there are no dates. Later phases are | [I](phase-i.md) | Mobile | Light | First prototype boot on phone-class hardware. | | [J](phase-j.md) | AI-native userspace layer (opt-in) | Sketch | Optional AI-integrated features running entirely in userspace above the kernel's trust boundary. Per [ADR-0015](../../decisions/0015-ai-integration-stance.md). | -**Where we are (2026-10-15):** Phase A and Phase B are closed; [Phase B.2](phase-b2.md) is active under [ADR-0040](../../decisions/0040-phase-b2-consolidation-bridge.md). Track B.2-1/T-030–T-037 is Done after [PR #48](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/48), maintainer authorization and verified first-main gates. Track B.2-2/T-045–T-056 is implemented/In Review; [integrated verification](../../analysis/reports/2026-10-15-phase-b2-track2-completion-readiness.md) and both fresh rounds are complete; final publication-tip CI is recorded before maintainer review in combined [PR #49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49). Of 46 tasks, 8 are Done, 12 In Review and 26 unimplemented (19 Ready/7 Draft). HIGH T-038 is Ready/unstarted and next. Phase C/D remain gated by whole B.2 exit; [current.md](../current.md) is the live pointer. +**Where we are (2026-10-16):** Track B.2-2 / T-045–T-056 is Done after maintainer-authorized [PR49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49) merge and verified first-main gates. The [completion retrospective](../../analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records all twelve delivered tasks, 161 checked criteria, completed evidence-retention maintenance and source-bound validation. Phase B.2 has 20 Done / 19 Ready / 7 Draft tasks; 26 remain unimplemented. HIGH T-038 is next, Ready and unstarted. Track B.2-1 remains Done; Phase B.2 stays Active and continues to gate C/D. ## Dependency sketch diff --git a/docs/roadmap/phases/phase-b2.md b/docs/roadmap/phases/phase-b2.md index dbef83a3..a3b99535 100644 --- a/docs/roadmap/phases/phase-b2.md +++ b/docs/roadmap/phases/phase-b2.md @@ -104,7 +104,7 @@ The finding/action list below is retained as the opening baseline. Its present-t ### Implementation status (2026-10-15) -**Maintenance status (2026-10-16):** T-049 returns In Review after [both fresh archive/citation rounds](../../analysis/reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-migration.md); T-056 remains In Progress for final candidate/exact remote lease/hosted/ordinary remote-clone validation after [both footprint prevention rounds](../../analysis/reviews/code-reviews/2026-10-16-pr49-evidence-prevention.md) and verified corrections. Eleven selected tasks are In Review. Original implementation/integrated reviews and immutable archival/public recovery/local history/citation migration are complete; whole-phase C/D and maintainer gates remain. +**Completion (2026-10-16): Done.** T-045–T-056 and all ADR-0044 maintenance are complete after maintainer merge of [PR49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49) at `52fa323` and explicit completion authorization. [First-main CI](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/actions/runs/38820329507) passes all seven jobs and six required app-15368 contexts; all 161 current criteria are checked. The [completion retrospective](../../analysis/reviews/business-reviews/2026-10-16-phase-b2-track2-completion.md) records archive/recovery, final review footprint, source-bound evidence and the remaining 26 tasks. T-038 is Ready/HIGH and unstarted; whole-phase C/D gates remain. **Original delivery status (2026-10-15): In Review; implementation and both integrated review rounds complete.** All twelve selected tasks T-045–T-056 are implemented and In Review, including optional-for-general-exit T-056. Steps 0–13 passed two fresh independent rounds with verified corrections; Step 13 reconciles all 58 original findings, all 156 task criteria and nine architecture freshness markers in the [integrated readiness record](../../analysis/reports/2026-10-15-phase-b2-track2-completion-readiness.md). 155 criteria are checked; T-051's maintainer SECURITY wording review remains pending before merge. The maintainer explicitly selected combined publication in existing [PR #49](https://github.com/HodeTech/Tyrne/pull/49) from development. Step 13’s Low README evidence-target finding was fixed and independently verified; both fresh rounds are complete. PR #49 records final publication-tip CI before maintainer handoff.