diff --git a/Common/Code.js b/Common/Code.js index 1952c20..9df3e79 100644 --- a/Common/Code.js +++ b/Common/Code.js @@ -28,6 +28,33 @@ var capableRenderers = 8; * @public */ var capableDerenderers = 13; +/** + * REASON: sciweavers.org retired tex2img.php, the GET image endpoint every Sciweavers + * renderer entry below is built on. Verified 2026-09-18: the site itself is up and its + * editor at /free-online-latex-equation-editor still renders, but tex2img.php returns the + * site's own 404 page for every shape of request - http and https, www and apex, both + * parameter orders, and every user agent tried (curl, Chrome, Googlebot). Even the embed + * URL sciweavers' own editor hands out after a successful render is a tex2img.php link + * that 404s. Its working path is now a POST to /process_form_tex2img that returns a + * one-off /upload/Tex2Img_/render.png; the id changes on every submit and does not + * carry the LaTeX, so it cannot satisfy our contract that an equation's image URL is + * stable and de-renderable back into source. + * + * These families are therefore skipped when RENDERING (see getRendererOrder), which drops + * three guaranteed-failing renderer attempts - two fetches each - from every equation that + * gets past Codecogs and Texrendr. They are deliberately still reachable through + * getRenderer/capableDerenderers so equations rendered before the shutdown keep + * de-rendering. What breaks if this list is emptied: Auto gets slower on every fallback + * and any explicit Sciweavers choice fails 100% of the time. + * @public + */ +var retiredRendererFamilies = ["Sciweavers", "Sciweavers_old"]; +/** + * @public + */ +function isRetiredRendererFamily(family) { + return retiredRendererFamilies.indexOf(family) > -1; +} /** * Renderer ID constants for retreiving info about specific renderers * @public @@ -49,6 +76,9 @@ var invalidEquationHashTexrendrFirst50 = "GIF89a%uFFFD%008%00%uFFFD%00%00%uFFFD% var invalidEquationHashTexrendrFirst50_2 = "GIF89a%01%00%01%00%uFFFD%00%00%uFFFD%uFFFD%uFFFD%0"; var invalidEquationHashTexrendrFirst50_3 = "GIF89ai%0A%uFFFD%01%uFFFD%00%00%uFFFD%uFFFD%uFFFD%"; // this is the No Expression Supplied error. Ignored for now. var invalidEquationHashTexrendrFirst50_4 = "%7FELF%01%01%01%00%00%00%00%00%00%00%00%00%02%00%0"; +// NOTE: this prefix is an HTML document where an image was expected. It originally caught +// Sciweavers answering an amsmath equation with its editor page, and it also matches the +// 404 page tex2img.php now serves unconditionally (see retiredRendererFamilies). var invalidEquationHashSciweaversFirst50 = "%0D%0A%09%3C%21DOCTYPE%20html%20PUBLIC%20%22-//W3C"; var defaultRendererPreference = "auto"; var activeRendererPreference = null; @@ -61,7 +91,11 @@ function normalizeRendererPreference(renderer) { case "texrendr": return "texrendr"; case "sciweavers": - return "sciweavers"; + // REASON: users who picked Sciweavers before it shut down still have it in their saved + // properties, and the option is gone from the sidebars. Migrate the stored value to + // Automatic here so those users render instead of failing on every equation; savePrefs + // writes the normalized value back, so the dead preference does not survive a render. + return defaultRendererPreference; default: return defaultRendererPreference; } @@ -72,9 +106,9 @@ function getPreferredRendererFamily(rendererPreference) { return "Codecogs"; case "texrendr": return "Texrendr"; - case "sciweavers": - return "Sciweavers"; default: + // NOTE: no "sciweavers" case - normalizeRendererPreference maps it to Automatic, so a + // retired family can never become the preferred family that getRendererOrder promotes. return ""; } } @@ -120,6 +154,10 @@ function getRendererOrder() { var prioritizedOrder = []; var fallbackOrder = []; for (var worked = 1; worked <= capableRenderers; ++worked) { + // REASON: retired services are still listed in getRenderer so old equations de-render, + // but attempting them here only costs two doomed fetches and a sleep per equation. + if (isRetiredRendererFamily(getRenderer(worked)[5])) + continue; defaultOrder.push(worked); } if (!preferredFamily) { diff --git a/Common/Code.ts b/Common/Code.ts index 3202116..a1c8a15 100644 --- a/Common/Code.ts +++ b/Common/Code.ts @@ -137,6 +137,35 @@ const capableRenderers = 8; */ const capableDerenderers = 13; +/** + * REASON: sciweavers.org retired tex2img.php, the GET image endpoint every Sciweavers + * renderer entry below is built on. Verified 2026-09-18: the site itself is up and its + * editor at /free-online-latex-equation-editor still renders, but tex2img.php returns the + * site's own 404 page for every shape of request - http and https, www and apex, both + * parameter orders, and every user agent tried (curl, Chrome, Googlebot). Even the embed + * URL sciweavers' own editor hands out after a successful render is a tex2img.php link + * that 404s. Its working path is now a POST to /process_form_tex2img that returns a + * one-off /upload/Tex2Img_/render.png; the id changes on every submit and does not + * carry the LaTeX, so it cannot satisfy our contract that an equation's image URL is + * stable and de-renderable back into source. + * + * These families are therefore skipped when RENDERING (see getRendererOrder), which drops + * three guaranteed-failing renderer attempts - two fetches each - from every equation that + * gets past Codecogs and Texrendr. They are deliberately still reachable through + * getRenderer/capableDerenderers so equations rendered before the shutdown keep + * de-rendering. What breaks if this list is emptied: Auto gets slower on every fallback + * and any explicit Sciweavers choice fails 100% of the time. + * @public + */ +const retiredRendererFamilies = ["Sciweavers", "Sciweavers_old"]; + +/** + * @public + */ +function isRetiredRendererFamily(family: string) { + return retiredRendererFamilies.indexOf(family) > -1; +} + /** * Renderer ID constants for retreiving info about specific renderers * @public @@ -160,6 +189,9 @@ const invalidEquationHashTexrendrFirst50 = "GIF89a%uFFFD%008%00%uFFFD%00%00%uFFF const invalidEquationHashTexrendrFirst50_2 = "GIF89a%01%00%01%00%uFFFD%00%00%uFFFD%uFFFD%uFFFD%0"; const invalidEquationHashTexrendrFirst50_3 = "GIF89ai%0A%uFFFD%01%uFFFD%00%00%uFFFD%uFFFD%uFFFD%"; // this is the No Expression Supplied error. Ignored for now. const invalidEquationHashTexrendrFirst50_4 = "%7FELF%01%01%01%00%00%00%00%00%00%00%00%00%02%00%0"; +// NOTE: this prefix is an HTML document where an image was expected. It originally caught +// Sciweavers answering an amsmath equation with its editor page, and it also matches the +// 404 page tex2img.php now serves unconditionally (see retiredRendererFamilies). const invalidEquationHashSciweaversFirst50 = "%0D%0A%09%3C%21DOCTYPE%20html%20PUBLIC%20%22-//W3C"; const defaultRendererPreference = "auto"; let activeRendererPreference: string | null = null; @@ -173,7 +205,11 @@ function normalizeRendererPreference(renderer: string | null | undefined) { case "texrendr": return "texrendr"; case "sciweavers": - return "sciweavers"; + // REASON: users who picked Sciweavers before it shut down still have it in their saved + // properties, and the option is gone from the sidebars. Migrate the stored value to + // Automatic here so those users render instead of failing on every equation; savePrefs + // writes the normalized value back, so the dead preference does not survive a render. + return defaultRendererPreference; default: return defaultRendererPreference; } @@ -185,9 +221,9 @@ function getPreferredRendererFamily(rendererPreference: string) { return "Codecogs"; case "texrendr": return "Texrendr"; - case "sciweavers": - return "Sciweavers"; default: + // NOTE: no "sciweavers" case - normalizeRendererPreference maps it to Automatic, so a + // retired family can never become the preferred family that getRendererOrder promotes. return ""; } } @@ -261,6 +297,9 @@ function getRendererOrder() { const fallbackOrder: number[] = []; for (let worked = 1; worked <= capableRenderers; ++worked) { + // REASON: retired services are still listed in getRenderer so old equations de-render, + // but attempting them here only costs two doomed fetches and a sleep per equation. + if (isRetiredRendererFamily(getRenderer(worked)[5])) continue; defaultOrder.push(worked); } diff --git a/Docs/Code.js b/Docs/Code.js index 15febde..5ec1e95 100644 --- a/Docs/Code.js +++ b/Docs/Code.js @@ -142,8 +142,9 @@ function replaceEquations(sizeRaw, delimiter, renderer) { // both because a Codecogs outage can hang UrlFetchApp long enough for // google.script.run to surface the generic "reload" error, and because it avoids // sending equation contents to external renderer APIs unless MathJax hard-fails; - // PR #61 wanted no server fallback at all, but keeping Texrendr/Sciweavers as the - // sidebar-invoked fallback preserves rendering when MathJax can't load). + // PR #61 wanted no server fallback at all, but keeping Texrendr as the + // sidebar-invoked fallback preserves rendering when MathJax can't load. Sciweavers used to + // back Texrendr up here; it was dropped when its image endpoint went away). var autoFallbackToClient = renderer === "auto"; if (clientRender || autoFallbackToClient) { console.log("MathJax render requested.", JSON.stringify({ sizeRaw: sizeRaw, delimiter: delimiter })); @@ -795,7 +796,7 @@ function buildClientRenderResponse(textElement, startElement, equationOriginal, } /** * Called by the client when MathJax rendering fails in auto mode. - * Tries remaining server-side renderers (Texrendr, Sciweavers) for the failed equations. + * Tries remaining server-side renderers (Texrendr) for the failed equations. * @public */ function clientRenderFailed(equations) { @@ -830,7 +831,10 @@ function clientRenderFailed(equations) { r: equation.options.r, g: equation.options.g, b: equation.options.b, - allowedServerFamilies: ["Texrendr", "Sciweavers", "Sciweavers_old", "Roger's renderer", "Number empire"] + // NOTE: Sciweavers/Sciweavers_old were dropped from this list when sciweavers.org + // retired its image endpoint (Common.retiredRendererFamilies). getRendererOrder already + // filters them out, so listing them here only suggested a fallback that cannot happen. + allowedServerFamilies: ["Texrendr", "Roger's renderer", "Number empire"] }); if (fallbackResult.worked > Common.capableRenderers || !fallbackResult.resp || !fallbackResult.renderer) { if (fallbackResult.authorizationError) { diff --git a/Docs/Code.ts b/Docs/Code.ts index 62ff7fd..c6b09ee 100644 --- a/Docs/Code.ts +++ b/Docs/Code.ts @@ -196,8 +196,9 @@ function replaceEquations(sizeRaw: string, delimiter: string, renderer: string = // both because a Codecogs outage can hang UrlFetchApp long enough for // google.script.run to surface the generic "reload" error, and because it avoids // sending equation contents to external renderer APIs unless MathJax hard-fails; - // PR #61 wanted no server fallback at all, but keeping Texrendr/Sciweavers as the - // sidebar-invoked fallback preserves rendering when MathJax can't load). + // PR #61 wanted no server fallback at all, but keeping Texrendr as the + // sidebar-invoked fallback preserves rendering when MathJax can't load. Sciweavers used to + // back Texrendr up here; it was dropped when its image endpoint went away). const autoFallbackToClient = renderer === "auto"; if (clientRender || autoFallbackToClient) { console.log("MathJax render requested.", JSON.stringify({ sizeRaw, delimiter })); @@ -941,7 +942,7 @@ function buildClientRenderResponse( /** * Called by the client when MathJax rendering fails in auto mode. - * Tries remaining server-side renderers (Texrendr, Sciweavers) for the failed equations. + * Tries remaining server-side renderers (Texrendr) for the failed equations. * @public */ function clientRenderFailed(equations: { options: AutoLatexCommon.ClientRenderOptions }[]) { @@ -980,7 +981,10 @@ function clientRenderFailed(equations: { options: AutoLatexCommon.ClientRenderOp r: equation.options.r, g: equation.options.g, b: equation.options.b, - allowedServerFamilies: ["Texrendr", "Sciweavers", "Sciweavers_old", "Roger's renderer", "Number empire"] + // NOTE: Sciweavers/Sciweavers_old were dropped from this list when sciweavers.org + // retired its image endpoint (Common.retiredRendererFamilies). getRendererOrder already + // filters them out, so listing them here only suggested a fallback that cannot happen. + allowedServerFamilies: ["Texrendr", "Roger's renderer", "Number empire"] }); if (fallbackResult.worked > Common.capableRenderers || !fallbackResult.resp || !fallbackResult.renderer) { diff --git a/Docs/Sidebar.html b/Docs/Sidebar.html index 3541164..090c9ae 100644 --- a/Docs/Sidebar.html +++ b/Docs/Sidebar.html @@ -78,7 +78,6 @@ - diff --git a/Docs/Sidebar.ts b/Docs/Sidebar.ts index f4b2d32..ddbd066 100644 --- a/Docs/Sidebar.ts +++ b/Docs/Sidebar.ts @@ -318,8 +318,12 @@ function loadPreferences(choicePrefs: {size: string, delim: string, renderer: st $('#delimit').val(choicePrefs.delim); // REASON: Older users may have Codecogs saved from when it was the practical default. // Open the sidebar on Automatic so Codecogs outages don't keep affecting them. - const rendererPreference = choicePrefs.renderer === "codecogs" ? "auto" : choicePrefs.renderer; - const savedRenderer = ["auto", "mathjax", "texrendr", "sciweavers"].includes(rendererPreference) ? rendererPreference : "auto"; + // Sciweavers gets the same treatment for a harder reason: it shut down its image endpoint, + // the option no longer exists in the selector, and leaving the saved value here would show + // an empty renderer box and send a dead choice back to the server. + const retiredOrDeprioritized = ["codecogs", "sciweavers"]; + const rendererPreference = retiredOrDeprioritized.includes(choicePrefs.renderer) ? "auto" : choicePrefs.renderer; + const savedRenderer = ["auto", "mathjax", "texrendr"].includes(rendererPreference) ? rendererPreference : "auto"; $('#renderer').val(savedRenderer); enableSidebarButtons(); setRenderButtonState(false); diff --git a/Sheets/Sidebar.html b/Sheets/Sidebar.html index db3d5f4..fc644c4 100644 --- a/Sheets/Sidebar.html +++ b/Sheets/Sidebar.html @@ -65,7 +65,6 @@ - diff --git a/Sheets/Sidebar.ts b/Sheets/Sidebar.ts index 3eba179..61d9182 100644 --- a/Sheets/Sidebar.ts +++ b/Sheets/Sidebar.ts @@ -146,8 +146,12 @@ function loadPreferences(choicePrefs: { size: string; delim: string; renderer: s $('#delimit').val(choicePrefs.delim); // REASON: Older users may have Codecogs saved from when it was the practical default. // Open the sidebar on Automatic so Codecogs outages don't keep affecting them. - const rendererPreference = choicePrefs.renderer === "codecogs" ? "auto" : choicePrefs.renderer; - const savedRenderer = ["auto", "mathjax", "texrendr", "sciweavers"].includes(rendererPreference) ? rendererPreference : "auto"; + // Sciweavers gets the same treatment for a harder reason: it shut down its image endpoint, + // the option no longer exists in the selector, and leaving the saved value here would show + // an empty renderer box and send a dead choice back to the server. + const retiredOrDeprioritized = ["codecogs", "sciweavers"]; + const rendererPreference = retiredOrDeprioritized.includes(choicePrefs.renderer) ? "auto" : choicePrefs.renderer; + const savedRenderer = ["auto", "mathjax", "texrendr"].includes(rendererPreference) ? rendererPreference : "auto"; $('#renderer').val(savedRenderer); $('#insert-text').prop("disabled", false); $('#edit-text').prop("disabled", false); diff --git a/Slides/Sidebar.html b/Slides/Sidebar.html index 7e3ab31..29294ad 100644 --- a/Slides/Sidebar.html +++ b/Slides/Sidebar.html @@ -78,7 +78,6 @@ - diff --git a/Slides/Sidebar.ts b/Slides/Sidebar.ts index 435c3f7..d836d9b 100644 --- a/Slides/Sidebar.ts +++ b/Slides/Sidebar.ts @@ -256,8 +256,12 @@ function loadPreferences(choicePrefs: {size: string, delim: string, renderer: st $('#delimit').val(choicePrefs.delim); // REASON: Older users may have Codecogs saved from when it was the practical default. // Open the sidebar on Automatic so Codecogs outages don't keep affecting them. - const rendererPreference = choicePrefs.renderer === "codecogs" ? "auto" : choicePrefs.renderer; - const savedRenderer = ["auto", "mathjax", "texrendr", "sciweavers"].includes(rendererPreference) ? rendererPreference : "auto"; + // Sciweavers gets the same treatment for a harder reason: it shut down its image endpoint, + // the option no longer exists in the selector, and leaving the saved value here would show + // an empty renderer box and send a dead choice back to the server. + const retiredOrDeprioritized = ["codecogs", "sciweavers"]; + const rendererPreference = retiredOrDeprioritized.includes(choicePrefs.renderer) ? "auto" : choicePrefs.renderer; + const savedRenderer = ["auto", "mathjax", "texrendr"].includes(rendererPreference) ? rendererPreference : "auto"; $('#renderer').val(savedRenderer); $('#insert-text').prop("disabled", false); $('#edit-text').prop("disabled", false); diff --git a/tests/README.md b/tests/README.md index 6274484..419abd8 100644 --- a/tests/README.md +++ b/tests/README.md @@ -92,9 +92,10 @@ because it returns three SVG fragments instead of one. The fixed source passes. npm run test:render-services ``` -This optional live smoke suite covers the **60 external-renderer combinations** -with the two generic equations. Identical URLs across apps/delimiters reuse the -same response: 12 distinct requests instead of 192 duplicate image requests. +This optional live smoke suite covers **every external-renderer combination the +sidebars still offer** (40 since Sciweavers was retired) with the two generic +equations. Identical URLs across apps/delimiters reuse the same response: 8 +distinct requests instead of 160 duplicate image requests. Requests have deadlines and three workers. It saves returned images, an Auto/Inline screenshot, and explicit per-combination results under `test-results/render-services/`. It exits nonzero for unavailable services and @@ -107,3 +108,10 @@ On 2026-09-17, Codecogs and Texrendr returned complete sample equations in both size modes; Sciweavers returned **HTTP 404** for all four distinct sample requests. This external-service failure is independent of the MathJax Inline fix. See [review screenshots](evidence/pr71/README.md). + +That 404 was not transient. sciweavers.org is still up, but it retired +`tex2img.php` — the GET image endpoint every Sciweavers renderer entry was built +on — so the renderer was removed from the sidebars and from the render order, +while staying available for de-rendering old equations. The probe has run clean +since: on 2026-09-18, 8 distinct requests, 0 unavailable. See +[what was verified](evidence/sciweavers-retired/README.md). diff --git a/tests/browser/server-renderers.js b/tests/browser/server-renderers.js index 54078e8..2432e31 100644 --- a/tests/browser/server-renderers.js +++ b/tests/browser/server-renderers.js @@ -63,7 +63,10 @@ async function main() { })); const gallery = await browser.newPage({ viewport: { width: 1280, height: 900 } }); const escapeHtml = s => s.replaceAll('&', '&').replaceAll('<', '<').replaceAll('>', '>'); - const rows = ['codecogs', 'texrendr', 'sciweavers'].flatMap(renderer => samples.map(sample => { + // Derived from the shipped selector via serverCases, so retiring a renderer removes its row + // instead of leaving a hard-coded name that crashes on a missing result. + const galleryRenderers = [...new Set(serverCases.map(c => c.renderer))]; + const rows = galleryRenderers.flatMap(renderer => samples.map(sample => { const cells = ['smart', 'inline'].map(mode => { const result = [...results.values()].find(r => r.renderer === renderer && r.mode === mode && r.sample === sample); if (!result.filename) return `${escapeHtml(result.error)}`; diff --git a/tests/evidence/pr71/README.md b/tests/evidence/pr71/README.md index e193ef1..f4e3e71 100644 --- a/tests/evidence/pr71/README.md +++ b/tests/evidence/pr71/README.md @@ -33,5 +33,8 @@ samples. Repeated URLs share responses, yielding 12 distinct service requests. Codecogs and Texrendr returned the complete equations shown above. Sciweavers returned **HTTP 404** in both modes for both samples; the probe exits nonzero. No claim is made that Sciweavers works or that these live results are permanent. +(Follow-up: that 404 turned out to be permanent — sciweavers.org retired +`tex2img.php` while keeping the rest of the site up. The renderer has since been +removed from the sidebars; see [sciweavers-retired](../sciweavers-retired/README.md).) This checks the preferred service endpoint; fallback after an outage and Google image insertion are outside this smoke test. diff --git a/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/README.md b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c618b93 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,56 @@ +# Sciweavers: what is actually broken + +Captured 2026-09-18, from this branch. This directory answers a specific +objection to PR #71's live-probe result — "Sciweavers returns HTTP 404, but the +website clearly still loads." Both halves of that are true. They are about +different things. + +## sciweavers.org is up + +![sciweavers.org editor loads](sciweavers-site-loads.png) + +`https://www.sciweavers.org/free-online-latex-equation-editor` returns HTTP 200 +and its Tex2Img editor works. Nothing here suggests the site is down. + +## The endpoint AutoLatex uses is gone + +![tex2img.php returns 404](sciweavers-tex2img-404.png) + +Every Sciweavers entry in `Common.getRenderer` is built on `tex2img.php`, a GET +URL that returns the image directly. That file now returns the site's own 404 +page. Checked 2026-09-18: + +| Variation tried | Result | +| --- | --- | +| `https://www.sciweavers.org/tex2img.php?bc=…&eq=…` (our URL) | 404 | +| `…?eq=…&bc=…` (the order sciweavers' own editor emits) | 404 | +| `http://` (301s to `https://`), apex `sciweavers.org` | 404 | +| curl, Chrome, Googlebot and Apps-Script-shaped user agents | 404 | +| With a session cookie and a Referer from the editor page | 404 | +| `/tex2img.php` with no query string at all | 404 | +| Real Chrome, screenshot above | 404 | + +The site's working path is now a POST to `/process_form_tex2img`, which writes a +one-off image to `/upload/Tex2Img_/render.png`. Two identical submits 3 +seconds apart returned `Tex2Img_1789770006` and `Tex2Img_1789770009`: the id is +per-request and carries none of the LaTeX. AutoLatex de-renders an equation by +reading its source back out of the image URL, so a URL like that cannot replace +`tex2img.php` even though it produces a correct image. + +Their editor still advertises a `tex2img.php` link as the embed URL after a +successful render. That link 404s too, which is most likely how this went +unnoticed on their end. + +## After retiring the family + +![Live external renderer responses](external-auto-inline.png) + +`npm run test:render-services` on this branch: **40 server settings, 8 distinct +live requests, 0 unavailable**, exit 0. On `master` the same probe made 12 +requests and 4 failed. Nothing about Codecogs or Texrendr changed; the four dead +Sciweavers requests are simply no longer made, because the renderer is no longer +offered. `results.json` is the full run record. + +Sciweavers indices 5, 7, 8 and 11 remain reachable through `getRenderer` and +`capableDerenderers`, so equations rendered before the shutdown still de-render — +`tests/retired-renderers.test.js` pins both halves of that. diff --git a/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/external-auto-inline.png b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/external-auto-inline.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6ac9d6c Binary files /dev/null and b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/external-auto-inline.png differ diff --git a/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/results.json b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/results.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..85e6172 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/results.json @@ -0,0 +1,1145 @@ +{ + "checkedAt": "2026-09-18T22:33:37.587Z", + "matrixCases": 40, + "uniqueRequests": 8, + "results": [ + { + "urls": [ + "https://www.codecogs.com/eqnedit.php?latex=%5Cdpi%7B900%7D%5Cinline%20%7B%5Ccolor%5BRGB%5D%7B0%2C0%2C0%7D1%2B1%3D2%7D", + "https://latex.codecogs.com/png.latex?%5Cdpi%7B900%7D%5Cinline%20%7B%5Ccolor%5BRGB%5D%7B0%2C0%2C0%7D1%2B1%3D2%7D" + ], + "renderer": "codecogs", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "warmup": 200, + "status": "image-decoded", + "width": 535, + "height": 102, + "filename": "codecogs-inline-0.png" + }, + { + "urls": [ + "https://www.codecogs.com/eqnedit.php?latex=%5Cdpi%7B900%7D%7B%5Ccolor%5BRGB%5D%7B0%2C0%2C0%7D1%2B1%3D2%7D", + "https://latex.codecogs.com/png.latex?%5Cdpi%7B900%7D%7B%5Ccolor%5BRGB%5D%7B0%2C0%2C0%7D1%2B1%3D2%7D" + ], + "renderer": "codecogs", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "warmup": 200, + "status": "image-decoded", + "width": 576, + "height": 111, + "filename": "codecogs-smart-0.png" + }, + { + "urls": [ + "https://www.codecogs.com/eqnedit.php?latex=%5Cdpi%7B900%7D%7B%5Ccolor%5BRGB%5D%7B0%2C0%2C0%7D%5Cfrac%7B1%2B1%7D%7B2%7D%3D1%7D", + "https://latex.codecogs.com/png.latex?%5Cdpi%7B900%7D%7B%5Ccolor%5BRGB%5D%7B0%2C0%2C0%7D%5Cfrac%7B1%2B1%7D%7B2%7D%3D1%7D" + ], + "renderer": "codecogs", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "warmup": 200, + "status": "image-decoded", + "width": 600, + "height": 303, + "filename": "codecogs-smart-1.png" + }, + { + "urls": [ + "https://www.codecogs.com/eqnedit.php?latex=%5Cdpi%7B900%7D%5Cinline%20%7B%5Ccolor%5BRGB%5D%7B0%2C0%2C0%7D%5Cfrac%7B1%2B1%7D%7B2%7D%3D1%7D", + "https://latex.codecogs.com/png.latex?%5Cdpi%7B900%7D%5Cinline%20%7B%5Ccolor%5BRGB%5D%7B0%2C0%2C0%7D%5Cfrac%7B1%2B1%7D%7B2%7D%3D1%7D" + ], + "renderer": "codecogs", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "warmup": 200, + "status": "image-decoded", + "width": 443, + "height": 167, + "filename": "codecogs-inline-1.png" + }, + { + "urls": [ + "http://www.texrendr.com/?eqn=%7B%5Cfrac%7B1%2B1%7D%7B2%7D%3D1%7D", + "http://texrendr.com/cgi-bin/mimetex?%5CHuge%20%7B%5Cfrac%7B1%2B1%7D%7B2%7D%3D1%7D" + ], + "renderer": "texrendr", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "warmup": 200, + "status": "image-decoded", + "width": 160, + "height": 69, + "filename": "texrendr-smart-1.gif" + }, + { + "urls": [ + "http://www.texrendr.com/?eqn=%7B1%2B1%3D2%7D", + "http://texrendr.com/cgi-bin/mimetex?%5CHuge%20%7B1%2B1%3D2%7D" + ], + "renderer": "texrendr", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "warmup": 200, + "status": "image-decoded", + "width": 192, + "height": 46, + "filename": "texrendr-smart-0.gif" + }, + { + "urls": [ + "http://www.texrendr.com/?eqn=%5Ctextstyle%20%7B1%2B1%3D2%7D", + "http://texrendr.com/cgi-bin/mimetex?%5CHuge%20%5Ctextstyle%20%7B1%2B1%3D2%7D" + ], + "renderer": "texrendr", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "warmup": 200, + "status": "image-decoded", + "width": 192, + "height": 46, + "filename": "texrendr-inline-0.gif" + }, + { + "urls": [ + "http://www.texrendr.com/?eqn=%5Ctextstyle%20%7B%5Cfrac%7B1%2B1%7D%7B2%7D%3D1%7D", + "http://texrendr.com/cgi-bin/mimetex?%5CHuge%20%5Ctextstyle%20%7B%5Cfrac%7B1%2B1%7D%7B2%7D%3D1%7D" + ], + "renderer": "texrendr", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "warmup": 200, + "status": "image-decoded", + "width": 160, + "height": 69, + "filename": "texrendr-inline-1.gif" + } + ], + "checks": [ + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Docs", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "codecogs", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "all", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "\\[", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "(", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "smart", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "1+1=2", + "status": "image-decoded" + }, + { + "app": "Slides", + "renderer": "texrendr", + "delimiter": "$", + "mode": "inline", + "sample": "\\frac{1+1}{2}=1", + "status": "image-decoded" + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/sciweavers-site-loads.png b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/sciweavers-site-loads.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8c1712b Binary files /dev/null and b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/sciweavers-site-loads.png differ diff --git a/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/sciweavers-tex2img-404.png b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/sciweavers-tex2img-404.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000..dee21ba Binary files /dev/null and b/tests/evidence/sciweavers-retired/sciweavers-tex2img-404.png differ diff --git a/tests/helpers/render-matrix.js b/tests/helpers/render-matrix.js index ed58049..8b00c2d 100644 --- a/tests/helpers/render-matrix.js +++ b/tests/helpers/render-matrix.js @@ -38,7 +38,8 @@ function commonHarness() { }); vm.runInContext(commonSource, common, { filename: 'Common.matrix.js' }); // Apps Script libraries expose top-level values; VM lexical consts need an adapter. - for (const name of ['capableRenderers', 'rendererIds', 'invalidEquationHashCodecogsFirst50']) { + for (const name of ['capableRenderers', 'capableDerenderers', 'retiredRendererFamilies', + 'rendererIds', 'invalidEquationHashCodecogsFirst50']) { common[name] = vm.runInContext(name, common); } const render = common.renderEquation; @@ -149,4 +150,4 @@ function runCase({ app, renderer, delimiter, mode }, equation = '1+1=2') { } return { ...harness, payloads, source }; } -module.exports = { cases, runCase, options, modes, renderers, delimiters }; +module.exports = { cases, runCase, options, modes, renderers, delimiters, commonHarness }; diff --git a/tests/render-settings-matrix.test.js b/tests/render-settings-matrix.test.js index be2ebba..7bbaf24 100644 --- a/tests/render-settings-matrix.test.js +++ b/tests/render-settings-matrix.test.js @@ -3,7 +3,10 @@ const test = require('node:test'); const { cases, runCase, options, modes, renderers, delimiters } = require('./helpers/render-matrix'); test('matrix covers every shipped renderer and delimiter with Auto/Inline sizes', () => { - assert.equal(cases.length, 100); + // NOTE: derived, not a literal. The count moved 100 -> 80 when Sciweavers was retired, and a + // hard-coded total only tells you the number changed, never which selector changed. + assert.equal(cases.length, 2 * renderers.length * delimiters.length * modes.length); + assert.ok(renderers.length >= 4 && delimiters.length >= 5, 'selectors still cover the shipped options'); for (const app of ['Docs', 'Slides']) { assert.deepEqual(options(app, 'renderer'), renderers); assert.deepEqual(options(app, 'delimit'), delimiters); diff --git a/tests/retired-renderers.test.js b/tests/retired-renderers.test.js new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2cdfcbe --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/retired-renderers.test.js @@ -0,0 +1,89 @@ +const assert = require('node:assert/strict'); +const fs = require('node:fs'); +const path = require('node:path'); +const test = require('node:test'); +const { commonHarness, options } = require('./helpers/render-matrix'); +const root = path.join(__dirname, '..'); + +// sciweavers.org retired tex2img.php, the GET endpoint all four Sciweavers renderer entries +// are built on. The site still loads and its editor still renders, which is exactly why this +// is easy to "fix" back to broken: someone checks the homepage, sees it up, and re-enables the +// renderer. These tests pin the two halves of the decision separately - dead for rendering, +// alive for de-rendering - so neither half can be undone by accident. +const RETIRED_HOSTS = ['sciweavers.org']; +const LEGACY_SCIWEAVERS_INDICES = [5, 7, 8, 11]; +const stubApp = { newlineCharacter: '\n' }; + +function renderedUrls(prefs) { + const harness = commonHarness(); + if (prefs) harness.common.savePrefs('smart', '$$', prefs); + const delim = harness.common.getDelimiters('$$'); + harness.common.renderEquation('x%5E2', { ...harness.common.getDefaultRenderOptions(delim), delim }); + return harness.urls; +} + +test('retired renderer families are excluded from the render order', () => { + const { common } = commonHarness(); + const order = common.getRendererOrder(); + for (const worked of order) { + assert.ok(!common.isRetiredRendererFamily(common.getRenderer(worked)[5]), + `renderer ${worked} (${common.getRenderer(worked)[5]}) must not be attempted for rendering`); + } + // NOTE: Array.from, because these arrays are built inside the vm realm and deepStrictEqual + // compares prototypes - a bare deepEqual against a host-realm literal fails on identical data. + assert.deepEqual(Array.from(order), [1, 2, 3, 4, 6], 'Codecogs and Texrendr entries only'); + assert.deepEqual(Array.from(common.retiredRendererFamilies), ['Sciweavers', 'Sciweavers_old']); +}); + +test('rendering never requests a retired host', () => { + for (const prefs of [undefined, 'auto', 'codecogs', 'texrendr', 'sciweavers']) { + const harness = commonHarness(); + if (prefs) harness.common.savePrefs('smart', '$$', prefs); + // Every URL the whole fallback chain could reach, not just the first renderer that + // answers. The happy path stops at Codecogs, so a live render alone would pass even if + // Sciweavers were still queued up behind it. + const reachable = Array.from(harness.common.getRendererOrder()) + .flatMap(worked => [harness.common.getRenderer(worked)[1], harness.common.getRenderer(worked)[2]]); + assert.ok(reachable.length > 0, `renderer=${prefs} must still have live renderers`); + for (const url of reachable.concat(renderedUrls(prefs))) { + for (const host of RETIRED_HOSTS) { + assert.ok(!url.includes(host), `renderer=${prefs} could request ${host}: ${url}`); + } + } + } +}); + +test('a saved Sciweavers preference is migrated to Automatic instead of failing', () => { + const harness = commonHarness(); + harness.common.savePrefs('smart', '$$', 'sciweavers'); + // The dead value must not survive the round trip, or the next session reads it back. + assert.equal(harness.prefs.renderer, 'auto'); + assert.equal(harness.common.getPreferredRenderer(), 'auto'); + assert.equal(harness.common.getPreferredRendererFamily('sciweavers'), '', + 'a retired family must never become the prioritized family'); +}); + +test('equations rendered before the shutdown still de-render', () => { + const { common } = commonHarness(); + for (const worked of LEGACY_SCIWEAVERS_INDICES) { + const renderer = common.getRenderer(worked); + assert.ok(common.isRetiredRendererFamily(renderer[5]), `renderer ${worked} is a retired family`); + // %0 is the trailing delimiter marker a rendered equation link carries. + const result = common.derenderEquation(`${renderer[2]}x%5E2%2B1%0`, stubApp); + assert.equal(result.origEq, 'x^2+1', `renderer ${worked} must stay de-renderable`); + } + assert.ok(LEGACY_SCIWEAVERS_INDICES.every(worked => worked <= common.capableDerenderers)); +}); + +test('no sidebar offers a retired renderer', () => { + for (const app of ['Docs', 'Slides', 'Sheets']) { + const renderers = options(app, 'renderer'); + assert.deepEqual(renderers.filter(r => r === 'sciweavers'), [], `${app} renderer selector`); + assert.ok(renderers.includes('auto') && renderers.includes('texrendr'), `${app} keeps live renderers`); + const sidebar = fs.readFileSync(path.join(root, app, 'Sidebar.ts'), 'utf8'); + // The selector no longer has a sciweavers