@@ -1,3 +1,11 @@
+## 2026-07-14 — E-RUNG-CONTENT-LADDER-1 — the rung-content ladder ruled; persona-36 demarcated as a separate storyline (corrects E-STYLE-FAMILY-VS-RUNBOOK-1's "runbook" label)
+
+**Status:** RULED (operator, 2026-07-14). Canonical text: `.claude/v3/knowledge/persona-vs-rung-ladder.md` (linked from CLAUDE.md § V3 SUBSTRATE).
+**The ladder (content reading of the 0–9 rungs, from the ladybug-rs → thinking-engine lineage):** rung 0–1 = observation; rung 2 = the 144 thinking atoms (12 verb families × 12 tenses — `sigma_rosetta.rs` + `grammar/verb_table.rs`); rung 3 = the **34 NARS reasoning tactics** = THE runbooks (`lance_graph_contract::recipes::RECIPES [Recipe; 34]`, primitives in `ndarray::hpc::styles`); rung 4 = `StyleFamily`-12 thinking macros, autopoiesis through the triangle frozen × learned × exploration. The shipped `RungLevel` carries only the Pearl causal-depth reading — the content wiring (O1) and the rung-4→rung-3 edge (O2, the TRUE default_runbook semantics) are OPEN.
+**The demarcation:** the adjective-36 in `contract::thinking` (Empathetic/Warm/Blunt/Poetic…) is the **persona-modeling storyline** — off-ladder, unwired by design, NOT rung 3, NOT "literal NARS runbooks." `E-STYLE-FAMILY-VS-RUNBOOK-1`'s label is corrected through this entry (append-only; the original stands as written): `default_runbook()` bridges rung-4 macros to the persona vocabulary while wearing the rung-3 tactics' name.
+**Probe results banked with the ruling (2026-07-14 session):** p64-bridge `STYLES[ord % 12]` = DORMANT (zero external callers; TD-STYLE-TABLE-RESIDUE item 3 flipped below); `UNIFIED_STYLES` = TETHERED-not-collapsed (parity test; answers the MODULE-TABLE census open question).
+**Cross-ref:** persona-vs-rung-ladder.md (O1–O6 open items), E-FIVE-STYLE-TABLES-1, E-THINKING-STYLES-ARE-CLASSES-1 (FUTURE-DESIGN), MODULE-TABLE ADDENDUM 2026-07-10 (2).
+
 ## 2026-07-13 — E-V3-GRACE-WIDE-CARVINGS-1 — V1 migration gets a discouraged waiting room, not a crash (operator ruling)
 
 **Status:** RULED (operator, 2026-07-13). Recorded in `.claude/v3/soa_layout/le-contract.md` §3a.
 
@@ -1,5 +1,24 @@
 # Technical Debt Log — Open + Paid (double-entry, append-only)
 
+## TD-STYLE-TABLE-RESIDUE item 3 — PROBED, downgraded (2026-07-14)
+
+The "does any caller feed StyleFamily ordinals into p64-bridge
+`STYLES[ord % 12]`" probe ran (this session): **DORMANT — no live bug.**
+`STYLES` is reachable only via `style_by_ordinal`/`style_by_name`/
+`all_styles`; repo-wide, the only `style_by_ordinal` caller is
+p64-bridge's own 0..12 test loop; the three Cargo dependents
+(driver/planner/osint) import only `cognitive_shader::CognitiveShader`,
+never the styles surface; p64-bridge never imports `StyleFamily`.
+Residual hazard is **latent-API only**: `style_by_ordinal(family as
+usize)` by a future caller would scramble the predicate chain silently.
+Free hardening queued (zero external callers = zero breakage):
+`#[deprecated]` on `style_by_ordinal` steering to by-name conversion.
+Companion answer for the MODULE-TABLE census: driver `UNIFIED_STYLES`
+was TETHERED (names/ordinals/len parity test), not collapsed — a
+legitimate close of that open question. Ruling context:
+`E-RUNG-CONTENT-LADDER-1`; demarcation doc:
+`.claude/v3/knowledge/persona-vs-rung-ladder.md`.
+
 ## TD-MESSAGE-RESIDUE (2026-07-10, operator-ruled LEAVE-AS-IS)
 
 Per E-NOBODY-WAITS-1: no messages, no actors anywhere — ractor is only
 
@@ -0,0 +1,118 @@
+# Persona modeling vs the rung-content ladder — the demarcation
+
+> READ BY: v3-template-smith, truth-architect, integration-lead,
+> perspective-weaver (persona side), any session touching StyleFamily,
+> ThinkingStyle, runbooks, recipes, the 144 verbs, RungLevel semantics,
+> or persona modeling. Operator-ruled 2026-07-14 (this session, chat
+> transcript); board anchor: `E-RUNG-CONTENT-LADDER-1` in
+> `.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md`.
+
+## Why this file exists
+
+The workspace carried FOUR similar-looking spaces that sessions kept
+conflating — three 12-spaces and a 36-space — and D-TSC-1 (`1a11038`)
+canonized one conflation into the board ("36 = literal NARS runbooks").
+The operator separated them. This file is the demarcation, so no future
+session re-merges them.
+
+## The rung-content ladder (operator ruling, 2026-07-14)
+
+The 0–9 rung ladder came from ladybug-rs thinking and migrated to
+`crates/thinking-engine`. Its CONTENT reading — what kind of thinking
+object occupies each rung — is:
+
+| Rung | Occupant | Where it lives (today) |
+|---|---|---|
+| 0–1 | **Observation** | Pearl L1 side of `contract::cognitive_shader::RungLevel` |
+| 2 | **Thinking atoms** — the 12×12 = 144 universal-grammar verbs (12 verb families × 12 tenses) | `cognitive-shader-driver/src/sigma_rosetta.rs` (`VERB_ROOTS`/`VERB_TENSES`, 64 glyphs × 144 verbs = 9,216 atoms) + `contract/src/grammar/verb_table.rs` (`VerbRoleTable [[SlotPrior;12];12]`, TEKAMOLO priors) |
+| 3 | **The 34 NARS reasoning tactics** (induction, abduction, deduction, extrapolation, counterfactual, …) — THE runbooks, in the literal sense: executable inference recipes | Catalogue spine: `lance_graph_contract::recipes` (`RECIPES: [Recipe; 34]`, Stakelum/ladybug numbering, Sun et al. 2025 tiers, SPO-2³ coverage). Substrate primitives: `ndarray::hpc::styles` (29/34 modules shipped, `fn(Base17, NarsTruth) → result`) — most of it migrated toward lance-graph via the recipes spine |
+| 4 | **Thinking macros / styles** = `StyleFamily` (12) — Autopoiesis through the triangle **frozen × learned × exploration** (frozen = compiled templates / StepMask; learned = NARS revision / awareness; exploration = MUL / exploratory machinery) | `lance_graph_contract::style_family` |
+
+The code's shipped `RungLevel` carries the **Pearl causal-depth**
+reading (0–2 observe / 3–5 intervene / 6–9 counterfactual) plus the
+homeostatic elevation policy. That coexists with — but does NOT
+implement — the content ladder above. The rung↔content wiring is the
+half-hearted part of the 0–9 rewiring and is OPEN (see below).
+
+## Persona modeling — a SEPARATE storyline (the demarcation)
+
+The **36 adjective styles** in `lance_graph_contract::thinking`
+(Empathetic, Warm, Blunt, Frank, Poetic, … — 36 variants, 6 clusters,
+τ addresses, `FieldModulation`) are the **persona-modeling storyline**:
+
+- They are **NOT rung 3.** They are not reasoning moves.
+- They are **NOT the NARS runbooks.** The runbooks are the 34 recipes
+  (rung 3, above).
+- They are **not wired** into the rung ladder, the shader dispatch, or
+  the planner execution paths today ("carried and displayed, not acted
+  on" — the audited finding). That is expected, not a defect: persona
+  modeling is future work with its own storyline (perspective-weaver /
+  persona.rs territory), and the adjective vocabulary is its asset.
+- They happen to be 12-groupable (`ThinkingStyle::family()` → 36→12,
+  distribution 1..6 per family — NOT 3-per-family, so they are also
+  not the rung-4 triangle decomposition).
+
+**What made the conflation easy:** persona-36 is 12-groupable, the
+word "style" appears in all four spaces, and D-TSC-1's board ruling
+`E-STYLE-FAMILY-VS-RUNBOOK-1` labeled the persona-36 "literal NARS
+runbooks seeding the rung ladder." That label is CORRECTED by this
+demarcation: `StyleFamily::default_runbook()` bridges rung-4 macros to
+the *persona vocabulary*, while wearing the name of the *rung-3
+tactics*. The mapping pair (`family()`/`default_runbook()`) is
+mechanically sound as a 12↔36 bridge WITHIN the persona storyline; only
+its "runbook" naming and the board label cross storylines.
+
+## The four spaces, one line each (anti-conflation card)
+
+1. `StyleFamily` (12) — rung-4 thinking macros, orchestration dispatch. Canonical, deduped, frozen ordinals (driver order, Deliberate=0).
+2. `recipes::RECIPES` (34) — rung-3 NARS reasoning tactics. THE runbooks. Catalogue in contract; primitives in ndarray `hpc/styles`.
+3. 144 verbs (12×12) — rung-2 thinking atoms, the unified predicate surface (`sigma_rosetta` + `verb_table`). Computing, test-pinned.
+4. persona-36 adjectives — persona-modeling storyline. Off-ladder, unwired, future work. Keep out of rung vocabulary.
+
+## OPEN / CURRENT (the live items this demarcation leaves)
+
+- **O1 — rung↔content wiring absent.** `RungLevel` knows Pearl depth,
+  not content occupants. No rung references `sigma_rosetta`,
+  `verb_table`, `recipes`, or `StyleFamily`. The content ladder exists
+  only as this ruling.
+- **O2 — the rung-4→rung-3 edge (`StyleFamily` → recipe selection)
+  does not exist.** A macro choosing which of the 34 tactics fire is
+  the true "default_runbook" semantics; today's `default_runbook()`
+  points at the persona vocabulary instead. Eventual fix: retarget (or
+  twin) the mapping at `recipes::Recipe`, and rename the persona bridge
+  honestly (e.g. `default_persona()`).
+- **O3 — persona storyline unwired by design.** Future persona work
+  picks up the adjective-36 + `thinking-engine/persona.rs`; until then
+  no rung/dispatch code should consume it as if it were reasoning.
+- **O4 — D-TSC-1 residue (from the cross-session audit):**
+  `PlannerStyleExt` re-exported at `thinking::` but still NOT at
+  `api::` (the q2 E0599 path); the `#[deprecated]` note on the planner
+  alias points at the wrong space ("36-runbook space") and needs the
+  corrected wording; the two lab-only name→ordinal tables (`wire.rs`,
+  `auto_style.rs`) remain untethered.
+- **O5 — probe results to ledger (run 2026-07-14, this session):**
+  p64-bridge `STYLES[ord % 12]` is DORMANT (zero external callers;
+  dependents import only `CognitiveShader`) — latent-API hazard only;
+  free hardening = `#[deprecated]` on `style_by_ordinal` steering to
+  by-name. `UNIFIED_STYLES` (driver `engine_bridge.rs`) was
+  TETHERED-not-collapsed by D-TSC-1 (names/ordinals/len parity test) —
+  answers the MODULE-TABLE census's open question.
+- **O6 — triangle structure unbuilt.** Rung 4's autopoiesis triangle
+  (frozen × learned × exploration) has its three poles in separate
+  subsystems (StepMask/templates, NARS awareness, MUL) but no composed
+  macro object. `FUTURE-DESIGN.md` E-THINKING-STYLES-ARE-CLASSES-1
+  ("style = class: StepMask × WideFieldMask + rung set + KausalSpec")
+  is the landing zone.
+
+## Cross-refs
+
+- `.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md` — `E-RUNG-CONTENT-LADDER-1` (this
+  ruling), `E-STYLE-FAMILY-VS-RUNBOOK-1` (carries the corrected label
+  via this file), `E-FIVE-STYLE-TABLES-1` (the dedup finding).
+- `.claude/v3/MODULE-TABLE.md` ADDENDUM 2026-07-10 (2) — the
+  ancestry-pipeline census rows for `verb_table.rs`, `sigma_rosetta.rs`,
+  p64-bridge `StyleParams`, `UNIFIED_STYLES`, `auto_style.rs`.
+- `.claude/v3/FUTURE-DESIGN.md` — E-THINKING-STYLES-ARE-CLASSES-1.
+- `lance_graph_contract::recipes` module doc — the 34-tactic spec
+  provenance (ladybug `34_TACTICS_x_REASONING_LADDER`; ladybug is spec
+  source, never dependency — ada-rewrite-charter D0).
@@ -38,6 +38,15 @@ fleet-shipped 2026-07-02):
 - `.claude/v3/MODULE-TABLE.md` — per-file census of core / contract / planner
 - `.claude/v3/soa_layout/` — LE contract, tenant lanes, consumer map, routing
 - `.claude/v3/knowledge/` — V3 doctrine docs (`READ BY:` headers)
+- `.claude/v3/knowledge/persona-vs-rung-ladder.md` — MANDATORY before
+  touching StyleFamily / ThinkingStyle / runbooks / recipes / the 144
+  verbs / RungLevel semantics / persona modeling: the operator-ruled
+  rung-content ladder (0–1 observation, 2 = 144 verb atoms, 3 = the 34
+  NARS tactic recipes = THE runbooks, 4 = StyleFamily macros +
+  autopoiesis triangle) and the demarcation that the adjective-36 in
+  `contract::thinking` is the SEPARATE, unwired persona-modeling
+  storyline — never rung 3, never "NARS runbooks" (corrects
+  E-STYLE-FAMILY-VS-RUNBOOK-1's label). Open items O1–O6 tracked there.
 - `.claude/v3/agents/BOOT.md` — the four V3 cards (`v3-mailbox-warden`,
   `v3-envelope-auditor`, `v3-kanban-executor-engineer`, `v3-template-smith`)
 - `.claude/v3/knowledge/sonnet-worker-guardrails.md` — MANDATORY in every